Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: World: Europe
Front Page 
World 
Africa 
Americas 
Asia-Pacific 
Europe 
Middle East 
South Asia 
-----------
From Our Own Correspondent 
-----------
Letter From America 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Sport 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 


Robert Pigott reports for BBC News
"The tougher line has come 3 months too late"
 real 28k

EU Food Commissioner David Byrne
"The first legal steps have been taken"
 real 28k

Thursday, 9 December, 1999, 19:01 GMT
Blair attacks French beef ban

Beef British beef is still off the French menu


UK Prime Minister Tony Blair has condemned France as "completely and totally wrong" for refusing to lift the ban on British beef.

Speaking as he prepared to leave for the European Union summit in Helsinki - now likely to be overshadowed by the beef row - Mr Blair said France would "suffer the consequences" of its decision.


Mr Blair: 'France will face consequences'
"It is not just contrary to the science which shows that British beef is not just safe, but is probably some of the safest beef anywhere in the world today.

"You can't just have a situation where you can pick and choose what laws or rules of the European market you obey."

The PM's tough talking came after France was given a 10-day ultimatum to end the illegal embargo - or face the courts.

France has refused to comply with an European Commission ruling that the meat is safe, saying the risk of mad cow disease has not been completely eradicated.

Food Row Fears
EU Food Safety Commissioner David Byrne said the European Commission was likely to take the next legal steps against the French at a meeting in Strasbourg next Tuesday.

France would then have five days to respond to the next stage of the legal proceedings.

"Immediately after that, if the embargo isn't lifted then we are straight into court," said Mr Byrne.

Big fine possible

Legal moves against France were begun by the Commission three weeks ago. Pursuing the case through the courts could take up to a year and a half and would leave France facing a substantial fine, estimated at up to £100,000 a day, if it was found to be in breach of EU law.



I am not worried. I am first and foremost accountable to French people for what I do
Lionel Jospin
Mr Blair will raise the beef ban when he meets French Prime Minister Lionel Jospin at the Helsinki summit.

But Mr Jospin has defended his action, saying: "Today, in all honesty, before the French people, it was not possible for this government to lift the embargo."

He added: "I am not worried. I am first and foremost accountable to French people for what I do."

In a statement to Parliament, UK Agriculture Minister Nick Brown said the French action was astonishing.


Nick Brown UK Agriculture Minister Nick Brown is back in the firing line
Mr Brown told MPs: "Her Majesty's Government are surprised and deeply disappointed that the French have chosen to take this position.

"It comes after many weeks of intensive talks in which we received the impression we had answered all the questions and met all the concerns from the French side."

He continued: "British beef is a safe as beef from anywhere else in Europe, that is not just my view that is the unanimous view of the commission's senior scientific advisors.

"I can understand the frustration felt more widely around the country. The French action is astonishing. They have delivered a blow to the credibility of European law."

Mr Brown defended the government's tactics of engaging in discussion with the French over the issue.



The French action is astonishing. They have delivered a blow to the credibility of European law
Nick Brown
But Tory agriculture spokesman Tim Yeo blamed the government for being "weak and incompetent".

Reaction to the continuation of the ban has included Asda supermarket announcing it would switch from French to British suppliers for one variety of potato.

National Farmers' Union president Ben Gill has asked consumers to send a message to the French government through their shopping decisions.



I do not possibly see how France can continue to act like this and remain within the European Union
Ben Gill
He has also questioned France's membership of the European Union, saying: "I do not possibly see how France can continue to act like this and remain within the European Union. This is a real crisis for Europe, and something must be done.

"Do they want to be part of a club, and a single market, or do they just want to go on their own way?"

British Labour and Conservative MEPs will mark their opposition to the French ban by boycotting next week's official opening of the European Parliament in Strasbourg by French President Jacques Chirac.

France is not the only EU member facing legal action, as Germany could also face the courts if a meeting of its parliament on 17 December fails to lift its ban on British beef.

Germany has so far been awaiting the outcome of the Anglo-French beef talks before deciding whether to lift the ban itself.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
BBC RADIO NEWS
BBC ONE TV NEWS
WORLD NEWS SUMMARY
PROGRAMMES GUIDE
Europe Contents

Country profiles

See also:
09 Dec 99 |  Europe
A low point in Anglo-French relations
09 Dec 99 |  UK Politics
A slap in the face, Mr Brown?
09 Dec 99 |  UK
Farmers despair at French beef ban defiance
09 Dec 99 |  UK Politics
Government reeling over beef ban
09 Dec 99 |  UK
Countdown to beef crisis
09 Dec 99 |  UK
90,000 cattle missing from BSE records
09 Dec 99 |  UK
Ben Gill - farmers' leader under pressure
09 Dec 99 |  Media reports
French minister defends beef ban

Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
Links to other Europe stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Europe stories