BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Russian Polish Albanian Greek Czech Ukrainian Serbian Turkish Romanian

BBC News World Edition
 You are in: Europe  
News Front Page
Middle East
South Asia
Talking Point
Country Profiles
In Depth
BBC Sport
BBC Weather
Monday, 8 July, 2002, 18:08 GMT 19:08 UK
Crash pilots given conflicting orders
Ufa schoolchildren lay flowers beneath photos of lost classmates
Ufa schoolchildren have laid flowers for lost classmates
German investigators have revealed that the pilots of the Russian airliner involved in last week's mid-air collision with a cargo plane received contradictory instructions seconds before the crash.

They said voice recorders recovered from both aircraft showed Swiss air traffic controllers told the Russian pilots to descend, while the on-board warning system instructed them to climb.

All 69 people - including 45 schoolchildren - aboard the Russian Tu-154, and two crew members on the Boeing 757 were killed when the two aircraft collided at 35,000 feet (10,500 metres) over the German-Swiss border.

The revelation came as at least 1,000 people in the Russian city of Ufa, about 1,200 kilometres (750 miles) east of Moscow, attended an emotional service in memory of their dead.

Forty-five children from Ufa died when the Russian Tupolev crashed into a Boeing cargo jet last Monday night.

Launch new window : Mid-air collision
How the crash happened

Russian President Vladimir Putin, on a visit to neighbouring Volga region, made an unscheduled stopover at Ufa's cemetery on Monday, where dozens of crash victims were earlier laid to rest.

Mr Putin told the widow of the Tu-154's captain that "the Russian pilots were not to blame for the tragedy", the Russian news agency Itar-Tass quoted him as saying.

Mr Putin said the Russian pilots "were professionals of the highest class".


Shortly before Mr Putin's arrived, thousands of people gathered in Ufa's central square to pay their last respects to some of the victims.

Mourners at crash victims' funerals in Ufa
Thousands of mourners attended the funerals in Ufa

Mourners crowded around 33 wooden coffins bedecked with flowers, many clutching photographs of their loved ones who had lost their lives.

At the memorial service, Orthodox priests and Muslim clergymen offered prayers for the dead.

Then the coffins were taken by bus to the local cemetery, where they were interred.

The BBC's Steve Rosenberg in Moscow says the tragedy has shocked Ufa and the country and there is growing anger as the investigation continues.

Conflicting orders

According to German authorities, cockpit warning systems told the Tu-154 to climb and the cargo jet to descend, just 45 seconds before the collision.

Controller at Zurich
Skyguide says its controllers are under extreme pressure

But voice recorders reveal that one second later, Zurich air traffic controllers told the Russian pilots to descend.

The Russian crew did not respond, so the Zurich control tower repeated the order 14 seconds later, investigators say.

The Russian plane responded and the two aircraft collided 30 seconds later.

Although the aircraft were flying over Germany at the time, they were under the control of the Swiss air traffic control body, Skyguide.

Investigations are being carried out by both Swiss and German authorities.

The Swiss inquiry is looking into the possibility of homicide through negligence, which carries a three-year jail term for anyone found guilty.

The controller, who warned the Russian pilot to change course just 44 seconds before the collision, has been described as overburdened by a German team investigating the crash.

The BBC's Caroline Wyatt reports from Moscow
"The results of the investigation will be closely watched"

Key stories:

At the scene:


See also:

06 Jul 02 | Europe
04 Jul 02 | Europe
03 Jul 02 | Europe
26 May 02 | In Depth
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Europe stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Europe stories

© BBC ^^ Back to top

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East |
South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature |
Technology | Health | Talking Point | Country Profiles | In Depth |