BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: World: Europe
Front Page 
Middle East 
South Asia 
From Our Own Correspondent 
Letter From America 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Wednesday, 6 December, 2000, 16:37 GMT
Analysis: Spy case sours relations
Russian courts hold the defendant in a cage
Russian courts hold the defendant in a cage
By BBC News Online's Stephen Mulvey

The conviction of US businessman and former naval intelligence officer Edmond Pope for espionage in Russia will do further damage to already soured Russian-US relations in the closing days of the Clinton presidency.

Bill Clinton personally lobbied Vladimir Putin to release Mr Pope, but the Russian president refused to intervene until the courts had reached a verdict.

US diplomatic pressure on Mr Putin to use his right to pardon the 54-year-old American will now be intense.

Last month, after a lengthy conversation between the two presidents, a US official said: "We think President Putin understands [our] concerns, and we hope he acts on them as soon as possible."


Washington has maintained all along that Mr Pope is innocent, but has cited humanitarian grounds as the most compelling reason for his release.

Mr Clinton
Mr Clinton "repeatedly" raised the Pope case with the Russian president
After the 20-year sentence was delivered, White House National Security spokesman PJ Crowley said the US was "deeply disappointed" and once again underlined concerns about his health.

Mr Pope has a rare form of bone cancer, and has been denied regular access to a Western doctor since his arrest on 3 April. Nor, according to his lawyer, Pavel Astakhov, has he received "adequate" alternative medical care.

It was not only the US embassy doctor who was denied regular access to his patient. Consular officials were also only allowed to see him occasionally - sometimes at intervals of more than a month.

Russian doctors judged him fit to be tried, although hearings were frequently cancelled because he was too sick to attend.


Mr Pope, who does not understand Russian, often complained about his difficulty understanding the proceedings.

Mr Pope is not a spy, was not a spy, and there is no evidence in this case offered to prove he is a spy

Defence lawyer, Pavel Astakhov
He did not trust his translator - an employee of the Federal Security Service - but was refused permission to replace him.

Permission to video-tape the case, so that the translation could be checked later, was also denied.

Mr Pope's defence was that the documents on a new Russian torpedo system that he collected and paid for were all in the public domain.

The truth of this claim is hard for outsiders to judge, as the trial took place behind closed doors.

However, the Russian Security Service's key witness, a professor at Moscow's State Technical University, Anatoly Babkin, retracted during the trial statements he had made earlier to the prosecution.

Spies on the rise

Vladimir Putin: Spy turned president
Vladimir Putin: Spy turned president
He denied ever giving Mr Pope secret documents, and said that his initial statements implicating Mr Pope had been extracted under pressure.

Mr Pope is the first Westerner to be tried for spying in Russia for many years. In the past, suspected spies have been expelled, sometimes discreetly, sometimes publicly.

Many analysts interpret the decision to try Mr Pope as a political decision, and a sign of the rising clout of the secret services in Russia, following the elevation of one of their own, Vladimir Putin, to the presidency.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

21 Oct 00 | Europe
Clinton asks Russia to free 'spy'
05 Apr 00 | Europe
US 'spy' held in Moscow
13 Sep 99 | Britain betrayed
Who's being spied on?
05 Apr 00 | Europe
Analysis: Spymasters change focus
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Europe stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Europe stories