Page last updated at 11:48 GMT, Wednesday, 10 September 2008 12:48 UK

Girls Aloud win 20 single prize

By Mark Savage
BBC News entertainment reporter

Girls Aloud
Girls Aloud have now won the Popjustice prize four times

As Elbow collected their 20,000 Mercury Award in Park Lane's swanky Grosvenor House, Girls Aloud were awarded a crisp 20 note by a panel of judges squeezed into a tiny London pub.

The Popjustice Twenty Quid Music Prize, now in its sixth year, is given out on the same night as the Mercury, and rewards the best British single of the last 12 months.

I was among the judges who bestowed this prestigious honour on the Girls Aloud's Call The Shots - which triumphed over the Sugababes' About You Now in a fraught last-minute showdown.

The tongue-in-cheek ceremony had none of the star power of its big brother - but I couldn't help wondering whether the Mercury panel had been quite as rigorous in reaching their decision.

Did they, as we had, debate which song was most likely to encourage pandas to mate?

It wasn't a topic I personally felt qualified to discuss, but luckily one of the jurors worked in a zoo. (Girls Aloud are a powerful panda aphrodisiac, just so you know).

Eviction

The 30-odd judges were all readers of the Popjustice music website - and ranged from music industry professionals to die-hard pop fans.

There was even a former boy band member amongst us.

Aside from the main event, we were given a series of extra tasks, including the "opportunity" to design Britney Spears' new album sleeve (mine was called The Nun).

Leona Lewis
Leona Lewis's exit was one of the night's most controversial decisions
But the serious business began with a shortlist of 12 songs, ranging from Goldfrapp's folky ballad A&E to the clattering dance-rock of Bloc Party's Flux.

As proceedings kicked off, we each had to nominate one track for an instant, Big Brother-style eviction.

Amy Winehouse - who won the prize last year with Rehab - was ignominiously booted out for her near-ubiquitous version of Valerie with Mark Ronson.

"Poor Amy, though, she's had a bad year," noted Popjustice editor Peter Robinson, who presided over the event.

Later rounds saw artists pitched against each other, two at a time, with the panel's favourite put through to the next stage of voting.

THE SHORTLIST
Hot Chip
A&E - Goldfrapp
About You Now - Sugababes
Bleeding Love - Leona Lewis
Call The Shots - Girls Aloud
Dance Wiv Me - Dizzee Rascal feat Calvin Harris
Flux - Bloc Party
Money - Daggers
That's Not My Name - The Ting Tings
Valerie - Mark Ronson feat Amy Winehouse
Ready For The Floor - Hot Chip (pictured)
Song 4 Mutya (Out Of Control) - Groove Armada feat Mutya Buena
Stuck On Repeat - Little Boots
A particularly vociferous argument broke out when Groove Armada and Mutya Buena's "instantaneously brilliant" Song 4 Mutya went up against Girls Aloud's "self-indulgent" single.

"If we vote out Mutya," noted Jamie Smy, "she will come to every one of us in our beds tonight and scratch our faces off."

Despite the implied violence from a notoriously bad-tempered former Sugababe, the song went out.

'Best font'

A more contentious moment came when the smokers on the panel (all three of them) were sent out to choose between Leona Lewis's globe-straddling megahit Bleeding Love and Bloc Party's Flux.

Almost apologetically, they returned from their cigarette break to announce they had plumped for Bloc Party.

"Bleeding Love is the best second single ever by a reality star," they noted, "but Kele Okereke is a much better pop star."

As the shortlist narrowed down, the methods of choosing between people's favourite songs became more and more bizarre.

Which band had the best use of hair straighteners? What could a scientist tell us about the relative merits of Dizzee Rascal? Whose single artwork employed the best font?

At one point, Robinson demanded the judges' iPods so he could examine which songs they had played the most.

Keisha Buchanan of the Sugababes
Choreography was a key factor in the judges decisions
By the time the list has been whittled down to the UK's top two girl bands, there had been several stand-up arguments and at least one table overturned (it was being danced on, to be fair).

It was noted that About You Now and Call The Shots were both great British pop songs - but each fell short of the high standards set by the bands' previous songs.

Three brave souls stepped forward to sing a capella versions of the songs in an attempt to settle an argument over which had the more memorable melody.

Personally, I thought the Sugababes song presented a perfect piece of pop songwriting - with a bittersweet lyric, melodic progression and clever harmonies.

But, as I noted on my judging form, Girls Aloud's track was simply more original. Fellow judge Laura Leishman pointed out that Call The Shots depicted a more "mature and sophisticated relationship".

It was also praised for employing metaphor.

A tense atmosphere fell over the room as our final decisions were tallied - and a euphoric cheer greeted the announcement of Girls Aloud's victory.

If anything the night showed that, with the record industry in supposed crisis, pop fans are still incredibly passionate about their favourite artists.

Also, smokers hate Leona Lewis.




SEE ALSO
Elbow elated at Mercury Prize win
09 Sep 08 |  Entertainment
In pictures: Mercury Prize 2008
09 Sep 08 |  In Pictures
Girls Aloud set UK singles record
26 Sep 07 |  Entertainment

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

BBC navigation

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific