[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Sunday, 29 October 2006, 14:00 GMT
50 Cent copyright claim dismissed
50 Cent
50 Cent was voted songwriter of the year in May
A judge has dismissed claims by the ex-frontman of rap group 2 Live Crew that rapper 50 Cent stole the opening line for the 2003 single In Da Club.

Luther Campbell filed a claim at Miami Federal Court in January that 50 Cent used a line from Campbell's song It's Your Birthday, changing just one word.

But District Judge Paul C Huck claimed the phrase was a "common, unoriginal, non-copyrightable element of the song".

Judge Huck said there were almost no other similarities between the songs.

Dismissing the claim the judge said the disputed line only represented 11 seconds of a track that lasted more than three minutes.

No reasonable jury would conclude that the compositions have substantial similarities and the average person would not confuse the two songs, the judge wrote.

Original claim

The original claim was filed on behalf of Lil' Joe Wein Music, which holds the copyright for It's Your Birthday, against Curtis Jackson, the real name of rapper 50 Cent.

Campbell's lawyer had claimed that in In Da Club, "Sheila" becomes "shorty" in the line "Go shorty, it's your birthday."

Campbell's song appeared on his 1994 solo album Still a Freak for Life.

Campbell's lawyer Richard C Wolfe said, in January: "It's the melody, it's the pace, the style - everything about that one line is the same."

"We're entitled to a portion of the profits."

Neither party was available for comment on Friday.




SEE ALSO
Driving rap for US star 50 Cent
09 Sep 06 |  Entertainment
50 Cent named songwriter of year
23 May 06 |  Entertainment
50 Cent: Money Machine
17 Mar 06 |  Business
Rapper sues 50 Cent over lyrics
21 Jan 06 |  Entertainment
50 Cent defends 'violent' movie
18 Jan 06 |  Entertainment
50 Cent ad 'glamorised' gun crime
04 Jan 06 |  Entertainment

RELATED BBC LINKS

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific