[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Tuesday, 5 July, 2005, 16:54 GMT 17:54 UK
U2 win memorabilia court battle
Bono
Bono was not in court to hear the verdict
Rock band U2 have won their court fight for the return of memorabilia - including a Stetson hat - which they accused a former stylist of stealing.

Judge Matthew Deery at Dublin's Circuit Court ordered Lola Cashman to return the items, which also include earrings, within seven days.

He said he believed Bono's testimony that he had not given her the items which she tried to sell at auction.

After the verdict, Bono said they had brought the case out of principle.

Ms Cashman, who worked as U2's stylist in the 1980s, wrote an unauthorised book called Inside the Zoo, which upset the band.

When she attempted to put the memorabilia - which she said had been given as gifts - up for sale she was contacted by U2's lawyers.

She then began legal proceedings for defamation in London's High Court, which were put on hold for the Irish proceedings.

Bono said: "This case was brought very reluctantly, in the context of a larger dispute which we never invited.

"The point of principle involved was of much greater significance to us than any item of memorabilia."

Neither Ms Cashman nor any band members were in court to hear the decision.

Judge Deery said he found Ms Cashman's version of how she had been given the items at the end of a US tour doubtful, particularly her description of Bono running around in his underpants backstage.

Lola Cashman
Ms Cashman denied she stole the items

"It seems to me that Ms Cashman's version of events, the giving of the hat, is unlikely to have occurred," he said.

Bono had told the court he would not have given away the items, valued at 3,500, which he considered had iconic status, particularly the hat.

Judge Deery said he did not accept her claim that U2 had brought the case solely to stop the defamation proceedings, but recognised the outcome will substantially affect the other case.

"It would seem odd if the group were to make a provision to pursue a claim of this nature if the subject was not of importance to the band," he said.

He will decide on the issue of costs on 12 July.



SEE ALSO:
U2 possessions 'were not stolen'
29 Jun 05 |  Entertainment
Bono in memorabilia court fight
28 Jun 05 |  Entertainment
U2 thrill at 'homecoming' gig
25 Jun 05 |  Northern Ireland
Excitement builds for U2 Dublin gigs
24 Jun 05 |  Entertainment
U2 mania for homecoming gigs
24 Jun 05 |  Northern Ireland
U2 get lifetime achievement award
17 Jun 05 |  Entertainment


RELATED BBC LINKS:

RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific