[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Friday, 18 November 2005, 17:55 GMT
Madonna in plagiarism case defeat
Madonna experimented with Eastern influences on Ray of Light
A Belgian songwriter has won a plagiarism case against Madonna over her 1998 hit single Frozen.

Salvatore Acquaviva's claim that the song copied one of his recordings was upheld by a Belgian court.

His lawyer told the Reuters news agency the judge ordered EMI, Sony and Warner Music to withdraw the song from sale in the country.

The companies' lawyer declined to comment while Madonna's UK spokeswoman said she was unable to give a reaction.

Mr Acquaviva's lawyer Victor-Vincent Dehin said the judge agreed that Madonna's single used four bars of the song Ma Vie Fout L'camp, which roughly translates as My Life's Getting Nowhere.

Compensation claim

He said the judge ordered the record companies to get radio and TV stations in the country to stop playing the song.

The judge also ordered them to withdraw Ray of Light, the Madonna album on which Frozen appears, from sale, he claimed.

She performed songs from her new album in London this week

Mr Dehin said the companies would face a fine of more than 100,000 euros (68,000) if they did not obey the ruling within 15 days.

He said: "We tried to reach a friendly agreement... but they didn't want to negotiate so I sued for plagiarism.

"They have stolen a song, so they have to pay the value of the song."

Mr Dehin said he would try to negotiate a compensation deal for an undisclosed sum but was prepared to go back to court if the companies, who have the right to appeal, refused his claim.

Madonna's Ray of Light was a critical and commercial success and went on to win her four US Grammies, including best pop album.

Madonna film spills few secrets
17 Nov 05 |  Entertainment
Madonna's intimate night with her fans
16 Nov 05 |  Entertainment
Madonna's last dancefloor confession?
14 Nov 05 |  Entertainment
Madonna defends Kabbalah interest
31 Oct 05 |  Entertainment
Madonna mixes messages with show
25 May 04 |  Entertainment


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific