A judge has dismissed a lawsuit against Elizabeth Taylor over a Van Gogh painting a German family claimed had been stolen by the Nazis.
The legal battle began in October 2004
The 1889 artwork was bought by actress Ms Taylor at auction in 1963.
The descendents of Margarete Mauthner, a Jewish woman who fled Nazi Germany, sought its return under the US Holocaust Victims Redress Act.
But a judge ruled that state law says legal action must be filed within three years of property being taken.
The painting, entitled View of the Asylum and Chapel at Saint-Remy, was originally bought at Sotheby's auction house in London for $257,000 (£138,362).
It now hangs in Liz Taylor's Los Angeles home and is thought to be worth about $15m (£8m).
Margarete Mauthner's South African and Canadian descendants filed a suit in October 2004, claiming the work had been confiscated from her by the Nazis and should be returned under the 1998 Holocaust Act.
Liz Taylor then counter-sued, claiming to be the rightful owner of the painting, and stated it had passed through two other galleries and another collector - who had also fled Nazi Germany - before it had come into her possession.
Ms Mauthner's descendants claim Ms Taylor must have known that the painting had been taken by Nazi officials when she bought it.