[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Monday, 13 December, 2004, 14:01 GMT
Hello! fights against Zeta ruling
Catherine Zeta Jones and Michael Douglas before their wedding in New York in 2000
Catherine Zeta Jones and Michael Douglas wed in New York in 2000
Hello! magazine has challenged a court ruling which forced them to pay more than 1 million in damages to Catherine Zeta Jones and Michael Douglas.

Lawyers for the publication admitted that they had used snatched photos of the couple's wedding to spoil rival OK's exclusive coverage of the event.

But James Price QC told the Court of Appeal on Monday this was not unlawful.

A judge ruled last year that Hello! had breached the film stars' rights of confidence and awarded the damages.

Zeta Jones and Douglas were awarded 14,600, while OK! magazine was awarded more than 1 million due to commercial damage inflicted on its coverage.


Mr Price, representing Hello! magazine, told the Law Lords hearing the case that the practice of "spoilers" was common in the publishing world.

"We are in the position that if you are going to compete in this industry you have to publish spoilers," he told the court.

"But what happened to Hello! was that it was caught by a law which said 'stop it' retrospectively," he added.

Catherine Zeta Jones and Michael Douglas
Zeta Jones and Douglas claimed for "personal distress"

Mr Price also argued that spoilers could give the magazine in question an advantage.

"One can get a promotional boost from very obviously inferior pictures of an event in a competing publication," he said.

Mr Price added that the High Court judge who made the ruling against Hello! said that OK! had lost 1.4 million sales from the spoiler.

But Mr Justice Lindsay had also accepted that a spoiler could have the effect of increasing the sales of a magazine with an exclusive contract.

Mr Price said this made his original findings "manifestly unsustainable".


If the Appeal Court challenge is successful, then both OK! and the Douglases stand to lose their damages.

OK!, meanwhile, is challenging a ruling that entitled it to only 75% of its legal costs for its case against Hello!

The cost of the case so far has been estimated at 4 million.

Actress Zeta Jones, 35, had said in the original hearing that she and her 60-year-old husband accepted the OK! deal after turning down a higher offer from Hello! magazine.

The actress had added how she felt "devastated, shocked and appalled" when she realised her wedding ceremony had been gatecrashed by uninvited photographers, prompting the legal action.

The current hearing, scheduled to last up to five days, was adjourned until Tuesday.

Hello! appeals in Zeta Jones case
09 Dec 04 |  Entertainment
Zeta Jones wins 3m Hello! costs
23 Jan 04 |  Entertainment
Zeta wins 14,600 Hello! damages
07 Nov 03 |  Entertainment
Zeta damages judgement reserved
01 Aug 03 |  Entertainment
Why privacy is still an issue
11 Apr 03 |  Entertainment
Zeta Jones wins Hello! damages
11 Apr 03 |  Entertainment
What the Hello! judge said
11 Apr 03 |  Entertainment

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific