Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

Front Page



UK Politics







Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Low Graphics

Wednesday, July 14, 1999 Published at 09:36 GMT 10:36 UK


Star Wars: Sit back and enjoy it

Young star: Natalie Portman

By the BBC's William Gallagher

It's Star Wars. Huge fun, great excitement and spectacle enough to send your jaw dropping. The three main leads are exceptional, too, and deliver performances that are really far better than their roles warrant.

What's more, they do so in a range of planets and cities that are nothing short of beautiful.

Star Wars
So you should definitely see this film and you will relish the ride as you do - but it's also far from perfect and you will come away wondering what it would have been like if an adult had written it.

When the first Star Wars came out, I was a young enough boy to think Princess Leia and Luke Skywalker should end up together.

[ image: Darth Maul, as played by Ray Park]
Darth Maul, as played by Ray Park
Even by the next film, though, I knew she'd be better off with Han Solo if she had to pick anyone at all. George Lucas clearly thought the same, so it felt like the movies were growing up at the same time as me.

It's not true. Nobody can touch Lucas for the visual impact of his fantasy films and the core story is an excellent epic with enough duplicity and deceit to get you wound up and concerned for the characters.

But although he's 20 years older and has created an entire little film industry of his own, Lucas's writing in The Phantom Menace is more primitive than it was for the original Star Wars.

[ image: George Lucas, Jake Lloyd and R2D2]
George Lucas, Jake Lloyd and R2D2
There are some lines that make you pity the cast and others that make you pity Lucas. He has no trust in an audience's ability to see the obvious so he will tell us and attempt to sweeten the pill with humour.

He's not great on humour. Comic character Jar Jar Binks is a failure, although technically superb.

While the cute Anakin Skywalker - variously being called Mannequin or Anadin - is not as wooden as expected - he has to carry far too much of the plot.

It is a great idea to show us this boy when we know he will become the evil Darth Vader of the later films because it lends terrible import to some seemingly innocent lines.

But knowing a taste of his future is also a weakness for you cannot watch him (Jake Lloyd) and Queen Amidala (Portman) without snapping out of the film and wondering how in the world this adult royalty is ever going to marry this nine-year-old.

While it's on the screen, Star Wars will snatch you out of the cinema and into its universe and give you a fabulous couple of hours.

Without question, it's the most exciting movie of the year and huge, huge fun - it just wouldn't have taken much to make it a lot better.

Advanced options | Search tips

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©

Entertainment Contents

TV and Radio
New Media

Relevant Stories

13 May 99 | Tom Brook
Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Plot

Internet Links

Star Wars

The Phantom Menace UK

Black Jedi (UK fan site)

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.