BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific
BBCi NEWS   SPORT   WEATHER   WORLD SERVICE   A-Z INDEX     

BBC News World Edition
 You are in: Entertainment  
News Front Page
Africa
Americas
Asia-Pacific
Europe
Middle East
South Asia
UK
Business
Entertainment
Science/Nature
Technology
Health
-------------
Talking Point
-------------
Country Profiles
In Depth
-------------
Programmes
-------------
BBC Sport
BBC Weather
SERVICES
-------------
EDITIONS
Tuesday, 1 October, 2002, 08:45 GMT 09:45 UK
Peter Gabriel's Up: Your views
Peter Gabriel
Gabriel used to be in Genesis
Prog rock veteran Peter Gabriel has released his first album for 10 years.

It was recorded in various locations including France, Senegal and on a boat travelling up the Amazon.

"He returns in weird and sometimes wonderful form with an album of rich soundscapes and supple melodies," wrote the BBC's Nigel Packer.

But what do you think?

This debate is now closed. Please see a selection of your comments below.

Have your say

Gabriel's work with Genesis was pretentious yet deserved respect. Solsbury Hill is one of the finest pop songs ever written. Big Time/Sledgehammer were refreshing numbers that inspired joy in the listener.

Gabriel's latest, however, is the new age, post-modern, psudo-liberal, world music rubbish that people are encouraged to like, however much it fails in every respect as popular music.
Ali Arikan, London, UK

Excellent album. Real music unlike today's chart fare.
Darren Allen, England

Worth the wait.
Joan, UK

Ten years? It's as if the last 25 years had never happened.
Andrew, UK


I haven't mentioned any individual track because it's the sum of the whole that makes this album so special

Andrew Neave, USA
This album proves to me that true talent and the ability to write memorable melodies was not something associated with the 70s and 80s. Peter Gabriel has produced the album of the year, a work few other people in the world could manage in the scope of the arrangements, just as you think you have reached the highlight of the album along comes another track and another moment you think "now that's genius". This album has got me in a "UP" mood, I haven't mentioned any individual track because it's the sum of the whole that makes this album so special.
Andrew Neave, USA

Well, nothing from PG will ever top his Genesis stuff like "The Lamb" but this one is quite good, for the tracks I've heard so far.
Mel, Scotland


Peter is back to his best, it may be 10 years since his last album but it's been worth the wait

Dave Johnson, UK
UP is not a great album by any means. Being a PG fan for some time, I was looking forward to this release but it kind of peters out (pun intended) after the first three tracks.

The single "The Barry Williams Show", far from being a pithy indictment of reality TV, arrived five years too late and makes PG seem out-of-touch.

Oh well, his next opus "I/O" (that stands for Input/Output) should be arriving within the next 18 months (that's 15 years to all us fans familiar with Gabriel's writing speed).
Darren, UK

After waiting so long for Peter Gabriel's new album it was a worry that it would be a disappointment. But no, once again Peter has made an album that at its basic level will sink into your very soul after a few listens.
Paul Hedges, Great Britain

Peter is back to his best, it may be 10 years since his last album but it's been worth the wait. I doubt Phil Collins' new album will be as good as this!
Dave Johnson, Hemel Hempstead

Gabriel is at his best. Album is superb, makes you want a better sound system! Rich tracks full interesting sounds and layers - make sure you buy a copy for the car too!
Andrew, Canada


Technically perfect, emotionally charged as ever, but less pioneering than he used to be. Still a great album

Stephan, UK
Wow, if there is anyone who would speak negatively about this album, they obviously don't know anything about music......bravo Gabriel.....superb sounds, intense lyrics, made us all happy...much love from the States. Keep them coming though.
Shahram Khan, USA

Brilliant. Love the modern King Crimson touches (presumably provided by bass player - Levin). Much darker, more emotional fare than his previous album, Us. Heard the songs for first time at an outstanding warm-up show in Milan. The album will always remind me of this unforgettable performance.
Chris Frost, Germany

It's been such a long wait - the "forthcoming" album title was announced back in 1998! It had to be something special to avoid a tinge of disappointment. I'm not sure yet of its potential classic status, but it's like a cool drink of water in the otherwise scorching desert of popular music out there. Love him or loathe him, you won't hear the sounds he makes anywhere else. Not every song stands out, but there are many moments of magic and long-term and patiently-waiting fans will get their money's worth.
James Bowley, United Kingdom

It is hard to believe that it took Gabriel a decade to complete UP. Some of the stuff works beautifully, and contrast and diversity certainly are an advantage of his album. But after listening to the CD more than just oncs, one craves for some simplicity. Technically perfect, emotionally charged as ever, but less pioneering than he used to be. Still a great album.
Stephan, Britain

Sheer genius, it's been a long time coming. I've been through it three times now and, like all other Gabe albums, it's taken over my mind. I can't really hear any singles on it which appeal to me, I just hope enough people buy the album to convince the man to release another. This is definitely the best new album I've heard this year.
Pete, UK


From the blast off of Darkness to the landing The Drop, a hell of a ride! Masterpiece!

John Rucker, USA
I am a huge Peter Gabriel fan. But after a wait of 10 years this is somewhat disappointing. The tracks, although containing flashes of sheer brilliance, appear drawn out and at times lose their way. It's not that it's a bad album - it just doesn't have that instant accessibility of So or Us. Perhaps when I get to see the live treatment of this new material.
Phil Ruff, Manchester

With my hand on the play button and my heart in panic mode, I began the new album and my fears were quickly put to rest. The clean sound, the tremendous tunes and scary unusual moments have made this one of my favourite PG albums. His concert presentation of these tunes should be fantastic. Way to go Pete!!
Adam G Pituch, Canada

Andrew Neave (see above) was correct in saying that just when you think you've hit the highlight of the album, something else comes along and shakes you even harder. For me, the best example of that might be hearing the late Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan's vocals on Signal to Noise - that raises the hair on the back of my neck every time. Truly, listening to Up is a very personal experience; it can be a soundtrack to realisation, rebirth (as it has been for me), or whatever your soul might be in need of. In short, Gabriel's done well by the fans once again.
Aubrey, USA

If you only listen to this once or twice, you will be disappointed, it is "difficult". But listen to it just a few more times and the full intensity and brilliance will begin to emerge. It really is absolutely incredibly good. Superlatives enough? Buy it! You will regret it at first. Then...
John Davie, Yorkshire


He's a creative powerhouse, never content to retread his old songs or sound anything like whatever's fashionable at the moment

John Myhill, UK
After listening to the entire CD just the once, I feel that Gabriel has stepped back towards his prog-rock heritage, where rhythms, melodies and the vocals fluctuate within a song, almost as though this CD needs to accompany moving images and visuals more so than Gabriel's soundtrack work.

The CD doesn't seem like a progression of his last "proper" CD, entitled Us, which was a perfect marriage of his Last Temptation of Christ soundtrack and So. I guess with a 10 year gap, an audience will have to look quite far back in order to calculate progress.

For me the album soars during the slower movements of the collection, where one can be elevated to absorb every rasp of his voice, every layer of the song. Quite beautiful. It reminds me that I will always be a huge Peter Gabriel fan and hope that the next CD will arrive before my entire head turns grey.
Paul Cutler, USA

From the blast off of Darkness to the landing The Drop, a hell of a ride! Masterpiece!
John Rucker, USA

My speakers and ears have been craving something great this year. This fulfills the craving and leaves me satisfied that music can still be great and it wasn't me turning into Victor Meldrew.
Jonathan Sapier, England

On first hearing it reminds me of his previous best album (his third, the one with Games Without Frontiers on). Both can be tender, touching, rocking or downright scary by turns, often in the same song. He's a creative powerhouse, never content to retread his old songs or sound anything like whatever's fashionable at the moment. An old bootleg of his was called Expect the Unexpected which is what you have to do with such an original artist. It'll take a while to really get into Up, but it's clear he's still got the "Genius" option ticked on his creative software.
John Myhill, UK


Unfortunately what you actually get is a World Music lite production as bland and unimaginative as the car commercials it will eventually become musical wallpaper for

Chard, France
Breathtaking and exhausting, Up takes you on an emotional rollercoaster. Absolutely stunning.
Ed Staines, United Kingdom

Just listen to Signal to Noise from this album. Beg, borrow or steal to get it. This is a gigantic anthemic piece of music sculpturing, you've just got to hear it, if this doesn't stir the deepest untouched emotions in you, then nothing will....
Glenn, N Iireland

Gabriel's album suffers from "kitchen sink" syndrome. He must believe that if you throw enough things into the mix something bright and original will emerge. Unfortunately what you actually get is a World Music lite production as bland and unimaginative as the car commercials it will eventually become musical wallpaper for. He should chop off the novelty facial hair and go back to wearing flowers on his head. That strikes me as being as equally relevant a gesture as his new album.
Chard, France

Up isn't Gabriel's first album in 10 years despite what all the media coverage says - OVO was released in 2000.
Dave Owen, UK

At first listen I was a bit disappointed with Up. There were a few tracks that stood out but on the whole it was very hard going. After 30-plus listens.. this man is a genius. The power, the images, the different layers throughout all the tracks, build up over time and you suddenly realise what he is doing, or trying to say, and you realise, not for the first time, that this man is truly a genius. People that knock it are not hearing what's there.

If you're expecting another "Sledghammer/Kiss That Frog" type album, leave it alone (you'll probably think "TBWS" is great, although it does not belong on this masterpiece). If, however, you yearn for the early days of PG3 & 4, and Peterżs awesome strained, gut-wrenching vocals, and lyrics that make your stomach tighten and your eyes water then go and get this NOW! The sooner you have it the quicker you'll feel it.

żIżve got sunshine in my stomach, like Iżve just finished listening to UP.
Mike Wilkinson, UK


Even though the production is excellent, I get the feeling that UP is a bit rushed. Yes I know it took ages but I've been listening to Peter Gabriel for about 20 years and I think that some of the new songs will be less memorable

Jay, UK
Superb. Where some rockstars age gracelessly, no names, Gabriel has aged and taken his muse with him. With a collection of songs that draws upon all periods of his career (can anyone else hear early Genesis in the vocals and structure?), Gabriel has created an album of thoughtful songs with intense emotions. This isn't an album of pop-songs, so for those wanting Sledgehammer 2, you'd better make do with the current single, The Barry Williams Show. For the rest of us, its time to settle back and enjoy.

By the way, it sounds brilliant on headphones.
Ben Christie, UK

UP is a mature album and shows to me some nods back to early Gabriel. On top of that, there is a contemporary feel to it too. You could imagine the feel of UP rather like an influence filter as there are many relations to his previous solo efforts. I love the seedy first track about how people can sometimes be controlled by their fears, Gabriel then gives hope in the almost epic Hours which probably took more work than the verses. This track brings back some of the magic that was missing from So and Us.

Even though the production is excellent, I get the feeling that UP is a bit rushed. Yes I know it took ages but I've been listening to Peter Gabriel for about 20 years and I think that some of the new songs will be less memorable. However, I've only listened to it twice so I'll give it the benefit of the doubt in the hope that it'll grow on me, as all the Gabriel albums I've listened to have a habit of doing.
Jay, UK

Worth the wait! If you don't have UP, get it!
Colin Sullivan, Ireland

Marvellous. Welcome back!
Peter, England

My good friend purchased UP a few nights ago during a visit to Virgin in Los Angeles. What a great way to drive down Sunset Blvd - an awesome album, I'm soon off to buy my copy.
Ray Lazarine, USA


I agree these are not groundbreaking songs, but as a whole it is the future of music, just watch and see

Gary, USA
Devastating Gabriel has absorbed the ethnic influences of past albums and integrated them into a true "world music." He is at the top of his studio craft, creating subtle, layered, and absolutely unique textures. His lyrics are hauntingly painful, and bear repeated, serious listening. Pay attention to the sequencing, and you may find a sort of loose story unfolding, giving each song more resonance within the context of the whole work. This is a work of transcendant soulfulness, extreme musicality, and existentially painful joy.
MB, USA

Comments that this is "world music lite", "background music for commercials" etc. are unbelievably inaccurate and downright stupid. You'll notice in the comments that are against this album a real sense of bitterness and hatred. Sad. Anyway, this album is breathtaking - my second fave PG album after Passion. There is genuine passion and emotion in this music, things devoid in so much of mainstream music and yet so integral to Peter's work. This album is better than So, or Us, without question. Essential.
Oliver Thompson, England

A masterpiece that people will have to listen to and not just hear to enjoy. Not immediately catchy as usual with PG but so intense and totally genius. The best album I've heard for a long long time.
Pascal, France

It is important to sit back, as has been said by others, and let this recording wash over you. It's so hard to judge UP this early, but in just three days it has called out to me to play it whenever I get the chance. Can't wait for the live show!
Bob, USA

Like Ben Christie above, I immediately heard a lot of old Peter vocal phrasing. I was very pleasantly surprised by this because it was wedded so well with the new music. Many times it sounds gritty (this is intentional not an audio defect) and raw, but at other times soft and warm. I agree these are not groundbreaking songs, but as a whole it is the future of music, just watch and see...
Gary, USA


To me, the songs are structured as symphonies, layers of instrumental sounds making new melodies

Martijn ten Napel, UK
On February 27, 1980, which also happened to be my 21st birthday, I was a novice journalist in Dundee, Scotland. After a secret warm-up concert at the University, before a solo tour, Peter Gabriel agreed to sit with me and chat for almost two hours. In the course of this conversation, I asked him what was the ultimate aim of his work: "To send shivers down people's spines, the way someone like Otis Reading could do to me," he replied.

Up is his masterwork and crowning achievement of years of endeavour, exploration, distilling ideas, synthesising subtle layers of sounds, and raw self-expression. There is not a whiff of pretension, of lifting fashionable jungle drums or "new age bandwagoning." This is an album crafted by a man who has reached the peak of his endeavours; the rewards for the listener are thought-provoking and thrilling. It's also a damn fine rock record.
Kenny Mitchell, Italy

This is not popular music - thank God! It is, as I hoped, a work of rich depth and many layers. With Gabriel you always have work to do. He draws you in to every song and forces a response. Up is a wonderful collection of songs which will go on haunting and thrilling anyone prepared to listen. Thank you Peter for another example of true artistry and don't let it be so long for the next one yeah.
Hadge Hughes, England

I'm listening to it for the fifth time while typing this. I have goosebumps everywhere.

You need to really listen and let go if you want to get into the music, a superficial listen will give you no satisfaction at all.

It needs the same kind of concentration as a symphony, which isn't a surprise. To me, the songs are structured as symphonies, layers of instrumental sounds making new melodies.

Albums of this kind are rare. Treasure it.
Martijn ten Napel, UK


All I can say is that the 66 minutes go by fast and like with nobody else I yearn to hit the play buton again to listen to just one more time

Tejbans Kohli, USA
Excellent! Like most of PG's albums, some tracks appear initially to be sub-standard - however many listens later and you realise just what a genius this man is. I was pleased to hear a couple of tracks/phrases lifted from the Long Walk Home album (Rabbit Proof Fence music). I always felt there was more PG could have done with them and he hasn't failed to deliver...can't wait until I am 45 for the next one!!
Rob Smith, England

Been a long time PG fan. All I can say is that the 66 minutes go by fast and like with nobody else I yearn to hit the play buton again to listen to just one more time.
Tejbans Kohli, USA

Weird? A bit maybe but that's the way I like PG. Up or Down? I feel like the title goes a bit against the record's soundscapes.

Worth the wait? Mmmm, I think US was more appealing (to me of course) than UP, but still this is very good....... Ciao
Maurizio, England

I started listening to PG when So came out but actually think that most of the cues for this record come from his earlier work. Parts of it have the folksy sound of his prog rock era with Genesis and in other parts you can hear the rural Englishness of Solsbury Hill. I like Growing Up and don't see it as sub-Sledgehammer. Sky Blue starts like its going to sound over simple but actually adds layers and complexity. The Barry Williams Show even has Blur-like melodies supporting the chorus. Records of this scope and scale aren't made anymore and I'm having trouble getting my head around it but I'm enjoying the opportunity.
Dan, UK

See also:

23 Sep 02 | Entertainment
20 Sep 02 | Entertainment
10 Jun 02 | Entertainment
20 Aug 01 | Entertainment
16 Sep 99 | Entertainment
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Entertainment stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Entertainment stories

© BBC ^^ Back to top

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East |
South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature |
Technology | Health | Talking Point | Country Profiles | In Depth |
Programmes