BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific
BBCi NEWS   SPORT   WEATHER   WORLD SERVICE   A-Z INDEX     

BBC News World Edition
 You are in: Entertainment  
News Front Page
Africa
Americas
Asia-Pacific
Europe
Middle East
South Asia
UK
Business
Entertainment
Science/Nature
Technology
Health
-------------
Talking Point
-------------
Country Profiles
In Depth
-------------
Programmes
-------------
BBC Sport
BBC Weather
SERVICES
-------------
EDITIONS
Monday, 2 September, 2002, 14:35 GMT 15:35 UK
Edinburgh: Your festival views
Fringe festival performers
The weird and wonderful are part of the Edinburgh experience
The Edinburgh festival is billed as the biggest, and often best, arts extravaganza in the world.

It is made up of five events - the Fringe, the international festival and the jazz, book, film and TV festivals.

Each year brings a number of hilarious and scathing press reviews. But we want to know what you think of Edinburgh's festival.

If you have been in the past, did you have a good time and what were the great or terrible shows you saw?

And if you are going this year, send us your short reviews.

Have your say

Boothby Graftoe was hilarious, and Geoffrey from Rainbow was also great but the highlight would have to be Sophie. A funny but fantastically moving play that displays good coming of a genuine tragedy.
Dan, England

Amazed no one has mentioned the two best shows on the Fringe - Derevo's La Divina Commedia and a guy called Giles Brandreth in Zip - great mickey-take on all those great musicals. Truly superb, both!
Stevo Padaro, NY

Two major highlights for me this year were Angels Of The Universe from the Icelandic Takeaway Theatre and Terra Folk, the Slovenian folk Trio - outstanding entertainment!!
Fjola, England

I've just returned home after four packed days at the Fringe, and it was absolutely fantastic. I'd never been before, but the atmosphere along the Royal Mile, the huge diversity of things available and the fact that there's no better way to spend a day than at show after show, mean that I'll definitely be back for years to come.

I've got a couple of particular recommendations: Ross Noble's "Sonic Waffle", which had me crying with laughter at times, and, in a completely different vein, "Goering's Defence" at the Assembly Rooms. The latter is so well-performed and written to discomfort you enough to think hard - a definite recommendation.
Becky Loader, UK

It's fantastic! I'm going next week for the fourth year running - the sheer choice of entertainment means you can be busy all day from Shakespeare for Breakfast (With coffee and croissants) to Late 'n' Live. The best late night show is Sonnie Mann's chapel of Karaoke...Brilliant!
Paul, UK


Having been to the Fringe two years in a row I can safely say its been one of the best experiences of my life

Darren Coleman, England
I've just seen the Marx brothers Animal Crackers at C Venues. A real hoot. Groucho is more Groucho than Groucho and the laughs just roll along. A really funny show.
Clive, UK

Some brilliant stuff on this year! Side By Side By Sondheim and Bash and The Latterday Plays are excellent - can't believe either of them are student companies! Both of those are closing on Sat so do try and see them if you're up. Merrily We Roll Along and I Love You You're Perfect, Now Change are both fab too!
Steve, UK

Having been to the Fringe two years in a row I can safely say its been one of the best experiences of my life. How many other places could you say you have sat on stage, holding a microwave, as part of Noble & Silver's act in one show, and walked 100 metres down the road, on the same night and witnessed Trev & Simon riding around on stage on scooters? And that's just the comedy.
Darren Coleman, England

Festival, Smestival. It's one of the main reason's why I left the city. Italians flock around every fast food outlet, ra-ra toffs fill your regular pubs. Arrrrrrrrrgghhhh!!!
Gary Smith, Fife, Scotland


The show Watch Yourself There Now was brilliant fun which I doubt many big name acts could match

Helen, UK
Well, I was brought up in Edinburgh for 17 years, and went to festival for probably 15 of them. Fantastic festival, becomes even better with experience. Don't miss the performance artists on the Mound or the Royal mile. A full day's entertainment in themselves!!
Derek Collie, USA

Being a Fringe regular now, I have to say that it just keeps getting better. It's still a bit rough around the edges, only to be expected from such freedom of performance. We went to see The Unexpected Man and for a fiver we were treated to a performance ten times better than the London equivalent!
Paul McLernan, Scotland

The fringe is a great way to see as many new and up and coming acts as possible, instead of putting up with the usual famous acts who dominate all comic venues. The show Watch Yourself There Now was brilliant fun which I doubt many big name acts could match.
Helen, UK


I think it would be a great idea to be able to buy a type of season ticket that allowed festival goers into many different shows for the first week for a one-off cost of say 50

Ian, Scotland
Although everyone gravitates towards the big-name comedy shows backed by the main promoters, there's a lot of terrific student theatre and comedy at the Fringe which is well worth a look. The Marx Brothers' Animal Crackers was one such show - you couldn't have asked for funnier slapstick or wisecracks!
Helen, UK

I always go to the Fringe on the look out for the smaller acts. For many of them Edinburgh is the performing highlight of their year and it's a chance to get noticed and hit the big-time. Tony Kvetch, Sonny Earle, Gunter V, the list is endless of the comedians who've not been famous but have been very funny. Please support the up-and-coming - it's worth it.
Andrew, UK

As there are so many shows on at the festival, it is very difficult to know what to go and see - I think it would be a great idea to be able to buy a type of season ticket that allowed festival goers into many different shows for the first week for a one-off cost of say 50.

That way, a lot of shows probably wouldn't be playing to empty venues and the paying public would get the chance to see lots of performances - looks like a win-win situation to me
Lan, Scotland


I enjoyed the festival so much that I decided to stay in Edinburgh for the next 18 months!

Fiona Smith, Australia
The festival has thrown up some wonderful comedy over the years. I just feel sorry that this year there seems to be none of the bigger guns. Maybe that's a good thing.

Maybe it's time to unearth the next Tommy Tiernan, Dylan Moran or Sean Hughes. Dan Antonpolski, Brendon Burns, Danny Bhoy amongst others - we are watching.
Mark, Scotland

I saw Tony Winn doing his Singing in the Bath show at South Bridge Resource Centre last Thursday. Very funny, great music, short show at an hour but a bargain at 5. As Alan says, it's worth taking some risks away from the TV stars.
Arthur Smith, UK

I was lucky enough to visit the Fringe festival in 1999. I enjoyed the festival so much that I decided to stay in Edinburgh for the next 18 months! The festival is a brilliant part of Edinburgh lifestyle.
Fiona Smith, Australia

Last year was my first visit to the Fringe - and whilst there where some turkeys there were plenty of outstanding shows - Age of Consent, Falsettoland, Hedwig - to convince me to make an annual pilgrimage. This year I'm looking forward to catching some comedy acts - Jason Byrne, Tina C - and also a couple of plays that have caught my attention - Laramie Project, You Couldn't Make It Up. I've bought tickets for 20 shows in four days... Will I survive?
Peter Eaton, England


Last year I only had one day in Edinburgh. I spent 12 to see a big name TV star and the show was rubbish. I would have been gutted had I not already been to a free comedy show at lunchtime and spent the afternoon in stitches

Alan, England
I think in general it's better to avoid seeing shows with people from the telly - they tend to be fairly jaundiced about the whole thing.

On the other hand if you take some risks with newcomers you can see some real gems. And the atmosphere in the city is great.
Alan, UK

Last year I saw Alan Davies. The tickets were priced fairly high but he was only on for an hour, he repeated more than half of the jokes he had done the last time he was at the festival in 1998, and was grumpy.

He said he hadn't really wanted to come but someone had asked him because it was a comedy anniversary.
Marianne Malone, Scotland

One good tip for seeing the Fringe cheaply: go during the first week and hang out at the larger venues. The comedy promoters give away loads of free tickets, no doubt to bulk up the audience (who enjoys playing to an empty house?) as well as to prompt word-of-mouth recommendations. I saw five shows this way. Not all were brilliant, but one (Andrew Clover's Birthday Party) was so good I went back for a second helping!
Dorothy, Scotland

Last year I only had one day in Edinburgh. I spent 12 to see a big name TV star and the show was rubbish. I would have been gutted had I not already been to a free comedy show at lunchtime and spent the afternoon in stitches. Absolutely hilarious! I guess the lesson is you can't go by name or price but try selecting shows by recommendation. Listen to what other people say is good. And don't be put off the fringe by the odd poor show.
Alan, England

I've never been, but I do have the impression that this festival tends to be aimed at white middle class Radio4 Loose Ends listeners and junior Ned Sherrins, all hoping to be impressarios for all those tedious student junior Stephen Frys of the future.

I'm willing to accept my view is jaundiced so how about some wider coverage of the event (more on terrestrial TV, for example) and I suspect many others with a similar view, and from disparate backgrounds, may be attracted - not least as potential new performers.
Jeremy Whittingham, UK


It rained non-stop and the price of accomodation was ludicrous, but the atmosphere in the city made it all worthwhile

Mark Hudson, England
Love it. The Fringe, the City, the atmosphere. Highlight of the past few years has been the Aussie comic Adam Hills - genius! I will be returning to this beautiful, vibrant City for many years to come.
Joanna, England

There are some great small shows knocking around - they don't all have to shock or be from stand-ups waiting to be discovered. I saw the one man show "The Measure of a Milkman" yesterday in the afternoon - it was really good. My point is that there's more interesting stuff out there if you look beyond the big names.
Charlotte McCain, England

I visited the Fringe for the first time last year and saw six shows in a weekend - five of which were great. I won't forget Polly the Trolley Dolly in a hurry, and the topical sketch and song show, The Treason Show was the highlight of my weekend. It rained non-stop and the price of accomodation was ludicrous, but the atmosphere in the city made it all worthwhile.
Mark Hudson, England

I have been to the festival for three years in a row. I find the atmosphere amazing and look forward to it every year.
Pauline Dickson, Edinburgh


Six Women with Brain Death was fantastic

Caroline, UK
Noel Fielding: insane genius, hilarious. Chris Addison: brilliantly clever, amazingly funny. Phil Nicol: hyperactive, dangerous, literally in-your-face laughs. Recommend all three.
Dave Smith, UK

The Fringe is such an extraordinary phenomenon that, although seeing highlights and reviews on the telly is interesting, you really have to go there to have any idea of what it's like. The high's are just breathtaking, and the low's will give you something to talk about for years. May I recommend Jerry Springer - the Opera to anyone who's not easily offended. Hilarious but filthy.
Jane Trollope, UK

The Marx brothers were a class act, I was laughing into tomorrow. Some other great performances even from street entertainer The Mighty Gareth who was as much comedian as act with his chainsaw juggling finale. Who needs to pay?
Mouse, England

Six Women with Brain Death was fantastic. Both funny and thought-provoking, really worthwhile.
Caroline, UK

Messiaen's Visions de L'Amen performed in a late night concert at the Usher Hall by Peter Donohoe and Martin Roscoe was a sensation - this was music-making at its finest, with musicians and audience alike under the spell of a piece which, as Messaien surely hoped, transcends mere earthly matters.
Hugh Morton, Scotland

Just returned from a weekend. Many great shows, some less good. Worst was Trev and Simon - best joke was when my brother left to "cough his guts up" and Simon thought that he was going for "coffee and some soup"!
Leon Farrar, UK

It's about time they created a separate Comedy Festival. That way the fringe can return to being a showcase for new, cutting edge acts. The big promoters have ruined the whole thing. They charge big money for shows, and take over the bigger venues. Yet the standard isn't that great. I've just seen eight excellent shows at small venues. For some, I WAS the audience! GIVE US BACK OUR TRUE FRINGE... and stop the big boys cashing in.
DJ Richards, Edinburgh, Scotland.

The Cat Must Die at the caves was well worth the trek to the venue, (through dark, dank tunnels.) Despite limited amenities it was carried off with great aplomb. Overall the festival seems somewhat overmanaged this year, detracting from the spontenaity.
Liz, UK

Six Women with Brain Death was fantastic. Both funny and thought-provoking, really worthwhile.
Caroline, UK

As a first time festivel-goer, I was a little overwhelmed and uncertain. I also found it difficult to see what I wanted....but I found a couple of great festival shows including the sublime and hilarious "NiceMum" double act and also the excellent "Sonic Waffle". Excellent stuff and I would recommend it to all!!!
Joe, UK

Third year running and it keeps getting BIGGER and better yet very pleasurable - the banter at the late night and early shows...brilliant craic. The show Nicemum brought comedy to a new level with a duo - a suplime double act. Cracking stuff... more please!!!!!!
Kevin, Ireland

Just came back from an excellent weekend at the Fringe, managing to take in four shows in two days. The best of those four was Closer than Ever, a sophisticated and moving collection of songs, performed by amazingly talented young performers. The four singers completely captivated me, with a beautiful duet by the two girls standing out above all else. This musical has to be seen.
Dan, England

I was a first time fringer last night and it was ab fab, the Royal Mile was lined with quality cool acts, the best a drummer with small beer kegs, and big plastic dustbins...genius... and the comedy in the underbelly is very funny....go and have a ball.
Stevie, Bonnie Scotland

It's fantastic!!! Third year running and it keeps getting BIGGER & better but yet very pleasurable - the banter, the late night and early shows...brilliant craic. The show Nicemum brought comedy to a new level with a duo - a sublime double act. Cracking stuff... more please!!!!!!
Kevin, Ireland

I've just returned from my first Edinburgh experience, and it was well worth the twelve-hour coach journey, both for the shows and the vibrant atmosphere. I saw two excellent productions at the Gilded Balloon: The Cat Must Die, which was energetically performed by a very talented cast and tremendous fun, and Watch Yourself There Now, which was a hilarious and slick satirical affair, even if it did owe more than a little of its brilliance to Chris Morris et al. I am now expecting great things from both casts!
Abi, London, UK

I 'tumbled on the Fringe the first time I was in Edinburgh five years ago, and only got to see two things.

This year I went with the intention of taking in everything I could... but it was pretty expensive, so I only got to see about five or six things in the three days I was there.

Still, special mention to Gyles Brandreth in Zipp!! (100 musicals in 90 minutes), and the free taping of Just a Minute for which we stood in the returns line for two hours! Totally worth it!
Jodi, Canada

Send us your comments:
Name:

Your E-mail Address:


Country:

Comments:

Disclaimer: The BBC will put up as many of your comments as possible but we cannot guarantee that all e-mails will be published. The BBC reserves the right to edit comments that are published.

Coverage of the 2002 Edinburgh Festival from BBC News Online

The buzz

In focus

Fringe diarists

REVIEWS

AROUND THE BBC

WEBSITES

Fireworks at the Palace

Edinburgh festival


Links to more Entertainment stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Entertainment stories

© BBC ^^ Back to top

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East |
South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature |
Technology | Health | Talking Point | Country Profiles | In Depth |
Programmes