BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in:  Entertainment: Film
Front Page 
UK Politics 
TV and Radio 
New Media 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Wednesday, 3 April, 2002, 12:58 GMT 13:58 UK
French film sparks censorship row
Jean-Pierre Leaud (left) and Jeremie Renier
Jean-Pierre Leaud (left) and Jeremie Renier star
An French film called The Pornographer has become the centre of a dispute after censors ordered a graphic sex scene to be cut.

The British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) asked for 11 seconds of an "extremely explicit" sequence to be edited out before they would award it an 18 certificate for a UK release.

Six extra seconds were cut from the film by mistake
Six extra seconds were cut from the film by mistake
That was "outrageous", according to the film's distributors Tartan Metro.

To complicate matters, 17 seconds ended up being cut from the film by mistake, and Tartan Metro are now racing to get the missing six seconds put back in before its release later in April.

The editing was done by an "overzealous editor", Tartan Metro said.

"He is very good at his job, he didn't realise that in film censorship, every second counts," a spokeswoman told BBC News Online.

The film company is now sending the version of the film with the six seconds put back to the BBFC so it classified in time for its release on 19 April.

But Tartan Metro are still angry that any cuts were ordered in the first place, and will put a card at the start of the film to tell people that it has been "butchered" due to "archaic" rules.

'Very upset'

The offending scene, which can be seen in France by anyone over 16, is a crucial moment that is "totally in context", according to the spokeswoman.

It was included when the film was given an award at the Cannes Film Festival 2001 by Fipresci, a federation of international critics.

The film's French director, Bertrand Bonello, said he was "very surprised and upset" at the cuts.

"The film has been sold in over 12 countries and this is the first time such a thing happens," he said.

"With the fine cast of this film, does it make all these people pornographers?"

'Extremely explicit'

The BBFC told BBC News Online the scene featured unsimulated intimate acts.

"It's extremely explicit and we would have quite happily given them a porn rating for it but we did not feel that it was appropriate in a mainstream film," a spokeswoman said.

"People would not expect to see that sort of material."

The film is about a father, a washed-up pornographic film-maker and his son who try to understand each other and build a relationship.

It stars respected actors Jean-Pierre Leaud and Dominique Blanc, who has won four of France's prestigious Cesar Awards.

See also:

26 Feb 01 | Entertainment
Censors snip French shocker
06 Jul 00 | Europe
French film sparks censorship row
27 Oct 00 | UK
Battle over sex videos
27 Sep 00 | Talking Point
Have the film censors got it right?
14 Sep 00 | Entertainment
Censors relax film guidelines
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Film stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Film stories