BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in:  Entertainment: TV and Radio
Front Page 
UK Politics 
TV and Radio 
New Media 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Wednesday, 6 February, 2002, 17:12 GMT
Head-to-head: Pop Idol finalists
Gareth and Will
Gareth and Will vowed to fight fair
The two Pop Idol finalists go head-to-head on Saturday's final as they compete for a lucrative record contract. BBC News Online takes a look at the two contenders, William Young and Gareth Gates.

William Young

William Young made his first big impression by standing up to judge Simon Cowell after he criticised his performance as "distinctly average".

Up until then he had been one of the less outspoken and showy contestants.

But not one to take things lying down, the 23-year-old told Cowell he did not agree with his opinion, much to the delight of the remaining contestants.

And the following week, Cowell was big enough to admit he had been wrong and told a grinning Will, "You've humbled me".

If pop stardom eludes Will he has a politics degree from Exeter University to fall back on and has also studied drama in London.

William Young
Judges have been struck by William's relaxed manner and big grin

One of his biggest fans is twin brother Rupert, who can always be seen in the Pop Idol audience.

Will's first brush with fame came with a contest run on ITV1's This Morning, winning a place in an ill-fated boy band.

All the judges admitted they did not remember Will from the initial Pop Idol rounds as they whittled the wannabes down to the final 50.

He was made to wait in the "maybe" room as the judges decided whether to allow him through to the next round.


He puts his unmemorable early performances down to the fact that he was "rubbish" and only got into the swing of the contest in the later stages.

As 50 were stripped down to 10, Will's talent began to shine through as he put his own spin on tunes.

A favourite week for him was when a live big band were brought in to accompany them.

Will came across as a natural crooner and admitted he was more comfortable with older songs than other music he has had to perform such as Abba.

His trademark big smile was as wide as ever as he took the performance in his stride.

From the outset it looked as if 17-year-old Gareth would be crowned runaway winner.

But in the final stages of the competition there has been an added air of excitement as Will has crept up in the stakes.

At one point he was tipped by the bookies to go on to win but once again Gareth is in front as the two go head-to-head.

The two candidates are completely different in style, looks and sound.

Will does not share Gareth's boyish good looks and trademark spiky hairdo but has a big voice, big smile and bigger personality, which his rival struggles to show because of his speech problems.

Gareth Gates

Gareth Gates has secured the most headlines since he started his quest to become a star.

Audiences were surprised the Bradford teenager had such a powerful singing voice after struggling to even introduce himself to the judges during the opening heats.

The 17-year-old has been blighted by a severe stutter since he was young and despite intensive therapy he still has enormous trouble with public speaking.

But this has endeared him to audiences further because of his bravery in putting himself through such a public contest, knowing he may not be able to speak at crucial moments.

His biggest setback was appearing at the first Pop Idol press conference and not being able to answer questions from journalists.

Gareth Gates
Gareth has excelled as singing Westlife songs
But amazingly the stutter disappears as soon as he opens his mouth to sing.

Gareth has not been afraid to show his emotion on live television.

He memorably cried when his closest friend from the show Zoe Birkett was voted off, sparking rumours they were in a relationship.

It was his tear-stained face that adorned the front pages the next day, rather than that of the defeated Zoe.

And Gareth has shared the hard work of trying to overcome his stutter with viewers.


He has admitted the rollercoaster that has been Pop Idol has got the way of his therapy, making him slip back into old habits.

The judges have constantly commented Gareth has what it takes to go all the way, with both his voice and look.

His own idol is Robbie Williams, although Britney Spears wins his vote for best looking star.

Gareth is a former choirboy who once sang for the Queen at Bradford Cathedral.

He has had several cracks at telly talent searches, appearing on Steps II the Stars and Michael Barrymore's My Kind of Music.

Gareth cried on live television when his friend Zoe was voted off
He is keen to tell people he is not just a pretty pop face and spends his spare time writing his own material.

The singer comes from a large family with three younger sisters as well as three foster siblings.

Screaming girls

He is studying for his A-Levels in Bradford, although it is unlikely he will complete his education if he wins a recording contract through the show.

He says that apart from his love of singing, he would love to be famous so he could help other people and donate money to charity.

As part of his pledge to Pop Idol voters, Gareth has promised not to let fame go to his head, despite adoring girls already screaming his name whenever he is out.

His shy and sensitive manner, along with boy band good looks could be enough to keep him in the lead.

Is Pop Idol getting too much attention?



5915 Votes Cast

Results are indicative and may not reflect public opinion

See also:

04 Feb 02 | TV and Radio
Pop Idol stars campaign for votes
02 Feb 02 | TV and Radio
Darius out of Pop Idol
02 Feb 02 | Music
Rik faces Pop Idol legal threat
28 Jan 02 | TV and Radio
Pop Idol audience reaches 10 million
23 Jan 02 | TV and Radio
Pop Idol: What's all the fuss about?
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more TV and Radio stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more TV and Radio stories