BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: Entertainment: Music
Front Page 
UK Politics 
TV and Radio 
New Media 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Thursday, 24 January, 2002, 18:01 GMT
Mariah's lawyers threaten to sue
Carey was dropped after poor sales of her last album
Carey was dropped after poor sales of her last album
Lawyers for singer Mariah Carey are threatening to sue her former record company, EMI, for saying it "terminated" her contract.

They are angry that EMI announced it was terminating the pop diva's 70m five-album deal, instead of the agreed wording - "cancelled".

The news from EMI that it was letting Carey go followed the poor reception of her last album Glitter, which sold 500,000 copies in the US.

Carey's lawyers say pay-out was closer to $50m
Carey's lawyers say her pay-out was closer to $50m
Both parties had issued a joint press release saying the contract had been "cancelled".

But EMI then followed London Stock Exchange rules by disclosing the deal in a separate announcement hours before Americans were awake, saying the contract had been "terminated".

Carey's lawyer Marshall Grossman said that was "deplorable".

"We are appalled that EMI would deal so cavalierly with these issues and do so less than 24 hours after the parties had finalised their agreement and settled the exact terms of the joint press statement," he said.


But EMI's lawyer, Bert Fields, said the label had done no wrong.

"Certainly, it was not EMI's position that Ms. Carey was fired or anything like that, and there was no intention to create that impression," he added.

Mr Grossman also questioned the amount EMI is paying to release Carey from her contract.

The record company said it was $28m, but her lawyers argue that the amount does not take into account the $21m (14.7m) Carey kept for making the failed Glitter album, minimising the losses suffered by EMI.

Mariah's film Glitter was a big flop at the cinema
Mariah's film Glitter was a big flop at the cinema
The music giants are threatening to counter-sue the singer, if Carey's lawyers go ahead with court action.

Mr Fields said: "We will file a cross-complaint saying Ms Carey's representatives were making a lot of inflammatory statements around the world on Thursday which go way beyond the agreed press release."

This news comes at a bad time for Carey who is still recovering from a turbulent 2001.

She suffering an emotional breakdown which led her to check into a clinic to recover. The singer was placed in psychiatric care in August after suffering from "extreme exhaustion".

Her first major film, also called Glitter, was postponed until she was well enough to promote it.

But bad reviews ensured it did not recoup its money at the box office.

The movie, which cost $22m (15.4m) to make, made just $4m (2.8m) back in its US run.

See also:

24 Jan 02 | Music
Mariah tipped for comeback
23 Jan 02 | Music
What next for Mariah?
23 Jan 02 | Music
EMI drops Mariah Carey
07 Sep 01 | Reviews
Mariah Carey: Your views
07 Sep 01 | Reviews
Glitter fails to shine
02 Aug 01 | Showbiz
Mariah Carey in psychiatric care
27 Feb 00 | Entertainment
Mariah Carey wows the stars
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Music stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Music stories