BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: Entertainment
Front Page 
UK Politics 
TV and Radio 
New Media 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Saturday, 20 January, 2001, 08:43 GMT
Battle of the bulletins
michael buerk
Ten O'Clock News faces News at Ten three times a week
By BBC media correspondent Torin Douglas

It has been called a small piece of broadcasting history - the first head-on "battle of the bulletins" on Britain's two most popular television channels.

But what impact will the clash between ITV's revived News at Ten and the BBC's Ten O'Clock News have on viewers?

There have been complaints from politicians and the National Consumer Council that there will now be less choice for viewers - particularly those without multi-channel TV, who cannot watch the 24-hour news channels from the BBC, Sky or ITN.

Instead of deciding when to watch the evening news, terrestrial viewers must take it at 10pm.

It is our time and we look forward to reclaiming it

News at Ten presenter, Trevor McDonald

And the chance to watch both bulletins - for the really keen - will be removed.

Yet some say the move could increase news audiences overall, helping buck the trend of recent years.

ITV's bulletin is on an hour earlier than it has been, when more people are available to view.

And neither bulletin now has to face such ferocious competition on the other major channel.

Instead of competing with huge ITV ratings-winners like Inspector Frost or Who Wants To Be A Millionaire?, the BBC Ten O'Clock News will be facing News at Ten on three nights a week.

And ITV's news - which was moved to 11pm because so many viewers were switching away from the 10pm bulletin - will also be more protected.
Trevor McDonald
McDonald: 'Delighted'

Yet inevitably attention will focus on which bulletin performs better - in ratings and in news coverage.

Both sides are bullish.

Traditionally, News at Ten and its presenter Trevor McDonald got more viewers than the old BBC Nine O'Clock News.

"I'm delighted to be back in the 10 o'clock slot," he said.

"It is our time and we look forward to reclaiming it."

Inheriting millions of viewers from Who Wants To Be A Millionaire? and Peak Practice this week will be no handicap.

The size of a news bulletin's audience is heavily dependent on the programmes that precede it.

We want to be more ambitious than ITV, with more specialist correspondents, a broader agenda and more intelligent coverage

BBC's head of television news, Roger Mosey

But the BBC is confident too.

It points out that the new News at Ten is shorter than the old - 20 minutes, including advertisements - and that it is at 10pm on just three days in the first week.

"They don't seem wholehearted about it," said the BBC's head of television news Roger Mosey.

"The BBC Ten O'Clock News is a 32-minute bulletin, including regional coverage - and we want to be more ambitious than ITV, with more specialist correspondents, a broader agenda and more intelligent coverage."

Inevitably, the journalistic rivalry will be intense as the bulletins go head-to-head.

Some fear there could be a "news war", with a frantic search for sensational exclusives.
chris smith
Smith: Criticised the BBC

The 10pm slot is ideal for pre-empting the following morning's newspapers - and stories that have been embargoed for publication the next day.

The irony is that most viewers will not be comparing the rival bulletins, because they will be on at the same time.

But journalists, spin-doctors and other professional media-watchers will - and so will the BBC governors and the culture secretary Chris Smith.

Last autumn, he welcomed ITV's move to 10pm and criticised the BBC's, blaming the corporation for the head-on clash - even though it announced its move first.

Politically sensitive

That makes the outcome of the battle politically sensitive.

The BBC insists it is going to judge the success of its news move over a couple of years, not a couple of weeks.

It hopes its other changes to BBC One - including a fourth EastEnders and investment in new dramas and comedy - will kick in this autumn, bolstering the news audience.

But others are likely to judge the outcome more quickly.

See also:

14 Nov 00 | UK
News At Ten rethink urged
17 Oct 00 | Entertainment
Honours even in ratings war
16 Oct 00 | Entertainment
News move sparks ratings battle
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Entertainment stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Entertainment stories