Page last updated at 15:14 GMT, Friday, 11 September 2009 16:14 UK

Rover bosses attacked over payout

Rover worker on the report: 'What a waste of money'

Bosses running carmaker MG Rover - which collapsed with the loss of 6,500 jobs - gave themselves "unreasonably large" payouts, a report has found.

Pay and pensions worth £42m was shared by five executives, which inspectors said was "out of all proportion".

The executives described the report, which cost £16m, as a "witchhunt" and a "whitewash for the government".

Business Secretary Lord Mandelson demanded an apology from the men, who face a ban from running other firms.

He said he would go to the courts if necessary to stop them managing companies in future.

But experts questioned whether the report provided sufficient grounds for disqualifying the men and suggested any ban was unlikely to be for more than five years.

The demise of MG Rover brought an end to mass production of cars by a UK company.

But the former executives - the so-called Phoenix Four and the chief executive they employed to run the company - said their payouts were not the reason for the collapse.

"The real reason is the government bungled the last chance to save MG Rover," said chief executive Kevin Howe, chairman John Towers, ex-vice-chairman Nick Stephenson, Peter Beale and John Edwards.

FINANCIAL REWARD
Peter Beale £8.981m
John Edwards £9.024m
Nick Stephenson £8.976m
John Towers £8.958m
Kevin Howe £5.708m
Source: MG Rover report

Data erasing

The Serious Fraud Office (SFO) has said it does not intend to launch a criminal investigation into the collapse, which saw about 6,500 people lose their jobs.

The 830-page report, by two government-appointed inspectors, took four years to produce and cost about £16m. It contains little criticism of the government.

Other findings include:

  • Mr Beale bought software to "clean" data from his personal computer, a day after investigators were appointed, "despite being aware that we would want to image and then review the contents of his computer for documents relevant to our investigation"
  • Mr Stephenson paid more than £1.6m to a consultant he had a "personal relationship" with
  • Executives had exaggerated in statements to MPs the personal financial risks they were taking
  • MPs investigating the demise of the firm were given "inaccurate and misleading information" by Mr Beale
  • There was evidence of a questionable briefing to the press by an adviser to former Trade Secretary Patricia Hewitt.

The issue of remuneration attracted most criticism in the government-commissioned report by Gervase MacGregor of accountants BDO Stoy Hayward and Guy Newey QC.

MG ROVER'S DEMISE
2000: Sold by BMW to the Phoenix Four for £10
2000-2004: Made losses of £611m in the first four years
2004: Started talks with Shanghai Automotive Industry Corporation (SAIC)
2005: SAIC pulled out of a deal to save the whole company and MG Rover goes into administration
2006: MG Rover's assets sold to Nanjing Automobile
2007: Nanjing resumes MG production at the Longbridge plant
2009: Serious Fraud Office investigates circumstances of collapse but says no plans for criminal charges
2009: Long-awaited report, which has cost more than £16m, is released


The five "obtained large, and we say unreasonably large, financial rewards, totalling tens of millions of pounds" between 2000 and 2005, the report said.

They also "chose to give themselves rewards out of all proportion to the incomes which they had previously commanded, which were also large when compared with remuneration paid in other companies and which were not obviously demanded by their qualifications and experience", it added.

Had the venture succeeded, there would have been little objection to the rewards, the inspectors suggested, but said MG Rover was "in fact very unprofitable and eventually went into administration".

Bridging loan

The four took control of MG Rover in May 2000 after buying it from previous owner BMW for a nominal £10, also getting an interest free 49-year loan of £427m from the German carmaker.

The executives were eventually unable to turn around MG Rover's fortunes and it went into administration under insolvency procedures in April 2005, with debts of more than £1bn.

Its assets were subsequently sold in 2006 to China's Nanjing Automobile, which revived the MG sports car brand, but moved most of the production to China. Before its demise, MG Rover had held talks about a joint venture with the Shanghai Automotive Industrial Corporation (SAIC).

The report said that the government could not be blamed for the collapse of those talks - and that SAIC had lost interest in Rover.

The UK had been "seriously" considering offering a £100m bridging loan to aid the deal - but decided there was little realistic prospect of it being repaid.

"To make a loan in such circumstances could hardly have been a proper use of public funds and would (as we understand it) have been illegal under EU law", the report said.


Have you been affected by the issues in this story? Are you a current or former MG Rover employee? Send us your views.

Name
Your E-mail address
Town & Country
Phone number (optional):
Comments

The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published. Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide.




Print Sponsor


RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

BBC navigation

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific