Page last updated at 14:59 GMT, Thursday, 11 June 2009 15:59 UK

Ferrero cleared of hazelnut fraud

By Anthony Reuben
Business reporter, BBC News

Ferrero Rocher advert 1993: a kitsch classic

Confectioner Ferrero has been cleared of allegations of fraud relating to the supply of hazelnuts.

The case arose after two banks lent 22.8m euros ($40.4m; £24.5m) to a Turkish firm that was the world's biggest hazelnut supplier at the time.

The firm, Baskan Gida, used the money to buy hazelnuts, but then transferred them to a second company, which meant the banks did not get their money back.

The banks had alleged that Ferrero had been involved in the switch.

'Enormously expensive'

But the judge Mr Justice Briggs did not agree with the case, which was brought by Bank of Tokyo Mitsubishi and KBC Bank, and cleared Ferrero, the company behind Ferrero Rocher chocolates as well as Nutella spread and Tic-tacs.

Mr Briggs handed down a 272-page judgment describing the trial as being "very long and no doubt enormously expensive".

The judge ruled that another defendant, Shabbir Abidali, had been involved in the conspiracy.

There will be another hearing at the end of the month to decide how much Mr Abidali will have to pay, although the judge said he would not be liable for the full 22.8m euros.

The hearing will also decide who will have to pay the costs of the case.

High costs

The case has been going on for seven years and has been in court for a total of 84 days since October, so the costs are expected to be greater than the 22.8m euros the banks lost in the first place.

A parallel trial going on Italy recently estimated that Ferrer's total costs, including the trial in London, could be around 11m euros.

The banks and Mr Abidali will also have to decide whether they want to appeal against the judgement.

Hazelnuts
Turkey grows 70% to 75% of the world's hazelnuts

The judge decided that three Ferrero witnesses - Antonio Do, Rosa Brunet and Alessio Casale - had all deliberately lied to the court.

Mr Brunet has now retired and the other two are still working for Ferrero.

Mr Briggs decided that they had lied about certain aspects of Ferrero's relationship with Baskan Gida, to protect the reputation of Ferrero, but he decided that did not mean that Ferrero had been trying to defraud the banks.

But the company defended its employees.

"Ferrero remains of the view that all of its personnel acted properly and with integrity throughout," said its solicitor Andrew Howell of Barlow Lyde & Gilbert.

The judge also said that Mr Abidali was "not an honest man", having created and backdated documents "which were plainly designed to give a false and misleading impression".

Mr Abidali's solicitors, Steptoe & Johnson, said: "Our client's position is that he has acted honestly and in good faith throughout."

As for the members of the Baskan family in Turkey that owned Baskan Gida, the judge ruled that they had indeed successfully defrauded the banks.

They were named as defendants in the case, but did not turn up at any of the proceedings and the judge concluded that they had probably not managed to make enough money out of the fraud to be worth pursuing through the Turkish legal system.

"Even if a judgment in these proceedings could be enforced against them in Turkey, it is unlikely that any of them are worth powder and shot," he said.



Print Sponsor


SEE ALSO
Ferrero accused in hazelnut fraud
04 May 09 |  Business

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

FROM OTHER NEWS SITES
The Scotsman Sweet news for Ferrero Rocher as it is cleared in fraud case - 39 hrs ago
The Times Ferrero Rocher cleared of 20m hazelnut fraud - 47 hrs ago



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

BBC navigation

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific