BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Friday, 23 November 2007, 13:08 GMT
Qinetiq deal 'cost UK taxpayers'
Qinetiq at Portsdown Hill near Portsmouth
Qinetiq makes a number of military products
UK taxpayers could have gained "more money" from the privatisation of defence research firm Qinetiq, the National Audit Office (NAO) has said.

While saying taxpayers could have gained "tens of millions" more, the NAO also condemned an incentive scheme that netted fortunes for Qinetiq's bosses.

The government defended the sale and said it was excellent value for money.

But Lord Moonie, the minister behind the original sale to a US buyout firm, said that he had tried to delay it.

He was a defence minister in 2003 when a third of Qinetiq was sold to the US private equity group, Carlyle, for 42m.

Stock markets had slumped and Lord Moonie felt that the Ministry of Defence (MOD) would not receive a decent price for its shareholding, said BBC business editor Robert Peston.

But he was unable to resist Treasury pressure for the sale, Lord Moonie told the BBC.

"We were reluctant to proceed with the sale, but a combination of the Treasury and the fact we needed the money for items in our budget persuaded us to go on with it," said Lord Moonie.


Carlyle's one third of Qinetiq grew in value to 372m, giving it a nine-fold return on its money.

BBC business editor Robert Peston
The increase in value of Qinetiq as it moved into the private sector has actually generated very good returns for the taxpayer
Robert Peston, BBC business editor

Qinetiq's 10 most senior managers gained 107.5m after the move, a return of 19,990% for their total 540,000 investment in shares, a return labelled "excessive" by the NAO.

Qinetiq's two most senior executives, chairman Sir John Chisholm and chief executive Graham Love, made spectacular gains.

Sir John invested 129,000 in the company and now has shares worth 23m. Graham Love turned 106,000 into 20m.

Qinetiq's bosses were allowed to negotiate the terms of the incentive scheme with Carlyle while the private equity firm was bidding for the business, the NAO added.

This deal didn't sell the family silver; it gave it away
Vince Cable MP

Conservative MP Edward Leigh, chairman of the Commons Public Accounts Committee, said the taxpayer had been "short-changed" and that top Qinetiq managers had "won the jackpot".

The Liberal Democrats said the deal amounted to giving away "the family silver".

Acting leader Vince Cable said: "It is completely unacceptable that the government has sold off a valuable national asset for a pittance, providing huge profits for the Carlyle group and the senior civil servants involved.

"This deal didn't sell the family silver; it gave it away."

Good value?

But the Ministry of Defence has defended the deal.

"It has delivered excellent value for money, generating more than 800m for the taxpayer, while protecting UK defence and security interests," said Baroness Taylor, Minister for Defence Equipment and Support.

She added that she is constrained by what she is allowed to say ahead of a hearing by the Public Accounts Committee in December.

Criticism of the deal will infuriate many business people, said the BBC's Peston.

"Although they acknowledge that Carlyle secured the stake at a great price, they point out that the MoD kept more than half of Qinetiq," he said.

"So the increase in value of Qinetiq as it moved into the private sector has actually generated very good returns for the taxpayer."

Former Defence Minister Lord Moonie on his role in the deal

Profit up at defence firm Qinetiq
07 Jun 06 |  Business
Market debut for Qinetiq shares
10 Feb 06 |  Business
Reid defends Qinetiq's sale price
27 Jan 06 |  Business
Qinetiq names float price range
25 Jan 06 |  Business
Government 'to sell off Qinetiq'
08 Jan 06 |  Business
Qinetiq's new battle
30 Apr 02 |  Business

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific