[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Friday, 12 October 2007, 01:24 GMT 02:24 UK
Action urged on footballer investment
By Bill Wilson
Business reporter, BBC News

The thorny issue of third-party ownership of players - whereby private investors own part of a player's rights - is in the spotlight again, more than a year after the transfer of two Argentines to England brought the matter to UK attention.

Former West Ham players Tevez and Mascherano
Calm before storm: Tevez and Mascherano sign for West Ham

Then, the move by Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano from Brazil to West Ham United set in train issues that ended up being decided in front of courts and tribunals.

Despite the furore, Kia Joorabchian - the man who brought the players to the UK - recently told the BBC he believed that the practice was still widespread.

Indeed, it is not illegal, as long as the investor does not attempt to influence club playing or transfers, or indeed any other club policy.

During their stab at English and European glory at the turn of the millennium, Leeds United were known to buy players with the aid of third-party investors.

Clause in Tevez deal said third party could move player on
This is against Premier League rules
Rules state third party cannot "materially influence" club policy or performance
Rule first brought in to deal with firms owning more than one club
West Ham admitted it was in breach of rules
Club fined 5.5m for this and for hiding deal from league

But this week, world governing body Fifa expressed serious concerns over third-party ownership of players.

Its strategic committee said that a result of the Tevez case, action was now called for as regards third-party ownership of players.

The committee said Fifa was working on a "simple and effective" solution as part of a general review of transfer regulations.

However, at present, Fifa has no rule expressly prohibiting third-party ownership of players - and in Latin American countries, third-party ownership is common.

'Source of income'

In Argentina, Uruguay and Brazil, such deals are allowed and are widespread - in fact, they started in South America. Tevez and Mascherano came to London from Brazilian club Corinthians.

For clubs in Brazil, 50% of income comes from transfers, making players a valuable commodity for clubs, and 35% comes from TV money, with just 15% from ticketing.

The Maracana stadium in Rio de Janeiro
Brazilian clubs cannot survive on their gate and ticket revenues

Lawyer Jose Carlos Meirelles of firm Pinheiro Neto Advogados in Brazil, which represents soccer investors, says: "Production of new players for transfer is the major source of income for clubs in South America.

"The positive is that clubs are always searching for new talent and might need a third-party investor to help fund that player.

"The downside is that clubs are selling their rights in the player to investors an early stage.

"In Brazil, the concept is that there should not be an influence in player sales. But there could be conditions of the transfer that could be agreed with the investor," he told delegates at a World Sports Law Report event in London.

Investor holds part of commercial rights to a player
Rights can be owned by individual, firm, bank or fund
Investor can help a cash-strapped club buy player
Deal allows investor to make return if player sold on
Investor not allowed to dictate transfer policy
Investor cannot hold the player's registration
Investor can also buy other interests, such as image rights

"For example, the investor can't put an onward transfer price in the contract, but they can stipulate things such as stating that the transfer should be to a club outside Brazil."

He adds: "In Brazil, we had some people [who] invested in football who really hurt the clubs.

"There has to be some sort of global corporate governance."

In Italy, as in Brazil and England, investors can make a return from funding a transfer to a club.

The Italian FA also does not allow external interference in the club's market choice if it sells the player on.

'Punish breaches'

In England, the Premier League's recently-revamped rules, L4, V8 and V20, ban any club from entering contracts that allow third parties "to acquire the ability materially to influence its policies or the performance of its teams".

In addition, all documents pertaining to third-party influence and ownership must be submitted to the Premier League.

These are areas that created problems for West Ham United and its contract with Mr Joorabchian's firms, leading to calls for Fifa to clarify its rules on third-party ownership of players.

Premier League chief executive Richard Scudamore was one of those who spoke on the matter recently to Fifa's strategic committee.

Club may refuse to transfer player
Club may divert part of transfer fee (eg in package deals)
A transfer may not be in investor's interest
Player may refuse to be transferred
Player may lose form or be injured

The FA has also invested in its compliance unit, to provide it with "more forensic accountancy'', and wants Fifa to "get involved'' over third-party ownership.

It has also introduced a blanket ban on agents owning a stake in the players they are responsible for advising.

But Stephen Joelson, partner at Clintons Solicitors, says what is needed is not necessarily more new rules.

"The issue of rights is the same as in all businesses. Breaches should be punished, not dealt with through other new rules," he says.

"Football is becoming increasingly a business. As long as we have investment, appropriate levels of debt, and people in the sport for the right reasons, then that is fine.

Norwich City chief executive Neil Doncaster
Norwich City chief executive Neil Doncaster

"But it is up to the regulatory bodies to make sure the right people are in control."

Meanwhile, Mr Joorabchian, the agent who brought Carlos Tevez to West Ham says: 'I know a lot of players in the Premier League - and other leagues - which are here in the same format as we have done, but in a hidden scheme."

One chief executive in the Football League Championship, Norwich City chairman Neil Doncaster, has no doubts that third-party investment is a modern fact.

"The reality is that there are already 'third parties' who have interests in players in this country," says Mr Doncaster.

Joorabchian ponders new takeover
28 Sep 07 |  Football Focus
Tevez saga prompts rule changes
09 Aug 07 |  Premier League
West Ham not to appeal over fine
09 May 07 |  West Ham Utd
West Ham sign Tevez & Mascherano
31 Aug 06 |  West Ham Utd


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific