Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Business
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Market Data 
Your Money 
Business Basics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
Wednesday, 26 January, 2000, 15:07 GMT
Court blow for Microsoft

Sun claims Microsoft saw its software as a threat

A Federal Judge has ruled that Microsoft must use a standard version of the Java software created by Sun Microsystems.

The move is the latest twist in a court case between the two software giants.

Sun filed a suit against Microsoft in 1997 for violating a licensing agreement. It accused Microsoft of having changed its Java software to undermine efforts to create a standard version.

Sun claims that Microsoft changed Java as it feared that the increasingly popular software could challenge the dominance of Microsoft's Windows operating system.

Tuesday's ruling was a reinstatement of an injunction that had been overthrown in the appeals court in November.

The judge however ruled that the dispute did not involve an infringement of copyright law, as Sun claims, but a contract dispute.

The court has yet to make a final ruling on the case.

Victory for who?

Both sides claim victory.

Sun says the issue is copyright infringement, while Microsoft says it is simply a contract dispute.

"This reflects the status quo and Microsoft is already in compliance with the order," Microsoft spokesman Jim Cullinan said in a statement.

"This strikes fundamentally at the heart of Sun's position in this case and supports Microsoft's oft-stated position that this is a contract dispute between two large and sophisticated companies," he said.

The ruling does not require Microsoft to recall any products, he added.

Sun says the ruling supports its claim that Microsoft engaged in unfair business practice.

"As we have said from the start of this case, Microsoft's misconduct with respect to Sun's Java technology has harmed competition, as well as those who use and rely on the Java technology," Sun attorney Michael Morris said.

Microsoft courtcase

Microsoft is also awaiting the outcome of an ongoing anti-trust case.

A US judge ruled last year that the company held a monopoly position which it used to harm competition and consumers.

That case is now in settlement talks and is expected to return to court on 22 February

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console

See also:
14 Jan 00 |  Business
Microsoft's next move
11 Jan 00 |  Business
Microsoft settles Caldera antitrust case
14 Jan 00 |  The Company File
The software superpower
13 Jan 00 |  Business
Microsoft 'facing split'
13 Jan 00 |  Business
Gates steps down - but the fight goes on
13 Jan 00 |  Business
Caldera vs Microsoft - the settlement
05 Nov 99 |  The Company File
Monopoly blow for Microsoft
06 Nov 99 |  The Company File
Ruling shakes Microsoft
06 Nov 99 |  The Company File
US Government hails monopoly ruling
07 Dec 99 |  Business
US v Microsoft: The mediator
15 Oct 99 |  The Company File
Sun calls for Microsoft to be kept intact

Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
Links to other Business stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Business stories