[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Monday, 6 March 2006, 22:29 GMT
Blackberry users stay connected
Blackberry devices are used by three million people in the US
The boss of the firm behind the Blackberry e-mail device says it came through its marathon patent dispute battle without losing a customer.

Canadian firm Research In Motion (RIM) reached a $612.5m (349m) settlement with patent-holding firm NTP, averting the possible closure of its US service.

Despite the uncertainty, chairman Jim Balsillie said RIM had not lost any of its four million users.

He said that the settlement costs would be paid from RIM's $1.8bn cash pile.

The settlement brought to an end four years of legal disputes with NTP, which claimed that RIM's technology infringed on its patents.

Patent trolls

Although the US patent office had yet to issue a final ruling on whether the patents were valid, a jury found against RIM three years ago.

A judge in a US district court had threatened RIM with an injunction to block its US service if the two sides could not resolve the dispute out of court.

"I am not angry, but basically we took one for the team," Mr Balsillie told the BBC.

"The uncertainty was interrupting our business, so we made the sacrifice. But it is not something we feel all that good about."

Some experts have hit out at "patent troll" companies like NTP, saying they acquire and use patents just to sue companies that actually make products and generate revenue.

They are particularly unhappy that in such patent cases firms are able to obtain injunctions that can then threaten a company's entire business.

RIM chairman and CEO Jim Balsillie
RIM boss Jim Balsillie said Blackberry customers stayed loyal

The Supreme Court is due to hear a similar case soon involving eBay and a patent-holding company called MercExchange.

"We feel the system has been manipulated," said Mr Balsillie.

"We shouldn't have to pay for the predictability of our business."

Looking forward, he said RIM had not lost ground to rivals like Nokia, Motorola and Microsoft.

He said the company would push on towards its five millionth customer later in 2006 and would continue to offer new web applications like Google Local, which provides a local mapping service for mobile phones.

The background to the Blackberry row

Settlement ends Blackberry case
06 Mar 06 |  Business
Blackberry wins stay of execution
24 Feb 06 |  Business
Minor victory for Blackberry firm
23 Feb 06 |  Business
Blackberry plan to avoid shutdown
09 Feb 06 |  Business
Washington steps in on Blackberry
02 Feb 06 |  Business
Court blow for Blackberry maker
23 Jan 06 |  Business
Patent worries fail to dent RIM
22 Dec 05 |  Business

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific