[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Friday, 24 February 2006, 22:09 GMT
Blackberry wins stay of execution
Blackberry user at the 3GSM conference in Barcelona
Blackberry devices are used by three million people in the US
The maker of the Blackberry device has won a stay of execution after a US judge opted not to impose an immediate injunction closing its service.

Research In Motion (RIM) is embroiled in a legal dispute with technology firm NTP, which says the Blackberry has infringed its patents.

Blackberry could have been forced to shut down its mobile e-mail service in the US immediately.

But Judge James Spencer said he would consider an injunction in the future.

No ruling

He said that RIM had infringed NTP's patents and that he would rule on an injunction as "soon as reasonably possible" but did not indicate when he might do so.

RIM's shares closed up 6.5% at $74.05 after the firm escaped immediate sanction.

The BBC's North America business correspondent, Guto Harri, said many Americans welcomed the development as if hearing good news about their health or their family.

Switching off the US service would have caused misery for more than three million users, he said.

I was given a Blackberry by my new employers - how intrusive... Not a fan!
Adam, London

RIM claims to have a software patch that would enable its handheld e-mail devices to work even if the ruling goes against it.

Legal experts said they expected the judge would press both sides to settle the dispute out of court.

"He certainly wants them to settle," Steve Maebius, a patent lawyer with Foley & Lardner, told Reuters.

"He is giving them one more chance to do that."


Canada-based RIM said recently that it was negotiating with NTP, but described the US firm's offer to license the disputed technology as "untenable".

The tussle between the two companies dates back to 2002, when patent-holding company NTP successfully sued RIM in a lower court.

The two firms agreed a tentative settlement last year but the agreement subsequently collapsed.

Earlier this month, the US government asked a federal judge to hold off from a possible shutdown of the Blackberry service, because of the system's popularity among key government employees.

RIM has argued that a shutdown of Blackberry services would impair critical public services.

The background to the Blackberry row

Minor victory for Blackberry firm
23 Feb 06 |  Business
Blackberry plan to avoid shutdown
09 Feb 06 |  Business
Washington steps in on Blackberry
02 Feb 06 |  Business
Court blow for Blackberry maker
23 Jan 06 |  Business
Patent worries fail to dent RIM
22 Dec 05 |  Business
Court blow for Blackberry maker
30 Nov 05 |  Business

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific