[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 21 April, 2005, 12:20 GMT 13:20 UK
Chelsea chief: Man Utd vulnerable
By Bill Wilson
BBC News business reporter at the Soccerex conference

Chelsea chief executive Peter Kenyon
Mr Kenyon said key decisions at Chelsea are made by three people
Chelsea chief executive Peter Kenyon has said that publicly-listed clubs such as Manchester United will always be vulnerable to potential takeovers.

United's board is considering a third takeover offer from US billionaire Malcolm Glazer, with fans campaigning against the proposed 800m move.

Mr Kenyon quit as Old Trafford chief to take over at Stamford Bridge in 2003.

Now he has questioned whether the public-quoted structure is right for football clubs.

'In play'

Mr Kenyon was speaking at the Soccerex football finance seminar in London, attended by delegates from top clubs, federations and football businesses.

"As a public company you are always in play and in terms of long-term planning that makes life difficult," he said.
As a private business it means literally three of us (at Chelsea) can decide what to do
Peter Kenyon, Chelsea chief executive

"I am not sure if the public-quoted structure is right for football clubs," he said. "Within the industry, the preference would always be for private ownership over public.

"Look at the Malcolm Glazer situation and the quandary of the Manchester United board where if they recommend the offer they will have the anger of the fans to deal with."

'Golden goose'

He questioned the benefit to clubs of going public.

"There was a time that it was seen as the golden goose for clubs to go to the market," he said.

Clubs with listed shares
Arsenal (Holdings)
Aston Villa
Birmingham City
Celtic
Charlton Athletic
Heart of Midlothian
Manchester United
Manchester City - Ofex
Millwall (Holdings)
Newcastle United
Preston North End
Rangers - Ofex
Sheffield United
Southampton (Leisure)
Tottenham Hotspur
Watford (Leisure)
West Bromwich Albion

He said that when Manchester United went to the market, it was already a well-run club that had invested in the stadium, players and facilities from within its own earnings.

"Manchester United gained liquidity in shares, which allowed some money to go to key shareholders, but apart from about 16m, the bulk of the 150-160m we invested in players and stadia came from within the football club."

The Chelsea chief also claimed that key shareholders, rather than the club, were the ones to benefit from going public.

"Going to the market doesn't necessarily mean you have a well-run business. Most clubs that have gone to market have failed.

"Being private means you don't have external pressures. Manchester United are always in line for a potential takeover, first there was BSkyB, and now there is Malcolm Glazer," he said.

Private ownership boon?

He compared it with the situation at Stamford Bridge, which is privately owned by Russian tycoon Roman Abramovich.

"As a private business, it means literally three of us (at Chelsea) can decide what to do."

He was referring to himself, Mr Abramovich, and team manager Jose Mourinho.

Mr Kenyon, who was recently criticised by Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson over restaurant meetings with United's Rio Ferdinand, said there was a five-year plan for the Blues, which he hopes would see the business become profitable by 2009.

He also said the club would focus on four key markets, "London, Russia, where we feel we have a competitive advantage, China - not Asia - and north America."




SEE ALSO:
Chelsea deny Ferdinand interest
18 Apr 05 |  Chelsea
Man Utd board mulls Glazer offer
15 Apr 05 |  Business
Man Utd weighs Glazer's approach
14 Apr 05 |  Business
Chelsea makes 'biggest ever' loss
29 Jan 05 |  Business
Football improving business sense
25 Nov 04 |  Business


RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


PRODUCTS AND SERVICES

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific