BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in:  Business
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Market Data 
Your Money 
Business Basics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Tuesday, 30 April, 2002, 07:04 GMT 08:04 UK
Qinetiq's new battle
Qinetiq 1 balloon
Qinetiq scientists have more than 5,000 patents
test hello test
By James Arnold
BBC News Online business reporter

Getting into Qinetiq's Farnborough headquarters isn't easy; bags are searched, credentials pored over, cameras and recording equipment painstakingly vetted.

Qinetiq: Key facts
800m turnover
8,500 staff in 42 UK locations
5,000 patents granted/applied for
20 "spin outs" and joint ventures
And with good reason.

Qinetiq is a silly name for a deeply serious company, one whose founding principle is nothing less weighty than the defence of the realm.

Until the middle of last year, Qinetiq was the main part of the Defence Evaluation and Research Agency (DERA), the British Government's secret military laboratories.

Now, Qinetiq - currently owned by the Ministry of Defence - is on course for privatisation, wooing venture capitalists with a view to a stock market listing.

But can secretive government scientists hope to thrive in the private sector?

War baby

DERA was a child of the Cold War, a means of channelling scientific expertise in the struggle with the Soviet Union.

Sir John Chisholm
Sir John says public service and private profit are compatible

Beginning in the 1950s with some of the pioneering work into chemical and biological warfare, the agency had reached a peak of sophistication by the end of the 1980s.

But then the sudden end of the Cold War eliminated DERA's raison d'etre at a stroke.

Margaret Thatcher, then prime minister, cut off funding for DERA and similar agencies.

"She wanted to find out what they were good for by making them go out and find customers for themselves," says Sir John Chisholm, Qinetiq 's chief executive.

At first, self-reliance did not come easy.

"Everything was upside down from the commercial point of view," says Sir John.

"Under the old regime, if you won any business from the outside world, that subtracted from the revenue coming in from the Treasury - so winning business was a bad thing."

New name, new business

A decade on, and the agency has found its commercial feet.

Profit is not in itself an objective, but it is a measure that you are really good at what you're doing

Sir John Chisholm, Qinetiq

Last year, the bulk of DERA - excepting the super-secret Defence Science and Technology Laboratory - became a government-owned company, renamed itself Qinetiq, and began the slow process of piecemeal privatisation.

Qinetiq still earns some 80% of its 800m annual sales from winning Ministry of Defence tenders.

But it is the remaining 20% that is the firm's main growth area, what Sir John calls "managing the interface between ideas and business".

Qinetiq hopes to prosper by taking the ideas and technologies it learns from defence contracting, and seeking out ways to apply them to problems in the civilian field.

"A feature of warfare is solving problems at the frontier of knowledge," says Sir John.

"That gives us intellectual property that our business model allows us to spin off in different directions."

From bombs to babies

This has led to some unusual - at times endearing - applications of originally scary technology.

  • Qinetiq has converted a system used to detect mines buried in mud, and applied it to a device to measure the heartbeat of unborn babies.
  • Soldier
    Another day in the Qinetiq labs
    Hollywood movie-style technology allowing neural guidance of fighter planes is being used for combating drowsiness in car drivers, as well as research into dyslexia in children.
  • Holographic 3D imaging is being developed in partnership with Ford, cutting down the amount of trial and error involved in designing cars.
  • A fibre-optic system developed for detecting submarines is being converted for use in gathering road tolls.
  • "Stealth" radar-avoidance technology is being used to cloak buildings, preventing them from interfering with air traffic-control systems, and shielding their computers from radar emissions.
  • Most peculiar of all, perhaps, is the application of missile-tracking technology to cricket, allowing umpires to get a better fix on the ball in flight.

The list could go on: in all, Qinetiq has more than 5,000 granted and pending patents.

Selling out

It is precisely this sort of - literally - rocket science that has got private sector investors excited.

Fighter pilot
He's here to help you stay awake
Last week, the government invited a dozen venture capital firms to bid for a minority stake in Qinetiq, a move explicitly intended to lead to a stock market flotation as early as 2004.

Although the Ministry of Defence will keep a keen eye on Qinetiq's progress - the firm will still be forbidden, for example, from selling military technology to foreign powers - it intends to sell its entire stake in the firm.

Sir John is sanguine about the company's prospects, arguing that it operates as a de facto private company in any case.

The firm has experience of privatisation, having contracted out and subsequently spun off its entire administrative and support operation in 1997.

Better still, says Sir John, an injection of cash will improve Qinetiq's chances of winning the best scientific staff - always a crucial consideration in a business driven by ideas.

Spreading thin

Looking forward, Qinetiq's close relationship with the Ministry of Defence gives it a powerful edge over private-sector rivals.

A Qinetiq-Ford imaging system
Holograms could make cars go faster

Not every firm can afford to develop a billion-pound jet fighter system in order to build a car accessory, for example.

But it still faces a number of significant challenges as it embraces the free market.

First, keeping strategy focused won't easy.

From being a straightforward defence contractor, Qineti1 has already become a defence contractor with sidelines in 11 other sectors, including rail, health, finance, telecoms and aviation.

As the company evolves, those business lines will multiply.

Sir John says that won't be a problem. All of Qinetiq's ventures are simply in the business of "getting value out of science", he argues.

But Qinetiq's ever-wider spread will inevitably put a strain on central resources, as well as bring the firm up against new kinds of previously unseen competitors.

Calling the shots

Second, new shareholders will have new demands.

In most firms with a scientific bent, there is a natural tension between the interests of short-term shareholder return, and those of longer-term research achievement.

Do scientists always make good businesspeople?

In many cases, shareholders are willing to be patient, if they are convinced that long-term returns will materialise, but Qinetiq is also bound by its public-service commitment, relegating profits to a secondary concern.

Sir John argues that the two are not incompatible.

"The fact that we are in competition, and win those competitions, tells us that we are doing well. Profit is not in itself an objective, but it is a measure that you are really good at what you're doing."

True enough, but today's shareholders - wary of inflated promises from hi-tech firms with funny names - have a habit of marking down the shares of firms that don't put their interests first.

Beating swords into ploughshares is laudable and ingenious, but making it pay may not be easy.

See also:

28 Mar 02 | Sci/Tech
Hi-tech kit tracks rowers
06 Mar 02 | England
Divers search for lost missiles
23 Dec 01 | Business
UK 'to scrap defence flotation'
17 Apr 00 | UK Politics
MoD to sell-off research agency
20 Jun 00 | UK Politics
Defence labs sell-off criticised
24 Jul 00 | UK Politics
Anger at defence agency sell-off
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Business stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Business stories