BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: Business
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Market Data 
Your Money 
Business Basics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Monday, 15 October, 2001, 21:26 GMT 22:26 UK
Byers blames Railtrack for collapse
Stephen Byers reports to the House of Commons on Railtrack
Mr Byers delivered a pugnacious performance
Railtrack left the government with no option but to put it into administration, Transport Secretary Stephen Byers has told the House of Commons.

I decided I could not give Railtrack a blank cheque

Stephen Byers
And no decision has yet been made on whether the company's parent can hang on to the Channel Tunnel rail link project to help it compensate its shareholders.

It was the beleaguered rail company which first raised the possibility of insolvency, Mr Byers told a packed house.

But Railtrack later hit back at Mr Byers' Commons speech, claiming it "lacked substance" in many crucial aspects.

The company also denied it had gone to the government with a "begging bowl, month after month", and had been trying to negotiate a broad package of reforms since July.

No guarantees

The rail company admitted it had raised administration as an option, but said it was in the context of ruling it out, not suggesting it as a viable course of action.

Mr Byers maintained the company told him in July that it was facing financial disaster.

By December 2001, losses would have been 700m, expanding to 1.7bn by March 2002, he said.

In August, Mr Byers said, Railtrack told him that it had only three options: restructuring, renationalisation or receivership.

Who will trust the government again? Not the City institutions. They will run a mile

Eric Pickles
Conservative transport spokesman
Restructuring would involve an open-ended commitment to cover Railtrack's costs and ensure a profit rather than a loss, as well as four years' suspension of regulation, Mr Byers said.

That was when administration began to emerge as a realistic option, he said.

Railtrack's board denied this, saying that prior to 5 October it had sought a "measured and fundamental" overhaul of its finances, not an "effectively open ended funding requirement".

It said the requested overhaul would have increased the transparency, predictability and stability of its affairs to deliver a better public railway.

But by 5 October, said Mr Byers, with Railtrack unable to put a figure on what it needed from the government, administration became the only course.

"I decided I could not give Railtrack a blank cheque," he said.

Mr Byers said the government had already made clear - with the agreement of Railtrack - that it would not protect shareholders over the travelling public.

Railtrack executives have been insisting that their shareholders should be compensated to the tune of about 360p a share, slightly less than the price at privatisation in 1996.

But Conservative transport spokesman Eric Pickles, said the 34bn private investment built into the government's 10-year plan was now at risk - and he called on Mr Byers to resign.

"Who will trust the government again? Not the City institutions. They will run a mile."

No word on Channel link

Railtrack had been expecting Mr Byers to announce that Railtrack Group - the failed company's parent - is to retain the right to run the Channel Tunnel rail link, which might provide a boost for out-of-pocket shareholders.

The licence to run Phase One of the rail link - the rest of the work has already been awarded to other contractors - is held by Railtrack Group, the parent of Railtrack plc.
Steve Marshall, chairman of Railtrack Group
Byers said Marshall agreed to no shareholder protection

But Mr Byers said the issue still needed more negotiation, since the government and Railtrack Group disagreed about how much it was worth. He planned to write to the company later on Monday, he said.

Railtrack has set the value at 400m. The government has yet to put its own value on the project.

Meanwhile, the train operating companies, such as Stagecoach and National Express, expect to be given a bigger role in track maintenance under Railtrack's replacement.

Mr Byers made it clear that Railtrack's replacement would be a private company limited by guarantee, without shareholders, and re-investing any profits into the network.

Railtrack shareholders have launched an action group to protect their interests, and are threatening to sue.

The BBC's Sean Curran
"Stephen Byers came to the Commons to deliver an "I am not going to quit" statement"
Sir Alistair Morton of the Strategic Rail Authority
"Rail needs investment"
Stephen Byers, Transport Secretary
"We're confident that we'll be able to lever in money from the private sector"

Key stories


Safety crisis
Should Railtrack's shareholders be compensated?



4719 Votes Cast

Results are indicative and may not reflect public opinion

See also:

15 Oct 01 | Business
Railtrack set for Chunnel deal
15 Oct 01 | UK Politics
Byers faces resignation demand
14 Oct 01 | Business
Pressure grows for Railtrack inquiry
11 Oct 01 | Business
German bank 'eyes UK rail network'
11 Oct 01 | Business
Railtrack pushes for rail link deal
09 Oct 01 | Business
Profile: The Railtrack salvage squad
15 Oct 01 | Business
Railtrack: What happens now?
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Business stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Business stories