BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Business
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Market Data 
Economy 
Companies 
E-Commerce 
Your Money 
Business Basics 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 

Friday, 5 January, 2001, 18:16 GMT
Belgians bitter at Interbrew snub
Stella Artois/Bass merger graphic with UK Trade & Industry Secretary Stephen Byers

By BBC News Online's Brian Wheeler

The British government's decision to block Interbrew's 2.3bn take-over of Bass has clearly touched a raw nerve in the company's native Belgium.

In an unprecedented move, Belgian economics minister Charles Picque hit out at UK Trade & Industry Secretary Stephen Byers, telling him that the decision will have "particularly prejudicial consequences" for both businesses.


The decision to make an unconditional purchase was a strategic error on a gross scale

Former Interbrew insider
Mr Picque said he regretted that approval with certain conditions could not have been made.

Former European Competition Commissioner Karel van Miert also weighed in, telling Belgian newspaper Le Soir that the British government's blocking of the deal was "disproportionate".

National institution

Belgian national pride has clearly been dented by the UK government's snub.

Interbrew is not only one of Belgium's largest companies, but one of a tiny handful with truly global reach.

Its board has traditionally included members of the country's nobility and powerful political figures such as current chairman, and former cabinet minister, Paul De Keermaeker.

Company profile - Interbrew
Formed in 1987, but traces origins to 1366
World's second largest brewer
Owns brands such as Boddingtons, Dos Equis, Jupiler, Labatt, Rolling Rock, Stella Artois
Interbrew's $3bn stock market flotation last year was meant to further strengthen its position at the top table of world brewing, funding an ambitious round of acquisitions.

But that strategy has been thrown into doubt by the British government's ruling, a sentiment reflected in the company's share price, which lost 20% when the news broke on Wednesday.

The underlying suggestion was that the British government was acting to preserve choice for the beer drinker will also have stung Interbrew, which styles itself the "the world's local brewer", and has a proud record of producing speciality beers.

'Punch on the nose'

Worse, however, is the financial cost, with some analysts predicting that Interbrew could lose as much as 600m when it finally comes to sell the Bass business.

A former Interbrew insider says: "To lose that kind of money will have a major impact... The Belgians pride themselves on having one of the world's largest breweries.

"It is a real punch on the nose for them."

Analysts have questioned the wisdom of Interbrew's decision to make an unconditional offer for Bass Brewers, before regulatory clearance had been gained.

"The decision to make an unconditional purchase was a strategic error on a gross scale," the former insider says.

Company profile - Bass Brewers
Founded in 1777 in Burton upon Trent
Boasts UK's oldest registered trademark (1876)
From 1967-1995 UK's largest brewer
Owns Bass, Hooch, Caffrey's, Carling, Grolsch (in UK), Tennents and Worthington brands

"Bass have got the money in the bank and now Interbrew are in the position of having to make a forced sale."

He adds: "I think they are guilty of a certain naivety. They obviously expected clearance to be a formality and it wasn't."

Interbrew's decision to press ahead with the Bass deal when, even on the most generous estimate, its new British portfolio easily outstripped the generally accepted limit of a 30% market share, is also under question.

Many in the brewing industry estimate said the actual share of the combined Whitbread and Bass portfolio - which included top-selling premium lager Stella Artois, Carling, Tennents, Caffrey's and Murphy's stout, was 38%.

Slim chances of success

Interbrew has said the British government's ruling "defies logic" and was "clearly disproportionate to the competition issues at stake" although it has not said whether it will appeal.

Leaders in the UK beer market
Interbrew (including Bass): 32%
Scottish & Newcastle: 28%
Carlsberg-Tetley: 13%
Legal experts have said the Belgian company had very little chance of overturning the decision.

So far, no decision on a merger by a British minister has been overturned in the courts. Some 11 previous appeals in merger cases have all failed.

If Interbrew did decide to appeal, it would focus on whether the ruling was "reasonable" and proportionate to the perceived narrowing of competition.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
BBC RADIO NEWS
BBC ONE TV NEWS
WORLD NEWS SUMMARY
PROGRAMMES GUIDE
See also:

04 Jan 01 | Business
Belgium slams blocking of Bass deal
03 Jan 01 | Business
What now for Bass beer brands?
01 Dec 00 | Business
Interbrew shares rise on debut
08 Nov 00 | Business
Interbrew to go public
19 Oct 00 | Business
Whitbread in pubs shake-up
14 Jun 00 | Business
Bass sells brewing ops
25 May 00 | Business
Beer sector faces shake-up
15 May 00 | Business
Whitbread and Bass to quit brewing
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Business stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Business stories