BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Business
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Market Data 
Economy 
Companies 
E-Commerce 
Your Money 
Business Basics 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 

Tuesday, 7 November, 2000, 12:53 GMT
The limits of globalisation
Macdonalds restaurant in Moscow
Mcdonalds led the charge into Moscow
by BBC News Online's Brian Wheeler

From London to Seattle, protesters have taken to the streets to vent their anger at 'globalisation'.

For the handful of companies which stand accused of world domination, the riots must make uncomfortable viewing.

Brands under attack
McDonalds
Nike
Microsoft
Ford
Coca-Cola
Marlboro
Starbucks

But what really gives chief executives sleepless nights is the prospect of a more widespread consumer revolt.

So far, the world's appetite for Big Macs and Coca-Cola seems as keen as ever.

But pockets of resistance are undoubtedly forming.

Growing dissent

Growth markets embraced with glee in the early Nineties by McDonalds, Coca-Cola, Philip Morris and other US consumer giants, are proving more difficult to crack than expected.

Russia, in particular, where poverty has rendered the concept of brand loyalty largely meaningless for many people, is not being won over easily.

In the past year, long-neglected brand names from the Soviet era have started to make a comeback as consumers turn their back on all things Western.


There is a very narrow dividing line between globalisation and mediocrity

Tom Blackett, deputy chairman Interbrand Newall and Sorrell

The Coca-Cola Company, which led the charge of Western brands into Russia, has been forced to switch production to traditional Russian soft drinks, such as Kvas, a cloudy, brown yeast concoction.

Philip Morris, whose Marlboro cigarettes once epitomised Western sophistication for Russian consumers, has found more success recently with a brand called Peter the Great.

In France, the wave of public support for a farmer who wrecked a McDonalds restaurant was a sign that dissent had spread beyond the university campus.

Under attack

The concept of global marketing is also changing.

The one-size fits all approach, driven by a deep-rooted conviction that the world's people all aspires to the same, Western, lifestyle, is no longer working.


Western marketers have misunderstood levels of intelligence and sophistication in emerging markets

Richard Hammond, advertising chief

Richard Hammond, former vice-president of global operations at US advertising giant Bozell, believes the big players are having to tread very carefully indeed.

"Once you reach a certain level of consumer sophistication, there is a backlash against advertising and being told what to buy.

"Brand marketers have to be careful about how they proceed.

"They need to integrate into the community, rather than impose their values on it."

Mr Hammond, who left Bozell to found his own multicultural ad agency, Spirit, believes the world's consumers are maturing fast.

"Western marketers have misunderstood levels of intelligence and sophistication in emerging markets," he says.

"When Bozell launched Heinz tomato ketchup in Moscow we went on TV with an ad from the UK. We simply changed the end line.

"That wouldn't work now. You would have to use a group of young Russians."

He adds: "In India as well, people have tried to use the techniques they have used in other emerging markets, but they meet a higher level of education than they expected." Apart from anything else, the multinationals realise that the power of the brand - as a guarantor of quality and status - has its limits.

"There is a very narrow dividing line between globalisation and mediocrity," Tom Blackett, deputy chairman of influential brand consultancy Interbrand, Newall and Sorrell says.

"There is a danger that the brand becomes so widespread that it loses what makes it special."

The fact that companies such as Coca-Cola, Philip Morris and Nike invest so heavily in their brands makes them uniquely vulnerable to fluctuations in public taste.

Interbrand has estimated that $75bn of Coca-Cola's $140bn market capitalisation is tied up in the Coca-Cola brand name.

The way Coca-Cola's share price plummeted following a contamination scare in Belgium last year showed how fragile that name can be.

Now - after a string of further PR disasters - the company which wanted to teach the world to sing has a different mantra - "Think global, act local."

Regional offices which once had 'pattern' ads and formulaic marketing strategies foisted upon them by corporate HQ are being encouraged to think for themselves - or so the company would have us believe.

Protester at WTO conference in Seattle, 1999
Seattle protests made headlines around the world

A new buzzword - 'glocal' - has been coined to sum up this newly responsive mood.

Better-informed

In the West, consumers are better-informed than ever, thanks in part to the internet, and are wising up to the marketing game.

"The car industry is a good example of consumers making more informed choices," Mr Blackett says.

"Skoda, which was once almost a joke, is going to be a really big brand.

"People now realise that - like supermarket cola - the product is essentially the same as the more expensive brand, in this case Volkswagen."

Former Coke employee Ken Phillips
Another PR disaster for Coke as former employees accuse it of racism

The anti-capitalism demonstrations in Seattle, London and elsewhere may have failed to impact on the multinationals' bottom line.

But they appear to have tapped into a wider sense of unease about the homogenisation of global culture.

This is something which the global consumer giants, with their market researchers and image consultants, will be painfully aware of.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
BBC RADIO NEWS
BBC ONE TV NEWS
WORLD NEWS SUMMARY
PROGRAMMES GUIDE

Talking PointFORUM
Naomi Klein
Quiz leading critic of globalisation
See also:

27 Oct 00 | Talking Point
Are we slaves to brands?
02 Nov 00 | South Asia
BA drops Buddha advert
19 Oct 00 | Asia-Pacific
Seoul braces for protests
19 Jun 00 | Middle East
G15 leaders attack globalisation
01 Jul 00 | Europe
Call for prison in Big Mac trial
25 Sep 00 | Business
Among the protesters
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Business stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Business stories