Page last updated at 15:17 GMT, Sunday, 13 April 2008 16:17 UK

China-Taiwan meeting bridges gulf

By Caroline Gluck
BBC News, Taipei

Taiwan's Vincent Siew and China's Hu Jintao - 12/4/08
The brief meeting focused on forging better economic ties

A high level meeting between China's President, Hu Jintao, and the man who will become Taiwan's next Vice-President, Vincent Siew, was historic - the highest level meeting between officials the two sides since 1949.

It was also, many analysts believe, likely to set the two sides on a path for better relations in the future.

Pictures of the men shaking hands and sitting down together in China's Hainan island, on the sidelines of the Boao Forum for Asia, were splashed on the front pages of Taiwan's newspapers.

Among the Chinese-language papers, the United Daily News said the meeting had created a "great opportunity because of their [the two men's] pragmatism and low-key approach".

The Apple Daily called the meeting "ice-breaking", saying it had created a "win-win opportunity".

The atmosphere was good - the discussion was candid and they didn't do anything to belittle us
George Tsai
Chinese Culture University, Taipei

But in its commentary, the Liberty Times - which generally supports the governing Democratic Progressive Party - was critical.

"Hu Jintao prepared a trap and [Taiwan President-elect] Ma [Ying-jeou] and Siew have been caught," reads its headline.

The paper quotes a traditional Taiwanese saying, suggesting Mr Siew's visit to China was "like asking for a medical prescription from a ghost" - suggesting he was seeking help from someone who would cause harm.

"Even if this is morphine or another kind of drug which will kill pain in the short term, it will kill Taiwan in the long-term," it said.


Most analysts, though, believe the meeting has brought positive results.

"I think it was a tremendously symbolic meeting - and also one that's ice-breaking," said Chao Chien-Min, who teaches Chinese politics and cross-strait relations at National Chengchi University.

"Some issues were ironed out and it's highly likely that we will see weekend charter flights between the two sides by 4 July. We could even see Chinese tourists coming here before the end of the year."

Taiwan's Vice President-elect Vincent Siew speaks during a roundtable panel at BOAO Forum
It was noted that Mr Siew was seated among VIPs at the forum

Those were pledges that Mr Siew and Mr Ma had made as part of their campaign to revive Taiwan's stagnant economy - which helped them win last month's presidential elections by a wide margin.

But for the plan to be realised, China's co-operation is essential. And that looks increasingly likely following Saturday's meeting.

In comments carried by China's state-run Xinhua news agency, President Hu said the two sides were facing an "historical opportunity", which needed joint efforts from both sides for further progress.

He said that the economic forum had "inspired us to think deeply about cross-straits economic exchanges and co-operation under the new circumstances".

He also backed two of Mr Siew's proposals: opening up Taiwan to more Chinese tourists and allowing weekend charter flights "as soon as possible".

There has been no direct air travel between the two sides since they split amid civil war in 1949. Mr Siew and his delegation had to travel to China via Hong Kong.

Mutual respect?

Mr Siew's decision to travel to the forum was a bold step, carrying significant risks as well as opportunities.

Some members of the governing Democratic Progressive Party, or DPP, had opposed the visit, saying it could undermine Taiwan's dignity and status in any future dealings with Chinese officials.

"Interaction between two hostile countries with very different ideas is good," said senior DPP legislator, Trong Chai, "but we must understand the position and ideas of the other side. The other side should respect the fact that Taiwan is an independent, sovereign country. Mr Siew didn't receive that kind of treatment."

 Ma Ying-jeou (Centre) and his wife and running mate Vincent Siew.
The Taiwanese voted for better relations with Beijing

But others disagreed. Mr Siew was attending the forum in a private capacity - as head of a private, non-government organisation promoting trade with China.

Those studying the nuances of his treatment were quick to note that he was seated in the front row, reserved for VIPs, and invited to join the centre table at a state banquet.

Both sides seemed determined to avoid sensitive political issues, focusing on economics. Despite their political differences, economic ties between the two sides have grown over the past two decades. China is now Taiwan's top trading partner and investment destination.

"The atmosphere was good; the discussion was candid and they [China] didn't do anything to belittle us. It seems both sides were sincere," said veteran China analyst, George Tsai, professor at Taipei's Chinese Culture University.

"It's melting the ice a few more inches - moving things in the right direction, and that's very helpful.

Golden opportunity

Some analysts have suggested China was willing to work for a good outcome, because it was keen to get good publicity and deflect attention away from its troubles in Tibet.

Tibetans living in Taiwan hold a candlelit vigil in response to China's crackdown against protests (28.03.08)
Some say China may want good publicity after protests over Tibet

Certainly, there has been a positive response to the meeting, with Washington praising the start of dialogue.

Former US Secretary of State, Colin Powell, an attendee at the forum, met Mr Siew and said he believed the talks were "good news for the region". Mr Powell told reporters that "the two sides have begun down a new path".

But Beijing also realises that last month's elections in Taiwan presented a golden opportunity.

When the people of Taiwan cast their ballots, they voted for change, including a less fractious relationship with Beijing than under the previous president, Chen Shui-bian, whose pro-independence rhetoric and policies had provoked and infuriated officials in China.

No-one is pretending that the task will be easy.

But the Hu-Siew meeting is an indication that if both sides are prepared to be more pragmatic, steps can be taken to build up mutual trust and increase interaction.

Only then, and in the longer term, can the tougher, political issues start to be addressed.

Taiwanese hope of new China chapter
23 Mar 08 |  Asia-Pacific
Taiwan flashpoint
12 Apr 08 |  Asia-Pacific
Taiwan victor promises China ties
23 Mar 08 |  Asia-Pacific
Choppy waters between China and Taiwan
22 Mar 08 |  Asia-Pacific
Profile: Ma Ying-jeou
22 Mar 08 |  Asia-Pacific
Timeline: Taiwan
22 Mar 08 |  Country profiles


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific