BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Languages
Last Updated: Thursday, 13 December 2007, 01:52 GMT
Nanjing remembers massacre victims
By Michael Bristow
BBC News, Nanjing

Taiping Gate monument
The Taiping Gate ceremony marked 70 years since the massacre
Shortly after capturing Nanjing in December 1937, the Japanese army gathered together 1,300 Chinese soldiers and civilians at the city's Taiping Gate. They then killed them.

They blew them up with landmines then doused them with petrol before setting them alight, finally using bayonets to finish off anyone still left alive.

This was just one small incident in what has become known as the Nanjing massacre, a six-week orgy of violence in which tens of thousands of Chinese people died.

A day before the massacre's 70th anniversary, a small group of survivors, dignitaries and visiting Japanese citizens gathered at Taiping Gate to remember the dead.

It is just one of a number of commemoration events being held in Nanjing this week to mark a bloody episode that still reverberates in East Asia today.

We only know about the Taiping Gate killings because of the tenacity of Japanese teacher Tamaki Matsuoka, who wanted to know more about the massacre.

Tamaki Matsuoka
Ms Matsuoka set up a hotline for former Japanese troops

With a number of others, she set up telephone hotlines in several Japanese cities in 1997, inviting former soldiers who had served in Nanjing to call up.

The group interviewed more than 200 old soldiers and, from the information it gathered, was able to identify the exact army unit that had carried out the Taiping killings.

Ms Matsuoka told her story at the Taiping memorial ceremony, which took place on a cold, wet Nanjing morning.

Before helping to unveil a small monument, she said she hoped Chinese young people would not forget what had happened in Nanjing.

School lessons

There is little chance of that. The atrocities carried out by the Japanese in Nanjing, and elsewhere in China during World War II, are drilled into Chinese schoolchildren.

NANJING MASSACRE
Bodies of Chinese laid in ditch (File photo)
December 1937 - Japanese troops invade Nanjing
Witnesses estimate 250,000-300,000 people killed
Reports of more than 20,000 women being raped
Japan claims numbers are much smaller
Some Japanese historians claim the massacre never happened
Some of them - from Nanjing 's 34th Middle School - were even on hand at the Taiping ceremony to lend their support. They promised to look after the monument.

In a speech, 17-year-old Wang Lin, head of the school's student association, said historical events should not be allowed to simply fade from memory.

Using a well-known Chinese phrase, she said past experience, if not forgotten, is a guide to the future.

She added: "Chinese people love peace, but you will be bullied if you fall behind. This is a serious lesson passed down by our ancestors."

Diplomatic tensions

But not everyone is as keen about remembering the past as this Chinese schoolgirl.

Although the Japanese government - and most Japanese people - acknowledge what went on in Nanjing, a small group of people claim the massacre has been fabricated.

Others say the 300,000 death toll often cited by the Chinese government is too high.

Japanese lawmakers line up as they visit Yasukuni Shrine (15/08/2007)
Official visits to the Yasukuni Shrine have angered China

It was an issue touched upon at the Taiping ceremony by Lin Boyao, who is ethnically Chinese but has lived in Japan since 1978.

"Even today, surprisingly, there are some people who deny the Nanjing massacre is a historical fact," he said.

"How can they be so shameless? This shows hatred for the dead and brings shame on the living."

The debate about what exactly happened after the Japanese army entered Nanjing on 13 December is not just about how to remember the past.

Even though the two sides are increasingly close trading partners, Japan's attitude towards World War II colours Chinese government policy to this day.

Former Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi's frequent trips to the Yasukuni shrine, which honours convicted war criminals as well as other war dead, soured Sino-Japanese relations for many years.

They only improved in 2006 when Koizumi handed over power to Shinzo Abe, who did not visit the shrine while he was in office - he sent a pot plant instead.

Lasting memories

Inevitably, this debate also fuels the anger of some Chinese people, a sentiment Beijing has occasionally encouraged.

In 2005, there were rare street demonstrations in several major Chinese cities over Japanese history textbooks which critics claimed whitewashed the country's World War II record.

Xiang Yuansong
Mr Xiang says he can never forget what happened in Nanjing

Despite the possible anger aroused by the anniversary, the owner of a Japanese restaurant in Nanjing said he was unconcerned.

"I've been here 15 years and am not worried at all. No-one talks to me about the massacre," he told the BBC as he waved goodbye to the final customers of the evening.

But the memory of the Nanjing massacre will not simply go away, at least as long as there are survivors such as Xiang Yuansong.

Now 80, Mr Xiang was just 10 when Japanese soldiers entered what was then the capital of China.

His 25-year-old brother was killed by the invaders. He remembers looking for him among the piles of dead bodies.

"We can never forget history," was his angry comment as he made his way home from the newly unveiled Taiping Gate monument.

SEE ALSO
Nanjing massacre victims named
04 Dec 07 |  Asia-Pacific
Beijing launch for massacre film
04 Jul 07 |  Entertainment
Poll finds Chinese wary of Japan
24 Aug 05 |  Asia-Pacific
Victory for Japan's war critics
23 Aug 05 |  Asia-Pacific
Q&A: China and Japan's troubled ties
14 Apr 05 |  Asia-Pacific



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific