[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Monday, 17 April 2006, 09:58 GMT 10:58 UK
Arroyo commutes death sentences
Manila jail
Inmates are rejoicing at the news, say prison officials
Philippine President Gloria Arroyo's decision to commute the death sentence for more than 1,000 convicts has been condemned by victim support groups.

President Arroyo's Easter announcement has been welcomed by the Roman Catholic Church and death penalty opponents.

But anti-crime groups fear it will simply embolden criminals, amid a recent resurgence in kidnappings.

Mrs Arroyo's move could spare the lives of 1,200 inmates on death row, which include at least 11 Islamic militants.

The president did not say, however, whether she would move to legally abolish the death penalty, which must be approved by Congress.

"Regarding those who [currently] face the death penalty, I announce that we are changing that punishment and will make [the maximum penalty] life imprisonment," the president said in her Easter message.

Her spokesman, Ignacio Bunye, later said she had made the decision after "deep contemplation and reflection in the field of Christian values".

She "believes that learning to forgive without compromising criminal justice would be a good start for the nation to move on," he explained.

Prison chaplain Monsignor Robert Olaguer said the inmates were rejoicing at the news. "They're thankful to the president because they'll have a longer life," he said.

'Tooth for a tooth'

But Teresita Ang-See, of the anti-crime Movement for Restoration of Peace and Order, said kidnap victims in particular were "dismayed" and "shocked" by the announcement.

"It's the height of insensitivity and callousness," she said, pointing out that a group of Chinese traders, a prime target for kidnappings, had recently appealed for convicted kidnappers to be executed so that an example could be set.

Gloria Arroyo prepares for her Lenten message [photo released by the presidential palace]
Mrs Arroyo did not say if she sought to abolish the death penalty

Dante Jimenez, of the Volunteers Against Crime and Corruption, said he had received calls from two victims' families who warned they would take matters into their own hands to ensure the killers of their loved ones met a similar fate.

"It will become a tooth for a tooth," he said. "It's saddening if victims will be victimised again because of this sweeping... commutations."

Mrs Arroyo lifted a moratorium on the death penalty in 2003 following the spate of kidnappings.

However, no executions in this predominantly Catholic country have been carried out since 2000.

Arroyo's 'lives for votes' gamble
28 Jan 04 |  Asia-Pacific
Philippines executions to resume
05 Dec 03 |  Asia-Pacific
Philippine executions suspended
30 Sep 02 |  Asia-Pacific
Arroyo under fire from Catholic bishops
19 Oct 01 |  Asia-Pacific
Profile: Gloria Arroyo
24 Feb 06 |  Asia-Pacific
Country profile: The Philippines
07 Apr 06 |  Country profiles

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific