Languages
Page last updated at 11:44 GMT, Tuesday, 30 December 2008

Caroline Kennedy fails to impress

Caroline Kennedy
Caroline Kennedy wants to become a New York senator

Caroline Kennedy's latest attempt to press her case to be the replacement for Hillary Clinton as a senator for New York has been widely criticised in the US media.

Ms Kennedy - daughter of former President John F Kennedy - broke weeks of silence on her bid, by giving a series of interviews at the weekend.

But she was criticised for being unknowledgeable on key policy areas, being unable to articulate why she was seeking public office for the first time - and even for possessing a verbal tic.

NEW YORK DAILY NEWS

Under the headline "Caroline Kennedy no whiz with words", the New York Daily News mimicked Ms Kennedy's speech pattern during the round of interviews.

"Caroline Kennedy, you know, might need, you know, a speech coach, um, if she, you know, wants, um, to be a senator," the paper said.

Totting up the number of "verbal tics" during its 30-minute interview, the paper counted "you know" more than 200 times... and added that "'um' was fairly constant, too".

Asked if President George W Bush's tax cuts on the wealthy should be repealed immediately, Ms Kennedy replied: "Well, you know, that's something, obviously, that, you know, in principle and in the campaign, you know, I think that, um, the tax cuts, you know, were expiring and needed to be repealed," the paper reported.

It consulted experts to give their opinion on her speaking manner. One said it was not necessarily an indication of weakness or doubt, just inexperience. Another advised her to get coaching, to pause more often, and "to listen to her father".

Columnist Michael Goodwin wrote: "The wheels of the bandwagon are coming off. Fantasy is giving way to inescapable truth. That truth is that Kennedy is not ready for the job and doesn't deserve it. Somebody who loves her should tell her."

NEW YORK POST

The New York Post also counted up the number of times Ms Kennedy said "you know" during its interview - 235 times in 41 minutes - "which works out to saying the phrase once every 10.5 seconds," it said.

The speech expert it consulted described it as a "very, very common" verbal tic called a "vocalized pause," and said it was a "Kennedyism" as demonstrated by her uncle.

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

The Associated Press said "Kennedy offered no excuses for why she failed to vote in a number of elections since registering in New York City in 1988".

"I was really surprised and dismayed by my voting record," she told AP. "I'm glad it's been brought to my attention."

AP reported that "since word of her interest leaked out in early December, Kennedy has faced sometimes sharp criticism that she cut in line ahead of politicians with more experience and has acted as if she were entitled to it because of her political lineage".

In response, Ms Kennedy said: "Anybody who knows me knows I haven't really lived that way. And I think that in my family, I come into this thinking I have to work twice as hard as anybody else. Nobody's entitled to anything, certainly not me."

NEW YORK TIMES

"[Ms Kennedy] still seemed less like a candidate than an idea of one: forceful but vague, largely undefined and seemingly determined to remain that way," the paper said.

"She provided only the broadest of rationales for her candidacy for the Senate, saying her experience as a mother, author and school fund-raiser, her commitment to public service and her deep political connections had prepared her for the job."

The Times said Ms Kennedy spoke "knowledgeably about education issues".

But the paper added: "... She said she hoped to be a consensus-builder, and declined to describe her positions on other pressing public issues - even in education, where she has some expertise. Ms. Kennedy would not say, for example, whether she supported proposals to abolish tenure for teachers and offer them merit pay instead."

Ms Kennedy "seemed irritated" when asked to describe the moment she decided to seek the Senate seat. She said "she couldn't recall", the article said.

"Have you guys ever thought about writing for, like, a woman's magazine or something?" she asked the Times reporters. "I thought you were the crack political team."

HUFFINGTON POST

Huffington Post writer Diane Tucker gave her take on the emphasis other media were placing on Ms Kennedy's speech patterns.

"The real reason her interview is riddled with 'you knows' is because she mocked the two Times reporters halfway through the interview.

"Rookie mistake, Caroline! You gotta play nice in the media sandbox. Good manners are important. ...No one ever says 'you know' in my interviews for HuffPost. We edit that garbage out. I'm sure Kennedy won't make that mistake twice. After all, she went to Harvard."

Tucker adds: "We Americans are a kind-hearted people, and we have always felt deeply sorry for her loss. Couldn't we make it up to Kennedy by gifting her a Senate seat? Wouldn't that be nice?

"Never mind that she's made it perfectly clear over the years that she really isn't into politics. Never mind that there are hundreds of New Yorkers with more experience. If Prince Charles is entitled to be King, then by golly Caroline Kennedy is entitled to be Senator."

SALON

Salon's Joan Walsh writes: "Overall, [Kennedy] was slippery, and regrettably, because I admire her, I came away with the feeling that she views her single best credential for the Senate seat as her celebrity, and, secondarily, her wealth."

Regarding Ms Kennedy's comment to the New York Times journalists about writing for women's magazines, Walsh wrote: "I've written for women's magazines, and I can anticipate people who might object to that remark as condescending, but I thought it was smart and funny: it captured the traditional media's growing infatuation with the telling sappy anecdote over important discussions of policy - even, sadly, at the New York Times."



Print Sponsor


SEE ALSO
Caroline Kennedy eyes Senate seat
16 Dec 08 |  Americas
Washington diary: Family ties
18 Dec 08 |  World News America
NY Times admits to fake letter
23 Dec 08 |  Americas

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

BBC navigation

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific