Languages
Page last updated at 08:55 GMT, Wednesday, 1 October 2008 09:55 UK

Canada PM faces plagiarism claim

Advertisement

Portions of the speeches were played side by side by the Liberal Party

A Canadian Conservative Party speech-writer has resigned after Prime Minister Stephen Harper was accused of plagiarism in a speech he made in 2003.

Owen Lippert admitted he had been "overzealous in copying segments" of a speech in support of the invasion of Iraq by then Australian PM John Howard.

Mr Lippert said neither his superiors nor Mr Harper, who was opposition leader at the time, had been aware.

The accusation comes half-way through a general election campaign.

Mr Harper, who has led a minority government since January 2006, called the snap election for 14 October last month, hoping to obtain a parliamentary majority, for which he needs to win 28 more seats.

Opinion polls suggest the conservatives are within striking distance of doing so, having maintained a near 10-point lead over the Liberals.

Context 'even worse'

The speech by Mr Harper was originally made on 20 March 2003 as the House of Commons in Ottawa held an emergency debate at the beginning of the US-led war in Iraq.

In the debate, Mr Harper urged Canada and the Liberal government to join the so-called "coalition of the willing".

COMPARE THE SPEECHES
Grab of speeches side by side (Source: Liberal Party of Canada)
Most computers will open this document automatically, but you may need Adobe Reader

Five years later at a campaign stop on Tuesday, a Liberal MP for Toronto, Bob Rae, accused the prime minister of plagiarism.

Mr Harper's 2003 speech had been made almost word-for-word two days before in Canberra by his former Australian counterpart, John Howard, he said.

To prove the allegation, portions of the speeches were played side by side.

"In the interests of world peace and regional security... The community of nations required Iraq to surrender," Mr Howard said in his speech.

"In the interests of peace and regional security... The community of nations required Iraq to surrender," Mr Harper said two days later.

Mr Rae said the discovery was made by accident almost two months ago by Liberal strategists who were looking for similarities between Mr Harper's government and that of US President George W Bush.

The Liberals said they did not release the information until Tuesday because they had been waiting to receive a videotape of Mr Howard's speech from Australia.

Liberal leader Stephane Dion said Mr Harper ought to be "expelled" by his party, and that the context in which the plagiarism had occurred made it "even worse".

"It's about Stephen Harper saying that Canada should go with the war in Iraq," he said.

"He's unable to choose his own words," he added. "Canadians want their country [to] speak with its own voice on the world stage."

'Pressed for time'

Conservative campaign spokesman Kory Teneycke initially refused to discuss the allegations of plagiarism.

Stephen Harper (7 September 2008)
Mr Harper has been depicting himself as honest ahead of the election

"I'm not going to get into a debate about a five-year-old speech that was delivered three parliaments ago, two elections ago," he told the CBC.

But eventually Mr Lippert, who describes himself as an expert in intellectual property, apologised and announced his resignation.

"Pressed for time, I was overzealous in copying segments of another world leader's speech," he said in a statement.

"Neither my superiors in the office of the leader of the opposition nor the leader of the opposition was aware that I had done so."

The BBC's Lee Carter in Toronto says the revelation comes during an election campaign that has focused heavily on leadership, with Mr Harper depicting himself as honest and dependable, contrasting himself to Mr Dion, who has been criticised for poor leadership and communication skills.

The two men are to face each other shortly in two vital televised debates - one in French on Wednesday and another in English on Thursday.


SEE ALSO
Canada premier plays economy card
08 Sep 08 |  Americas
Canadian PM calls snap election
07 Sep 08 |  Americas
Canadian PM to call snap election
05 Sep 08 |  Americas
Canadian PM presses Arctic claim
28 Aug 08 |  Americas
Canada FM quits for security slip
27 May 08 |  Americas
Country profile: Canada
12 Jun 08 |  Country profiles

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

FROM OTHER NEWS SITES
Channel 4 News Canada's PM under plagiarism cloud - 1 hr ago
London Review of Books Perry Anderson: After Kemal - 3 hrs ago
Globe and MailTory campaigner resigns over plagiarized speech - 4 hrs ago
ABCNEWS.com Canada Opposition Accuses PM of Plagiarism - 4 hrs ago
Modesto BeeCanada opposition party accuses PM of plagiarism - 5 hrs ago
* Requires registration



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

BBC navigation

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific