BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 15 November 2007, 10:35 GMT
Brazil police killings condemned
By Gary Duffy
BBC News, Sao Paulo

Police in Rio shanty town (File pic)
Police are accused of acting with virtual impunity
A senior United Nations official has harshly criticised police in Brazil for involvement in large numbers of extra-judicial killings.

Philip Alston, the UN's rapporteur on the issue, was speaking at the end of an 11-day fact-finding visit.

He said there was strong evidence that many of the 694 people killed by police in the first half of the year in Rio de Janeiro were extra-judicial killings.

Officials say firm action against crime is needed to safeguard civil rights.


Mr Alston will not compile his final report until March next year, but his initial conclusions are harsh and will not go down well with the Brazilian authorities.

Philip Alston
Mr Alston will deliver his final report next year
He told a news conference that the people of Brazil did not struggle valiantly for 20 years against a military dictatorship to make the country free, only for officers to kill with impunity in the name of security.

Some officers, he said, participated in the activities of militias and death squads.

Mr Alston referred to the 694 people killed by police in the first half of this year in Rio de Janeiro and whose deaths were classified by the authorities as acts of resistance.

This was often a euphemism for extra-judicial executions and virtually ensures impunity, he said.

'Major threat

One of this year's largest security operations in the city took place in June in the Alemao shanty town.

Mr Alston said he was staggered that an operation involving 1,300 officers resulted in 19 deaths, and that officers only seized a dozen weapons, and that the most important drug dealers were not arrested or killed.

He suggested the operation was driven more by political than security concerns.

Map of Brazil

His remarks seem certain to anger the authorities in Rio, who argue they are confronting a major threat from the city's drug gangs.

A spokesman for the state government said such conflict was undesirable, but in the name of civil and human rights, there was no way to back down from this obligation.

Among Mr Alston's initial recommendations were higher police pay, better forensics, improved witness protection and effective investigations into police killings.

This is not the first time that UN officials have reached damning conclusions about the police in Brazil and given the level of criticism, it seems unlikely to be the last.

War on Rio's drug gang slums
28 Jun 07 |  Americas
Brazil launches slum reform drive
03 Jul 07 |  Americas
Inside Rio's violent favelas
04 Jul 07 |  Americas
Police accused over Rio killings
29 Jun 07 |  Americas
In pictures: Rio violence
28 Jun 07 |  In Pictures
Gun battles in Rio leave 19 dead
18 Apr 07 |  Americas

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific