low graphics version | feedback | help
Does free trade benefit the poor?
WTO summit has provoked strong passions |
By BBC reporter Michael Gallagher
The meeting in Seattle is the most important trade summit since the World Trade Organisation was created five years ago. For the first time, the prospect of a genuinely free-trading world is in sight.
 |
|
"There's 1.5 billion people that are trying to join this organisation. I think that says something," he says.
"The principle is that a huge country like the United States, the most powerful, can go into a dispute with a small country like Costa Rica, and Costa Rica can win. Isn't this a civilised way of doing it?"
Not according to many of the WTO's critics. From environmentalists to human rights activists, there is no shortage of people who claim it is trampling on less powerful countries in the name of commerce.
Different rules for rich and poor
Thousands have converged on Seattle |
"In the previous round of talks, developing countries opened up their markets considerably, bringing down tariffs and largely taking away [import] controls," says Tagendra Kana, India's former commerce secretary.
"They now have a very fair claim that there should be a stronger opening up of the services market, where they have some skills and advantages."
"There should be liberalisation of agricultural trade, where, because of continued subsidies, prices are kept artificially low internationally."
|
|
Trade talk targets |
 |
Expand tariff cuts to agriculture and services |
|
Set agenda for other areas of trade liberalisation |
|
Discuss labour rights |
|
Set standards for 'fair' trading |
One of the most controversial areas at present is gene technology. Europe and the United States want patents to apply to modified genes in plants and animals. That will protect the interests of biotechnology companies.
"It's definitely a big, big problem," says Brazilian aid campaigner Anna Tonie. "By allowing patenting for some international firms to patent knowledge and bio-safety and other things from developing countries you are obviously instigating bio-piracy.
"It's easier for a firm, for example, to come to Brazil, to do their research and take their research back, say to the US, to Germany, or any other countries, without having to give in any kind of feedback or compensation for the indigenous people or local people that have developed that technology or has been looking after a plant for many, many years."
There is some evidence the WTO has been stung by this kind of criticism. It is trying to present the summit as one where Third World concerns will be heard. The message is that free trade can work for everyone.
US seen as enemy of fair trade |
"We're saying that essentially all goods coming from the 49 least-developed countries will be able to have access to the European Union with no duties being imposed upon them," says UK Trade Secretary Stephen Byers.
"That will make a massive difference as far as those countries are concerned. It will give them access to a market of 370 million people. It's a radical change that'll begin to lift them out of poverty."
Here to stay
It is likely much more will be needed to rebut the claim that free trade is not fair trade, and to satisfy the thousands of demonstrators who have converged on Seattle.
Among their complaints are that the WTO itself is inherently undemocratic, its treaties thrashed out behind closed doors by unaccountable lawyers, with few opportunities for countries to appeal. International free trade, it seems, is far from ideal.
But they may not have a choice. Whether they like it or not, it is here to stay.
"Globalisation, the very rapid movement of capital across the world, new technology, it's a transformation of the whole world system," says UK Overseas Development Minister Claire Short.
"The nation state can't operate in the way it used to. There are a lot of people who say they can't cope. And they're shouting and protesting.
"But I think it's a waking-up to how big the historical change is that is taking place in this era."
|
Search BBC News Online |
|
|
 Advanced search options | |
| |
 | |
 | |
| |
 | BBC RADIO NEWS |
| |
| |
 | BBC ONE TV NEWS |
| |
| |
| WORLD NEWS SUMMARY |
| |
| |
| |
| |
 | PROGRAMMES GUIDE |
|
|
See also: |
|
 |
|
 |
01 Dec 99 | Americas |
|
Trade protesters spark emergency |
| |
|
|
01 Dec 99 | UK |
|
London's WTO riot hangover |
| |
|
|
01 Dec 99 | Business |
|
WTO boss: Protesters harm the poor |
| |
|
|
30 Nov 99 | Americas |
|
In pictures: The WTO protests |
| |
|
|
30 Nov 99 | Business |
|
Trade talks backlash warning |
| |
|
|
23 Nov 99 | Battle for Free Trade |
|
Free trade flashpoints |
| |
|
|
28 Nov 99 | Battle for Free Trade |
|
Global hopes, global fears |
| |
|
|
24 Nov 99 | Battle for Free Trade |
|
Trade blocs and bullies |
| |
|
|
23 Nov 99 | Battle for Free Trade |
|
Free trade benefits all |
| |
|
|
Internet links: |
|
|
|
|
|
Anti-WTO action page |
| |
|
|
WTO |
| |
|
|
US Trade Representative |
| |
|
|
European Union Trade Directorate |
| |
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites |
|
Links to other Americas stories are at the foot of the page.
E-mail this story to a friend
~RS~a~RS~international~RS~q~RS~~RS~z~RS~19~RS~)