![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Sunday, October 24, 1999 Published at 12:34 GMT 13:34 UK World: Americas Canada faces water battle ![]() Businesses are eyeing up Canada's plentiful resource The Canadian Government is considering its response to a legal attempt from a US firm which could force it to allow water exports. Sun Belt Water is suing Canada for up to $10.5bn (C$15.75bn) in compensation for Canada's refusal to allow it to buy bulk water.
However Canada's Environment Minister, David Anderson, has insisted that the legal challenge is weak. Earlier, he said: "Bulk water is not a commodity of trade ... There's absolutely no reason to treat it as a trade commodity by taking it to Nafta or the World Trade organisation or any other trade organisation." A Canadian Foreign Ministry spokesman said on Friday that the government had 90 days to study the suit and agree to the composition of a three-person arbitration tribunal. Valuable resource
With about a billion people across the globe lacking sufficient fresh water, companies are lining up to transport Canada's water to the Middle East, Asia and America. A leader in Canada's Globe and Mail newspaper said Canada seems like an easy target because it does not have comprehensive water legislation, despite imposing a moratorium on exports. Canadian environmentalists say Sun Belt is attempting to use Nafta to overrule environmental laws. 'Not a trade issue' Canadian Foreign Affairs Minister, Lloyd Axworthy, has said Nafta does not give Americans the right to tap into Canadian water.
However analysts say that such understanding of the Nafta trade rules is not likely to survive an official challenge. Chapter 11 of the Nafta agreement between Canada, Mexico and the United States allows companies to sue governments if their regulations or laws hurt firms' international investments. Long-running dispute Sun Belt, based in California, and a Canadian partner company, Snowcap Waters, sued the Canadian province of British Columbia in 1993 after it banned bulk water exports. The province settled with Snowcap in 1996 for C$335,000 but did not reach an agreement with Sun Belt. Sun Belt claims it has been "mistreated" by the provincial government and courts in British Columbia. The firm's chairman, Jack Lindsey, is quoted as saying: "I am demanding the restoration of the licence I had in the first place. Canadian courts cannot block me." The BBC's Ian Gunn in Vancouver says Canadians are watching the latest development with concern, and are beginning to wonder how much control they really have over their fresh water supply. Maude Barlow, of the Council of Canadians trade lobby group, says there is no such thing as surplus water in Canada. She says studies show that despite its abundance, water is a finely balanced part of complex ecosystems. |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||