[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Wednesday, 1 October, 2003, 13:50 GMT 14:50 UK
Fight over Florida woman's fate
By Rachel Clarke
BBC News Online

In a room in a hospice in Pinellas Park, Florida, a woman named Terri Schiavo lies in bed. By various accounts she reacts and even interacts with staff and visitors.

But she has been incapacitated since suffering brain damage after a collapse in 1990 and her husband Michael says it is now time to let her die as she would have wished.

Mrs Schiavo needs no machines to keep her heart, lungs or other organs working but must be fed through a tube to her stomach - without this source of nutrition, she would die.

Her parents, Robert and Mary Schindler, say Mr Schiavo wants to free himself from his wife so he can re-marry. They also say he has spent hundreds of thousands of dollars in a fund for her care on legal costs. Mr Schiavo's lawyer says the money has been spent on medical bills.

The Schindlers have petitioned a federal court to try to overturn a ruling won by Mr Schiavo for the feeding tube to be removed at 1400 local time on 15 October. A hearing has been scheduled for 10 October.

Because of the pending court cases, neither the parents nor Mr Schiavo is giving interviews. But the parents' position is clear from their petition and Mr Schiavo's lawyer, George Felos, speaks for his client.

Mr Felos told BBC News Online that Mr Schiavo had come to the conclusion that his wife could not recover after several years of hoping for rehabilitation. At that time, he decided he needed to follow his wife's wishes - expressed on more than one occasion - that she did not want to be kept alive by tubes.

"The case is not about what Michael wants or the parents want - it's about what Terri wants," he said.

Terri Schiavo's parents Robert and Mary Schindler
Terri Schiavo's parents say her husband has "deprived her of her dignity"
But the Schindlers accuse Michael Schiavo of making up his wife's wishes and say he has denied her rehabilitation treatment they believe could have helped her to learn how to eat again and so live without the feeding tube.

The parents' petition says Mr Schiavo has "generally deprived Terri of her dignity as a human being, and treated her as though she were already dead".

It accuses him of "deliberately and maliciously" abusing the special relationship he has with his wife who also became his ward after her collapse through, among other things, "his decade-long campaign of deliberately degrading Terri's neurological responses by a calculated plan of sensory deprivation; his looting of Terri's guardianship estate for attorney fees in the effort to have her killed, contrary to his promises to the jury about how the money would be used; and his cohabitation with another woman, during which he has fathered two children out of wedlock".

After the petition was filed, however, George Felos said: "I would hope that the federal judge looking at this realises this is just an attempt to rehash what has gone on before.

"I think a federal judge is well aware that he doesn't have jurisdiction. Beyond that, it must be pointed out that so much of what is in this complaint is just an out-and-out lie."

So far, court rulings have swung between the two sides. Mr Schiavo has won orders from a judge that the feeding tube be removed - and it was taken out for two days in April 2001.

But various appeals and stays have also been allowed, though both the Florida Supreme Court and the US Supreme Court have refused to become involved.

Doctors chosen by the two sides to give medical opinions disagree on whether there is any hope of recovery for Mrs Schiavo, though a court-appointed physician agreed with Mr Schiavo's experts that there was none.

Dr Robert Walker, who teaches ethics at the University of South Florida's medical school, said it was a difficult case for all concerned.

The one question is really making an accurate diagnosis of her brain damage and what her capacity is and whether there is potential for improvement
Dr Robert Walker, University of South Florida
He told BBC News Online that it was near-impossible to say who was right and who was wrong given the fact that Mrs Schiavo - who was only 26 when she collapsed - had made no living will saying exactly what treatment she would want.

"It would be wrong to treat someone in her condition against her will but it would be wrong to discontinue treatment if she wanted it to be continued," he said.

Dr Walker said Florida state law did not differentiate between not starting medical procedures - which by its standards includes the use of a feeding tube - and stopping them.

But he said there was a great emotional difference for patients, their relatives and doctors between deciding not to do something - such as shocking a patient's arrested heart - which might prolong life, and withdrawing treatment which would lead to death.

In this case, however, he believed that the manner of death need not be a factor.

Cortex 'destroyed'

Mr and Mrs Schindler say their daughter would die slowly and painfully from starvation. Such a death would be a graphic and horrifying thought to most people, but Dr Walker said Mrs Schiavo simply does not feel hunger or thirst.

Terri Schiavo (image courtesy Terri Schindler Schiavo Foundation)
Terri Schiavo was 26 when she collapsed
Mrs Schiavo's brain scans have not been made public but Dr Walker has followed the case closely through media reports and court records.

"The majority of her cerebral cortex - the part of the brain that thinks and feels - has been destroyed and replaced by fluid," he said.

"She doesn't have any perception, there is no reason to believe she can suffer."

Unlike a patient in a coma, Dr Walker believes there is no hope for recovery for someone in Mrs Schiavo's condition - known as permanent vegetative state - because the cerebral cortex does not regrow once destroyed.

Despite the medical term, however, video of Terri Schiavo on a website run by her parents' supporters shows her more like a baby. But this is misleading as the movements are purely reflexes, Dr Walker says.

"The hard part of it is when you look at her, her eyes open, she blinks, she moves her head. If you do things that seem to be uncomfortable she will recoil from that but all of these things are known to be reflexive," he said.

"Terri Schiavo is very much alive, she is not in any sense dead, but she is severely brain damaged.

"The one question is really making an accurate diagnosis of her brain damage and what her capacity is and whether there is potential for improvement. These are matters for medical experts - that's a proper role for physicians.

"What's not proper for physicians is to be deciding whether Terri Schiavo continues in this way or not. That should be going by her wishes... it's not what others would want for her but what she would want for herself."

Case timeline:

  • 25 February 1990: Terri Schiavo collapses at home

  • November 1992: Michael Schiavo wins case against doctors he accused of misdiagnosing his wife; awarded $700,000 for her care and $300,000 for himself

  • 29 July 1993: Schindlers file petition to have Mr Schiavo removed as Mrs Schiavo's guardian; case later dismissed

  • May 1998: Mr Schiavo files petition to remove Mrs Schiavo's feeding tube

  • 11 February 2000: Judge Greer rules feeding tube can be removed

  • 20 April 2001: Schindlers win a stay to exhaust appeals

  • 23 April 2001: US Supreme Court refuses to intervene

  • 24 April 2001: Feeding tube removed from Mrs Schiavo

  • 26 April 2001: Judge orders doctors to reinsert tube

  • 22 November 2002: After more hearings, Judge Greer rules there is no evidence that Mrs Schiavo has any hope of recovery and orders tube to be removed on 3 January 2003

  • 13 December 2002: Judge Greer stays order to remove feeding tube to allow appeal

  • 6 June 2003: Appeal court upholds Judge Greer's ruling

  • 26 August 2003: Florida Governor Jeb Bush asks court to appoint new guardian for Mrs Schiavo; court does not act

  • 17 September 2003: Judge orders feeding tube removal on 15 October

  • 22 September 2003: Parents petition federal court

  • 10 October 2003: Federal court hearing due

  • 15 October 2003: Tube removal scheduled

    Euthanasia debate sweeps world
    26 Sep 03 |  Europe

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


    News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
    UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
    Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
    Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific