[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Saturday, 23 September 2006, 10:53 GMT 11:53 UK
Zambia's nursing brain drain
By Caroline Swinburne
BBC African Perspective, Zambia

Zambian nurse Tangu Mwanamoonga
Staff shortages mean that Tangu Mwanamoonga often works alone

Staff shortages within Zambia's health sector have reached crisis point as many nurses are driven to seek work abroad.

It is mid-morning in the male medical ward at the University Teaching Hospital (UTH) in the Zambian capital Lusaka.

As usual the ward is full, with 36 patients suffering conditions ranging from malaria and meningitis to HIV infection.

Ideally there should be six nurses on duty, but chronic staff shortages mean that as usual, sister-in-charge Tangu Mwanamoonga is alone, dispensing drugs, changing dressings and doing her best against the odds to monitor her seriously ill charges.

"You have to do everything for everybody," she says wearily.

"And if you don't do it - because you simply can't - you end up feeling guilty that you haven't been able to help."

Key election issue

Health will be a key issue when Zambia goes to the polls on 28 September.

Staff shortages have reached crisis point, with more and more nurses like Ms Mwanamoonga deciding to seek employment abroad.

Zambian outgoing Health Minister Dr Brian Chituwo
Our salvation can only lie in the economic growth of Zambia
Dr Brian Chituwo
Acting Health Minister

In a country with about 9,000 nurses, the Zambian Nursing Council says 3,444 filled out the paperwork needed to work abroad between 1993 and 2005. Many go to the UK.

The British National Health Service (NHS) has an ethical recruitment code which bans it from employing staff from many developing countries, including Zambia.

And so, at least to begin with, many Zambian nurses find work in the private sector, often at nursing homes for the elderly.

Maud Phiri came to the UK last October, after seven years as a staff nurse at Zambia University Teaching Hospital.

Back home she was sister-in-charge of the hospital's Burn's Ward, often caring single-handedly for as many as 50 surgical patients.

Maud Phiri, Zambian nurse working in the UK
If you are always worrying about what you're going to eat, what you're going to feed your family, then you really can't do a proper job
Maud Phiri
Zambian nurse in the UK
Now, her job is far less demanding, involving tasks such as washing old people, giving them their medication and generally helping to amuse them.

She is well aware she is not using her skills but does not feel guilty for her decision.

"To be effective as a nurse you need to be emotionally and physically well," she says.

"If you are always worrying about what you're going to eat, what you're going to feed your family, then you really can't do a proper job."

Limited quota

Zambia's outgoing Health Minister Dr Brian Chituwo [Dr Chituwo was recently moved to cover education affairs] says his government has made progress in improving conditions for medical staff.

Zambian patient Nathan Banda
There are not enough medical staff to care for Zambia's patients

To prove his point, he cites pay rises for nurses and a highly successful government-run programme aimed at encouraging doctors to work in rural areas.

If current President Levy Mwanawasa's party is re-elected, Dr Chituwo would like to see agreements with foreign governments, such as the UK, to allow a limited quota of nurses from countries like Zambia to work in their country, only for a limited period of time.

He would also like to make staff sign commitments to stay for at least three years, after being trained at tax payer's expense.

But Dr Chituwo is well aware that the basic problem is economic, asking: "You might say why not just pay the nurses more?'"

"Certainly, I can strongly lobby for the Ministry of Health, but there is only a limited amount of cash in the pot, and my colleagues may make a stronger case for agriculture or education.

"Our salvation can only lie in the economic growth of Zambia."

Join Caroline Swinburne to hear how in the BBC's African Perspective on Saturday and Sunday at 1906 GMT and 2106 GMT in both East and West Africa.

Will you be voting in Zambia's elections on 28 September 2006? What issues will influence your vote? Send us your views using the form below.

Your E-mail address
Phone number (optional):
Town & Country

The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published. Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide.

Country profile: Zambia
18 Sep 06 |  Country profiles
Aids hits Africa's health staff
04 Aug 06 |  Health
Reversing Africa's brain drain?
22 Mar 06 |  Africa


Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific