BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: World: Africa
Front Page 
Middle East 
South Asia 
From Our Own Correspondent 
Letter From America 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Saturday, 10 February, 2001, 15:11 GMT
Zanu-PF ups pressure on judges
Robert Mugabe
Zanu-PF has accused the judiciary of bias
Zimbabwean president Robert Mugabe's ruling party has called on two Supreme Court judges to quit, according to newspaper reports.

The move comes a week after Zanu-PF forced the country's chief justice to take early retirement.

Government critics feel that in the face of a serious threat from the opposition Movement for Democratic Change, the government it is trying to tighten its grip on those institutions which have demonstrated their independence.

The official Herald newspaper quoted Zanu-PF spokesman Jonathan Moyo as saying a meeting of its members of parliament on Friday passed a vote of no confidence in the country's highest court of appeal and urged justices Nicholas McNally and Ahmed Ebrahim to resign.

We were told very nicely and politely we should take our leave and go, otherwise anything could happen - they didn't want me to come to any harm

Justice Nicholas McNally
Mr Moyo said the judges had usurped parliament's powers by recently overturning a government ban on election result challenges.

Justice McNally said Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa asked for his resignation and that of his colleague Justice Ibrahim.

"We were told very nicely and politely we should take our leave and go, otherwise anything could happen. They didn't want me to come to any harm," he said.

But Justice McNally, who is white, has turned down the request while Justice Ebrahim, of Asian origin, has indicated he wants to consult his family, the paper said.

Sternford Moyo, president of the Law Society, told the BBC that if the judges agreed to resign in such circumstances it would set a precedent, making it difficult for the courts to rule against the government.

He also praised Justice McNally for refusing to step down and urged the other judges to follow his lead.

Neither the president nor parliament has the power to sack a judge outright.


A weeks ago, Anthony Gubbay, the chief justice, was forced to agree to retire after being told by the government that decisions had been incorrect and his safety could not be guaranteed in the wake of threats from ruling party militants.

The Supreme Court ruled on 30 January that the government decree banning opposition challenges to results of last June's parliamentary election infringed candidates' constitutional rights to seek legal recourse.

Anthony Gubbay
Zanu-PF has already forced the resignation of the chief justice
Ruling party MPs resolved on Friday to defend their disputed electoral victories in parliamentary elections held last June, chief parliamentary whip Joram Gumbo said.

The Supreme Court comprises two whites, one Asian and two blacks, but the government says its rulings generally reflect a "Rhodesian mentality".

Rhodesia was Zimbabwe's colonial name under white minority rule before Mr Mugabe's party took power after independence from Britain in 1980.

In December, the court effectively declared unlawful Mr Mugabe's drive to seize white-owned farms for black peasants without paying compensation.

Hundreds of militants stormed the supreme court in Harare on 24 November, disrupting a hearing on land seizures. No one was arrested for the disturbance.

Mr Mugabe has repeatedly vowed the courts would not stop his plans to seize more than half the 12 million hectares (30 million acres) of farmland occupied by 4,500 white farmers for blacks to redress what he calls the imbalances caused by Zimbabwe's colonial past.

Meanwhile, hundreds of armed riot police have forced journalists to abandon a protest against intimidation of the independent press and an anonymous bomb attack that damaged the press of the Daily News, a newspaper the government had accused of opposition bias.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

10 Feb 01 | From Our Own Correspondent
Zimbabwe's descent into violence
26 Oct 00 | Africa
Mugabe under pressure
08 Sep 00 | Africa
Mugabe attacks the 'masters'
30 Sep 00 | Africa
Opposition warning to Mugabe
18 Oct 00 | Africa
Third day of protests in Zimbabwe
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Africa stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Africa stories