Page last updated at 10:42 GMT, Thursday, 11 March 2010

Brazil's Lula criticised for Cuba dissidents comment

President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva in an interview with AP on 9 March
Lula said he believed some criticism of Cuba was hypocritical

Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva has been criticised for comments in which he appeared to compare Cuban dissidents to common criminals.

He told the AP news agency that hunger strikes, which some dissidents have staged, were not a pretext for release.

"Imagine if all the criminals in Sao Paulo went on hunger strike to demand freedom," President Lula said.

Cuban dissident Guillermo Farinas, who is on hunger strike, said he felt betrayed by Lula's comments.

Mr Farinas, 48, has been staging his protest for the past fortnight to seek the release of ailing political prisoners from Cuban jails.


He began his action after jailed dissident Orlando Zapata Tamayo, who had been on hunger strike for several weeks, died last month. His death provoked widespread international condemnation and calls for the release of all Cuba's detained political dissidents.

The Cuban government has said it will not bow to what it calls the "blackmail" of hunger strikes.

Cuban dissident Guillermo Farinas
The Cuban government says it will not bow to pressure from Mr Farinas

In the AP interview, President Lula, who visited Cuba last month, said hunger strikes should not be used as a pretext to press for release from prison.

"We have to respect the decisions of the Cuban legal system and the government to arrest people on the laws of Cuba, like I want them to respect Brazil," said Lula, who himself was a political activist against Brazil's military government in the 1970s and 1980s.

"I've been on hunger strikes and I would never do it again. I think it's insane to mistreat your own body."

Lula said he believed there was hypocrisy involved in the criticism of Cuba: "It's not just in Cuba that people died from hunger strikes."


Mr Farinas told Brazilian newspaper Folha de Sao Paulo that President Lula's comments showed "his commitment to the tyranny of Castro and his contempt for political prisoners and their families".

"A majority of the Cuban people feel betrayed by a president who was once a political prisoner."

The Brazilian Bar Association (OAB) said Lula's comments aimed to trivialise hunger strikes, which were a symbol of resistance to authoritarian regimes.

"It would be better for the Brazilian government to concern itself with the dreadful prison conditions in which (dissidents) are held," said the association's president, Ophir Cavalcante.

Brazilian Foreign Minister Celso Amorim supported Lula's comments.

"It's one thing to defend democracy, human rights, the right to free speech. it's another thing to be supporting everything that is dissident in the world. That is not (our) role," he said.

Mr Amorim said real change in Cuba was in the hands of the US.

"If someone is interested in creating political evolution in Cuba, I have a quick prescription: End the embargo."

Cuba's illegal but tolerated Human Rights Commission says there are about 200 political prisoners still held in Cuba, about one-third fewer than when Raul Castro took over as president from his brother Fidel.

Guillermo Farinas speaks to the BBC

Cuba lashes out at hunger striker
08 Mar 10 |  Americas
Cuba dissidents 'to refuse food'
27 Feb 10 |  Americas
Havana urged to release prisoners
24 Feb 10 |  Americas
Cuban prison hunger striker dies
24 Feb 10 |  Americas

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

The Economist Affirmative anticipation - 11 hrs ago
Washington PostEU condemns Cuba for rights violations - 20 hrs ago
NewsMax.comCuba Rejects EU Human Rights Condemnation - 20 hrs ago
Reuters UK Brazil lower house votes last amendment to oil bill - 35 hrs ago
Mining Technology Brazil to Limit Mining Rights - 49 hrs ago
* May require registration

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific