Page last updated at 17:33 GMT, Monday, 7 December 2009

Ten Tors drowning girl 'begged to leave trip'

Charlotte Shaw
Charlotte was throwing a friend's bag across the river when she fell

A girl who drowned while training for a hiking expedition had pleaded with teachers to abandon the trip, an inquest has heard.

Charlotte Shaw, 14, was training for the Ten Tors on 4 March, 2007, when she fell into Walla Brook on Dartmoor and was swept away.

Friend and team-mate Yasmin Moore told the coroner Charlotte felt "pushed" to continue by teacher Chris Fuller.

Charlotte, from Frithelstock, died from cardiac arrest as a result of drowning.

Answering questions from Devon coroner, Dr Elizabeth Earland, Yasmin Moore, now 18, said she and her team met Mr Fuller and asked to "come off" the trip on the second day of training.

'So scared'

"Most of us were in tears. He said if we carry on, if we get through that day, we will find it easy, the real thing," she told the inquest jury.

"We were really angry that we could not come off the trip."

Miss Moore said most of the team was crying but Mr Fuller told them to "keep warm and carry on".

When the coroner asked Miss Moore if she felt Mr Fuller was pushing them, she replied: "Yes."

The inquest heard Charlotte fell into Walla Brook as she threw Miss Moore's bag across the river.

Earlier in the hearing Miss Moore cried as her statement was read out to the jury by Det Con David Stribley of Devon and Cornwall Police.

Dartmoor rescue
Twenty-six pupils were airlifted from the moor

Miss Moore told police "she had never been so scared" when her friend fell into the water.

She said that she and Charlotte, students at Edgehill College, now known as Kingsley School, in Bideford, were struggling in terrible weather conditions to find a place to cross.

Miss Moore said one of the team leaders advised her to take off her rucksack which she gave to Charlotte before leaping to the other bank.

"Charlotte chucked it and she fell in when she threw the bag. She just went down the river," Miss Moore said.

"Charlotte said nothing - she didn't scream."

Dr Elizabeth Earland told the inquest the weather "was particularly bad, it was raining, causing the rivers and streams to swell".

The team used a mobile phone to raise the alarm. Charlotte was airlifted to Derriford Hospital where she was pronounced dead in the early hours of the next day.

Atrocious weather

Charlotte, who was described by her uncle at her funeral as an "energetic, talented, fun-loving smiling character", had been among 85 school groups on the moor training for the Ten Tors.

The weekend-long hiking expedition, which is organised by the British Army, began in 1960.

A total of 26 people from three schools - including Charlotte's school, Edgehill College in Bideford - were airlifted from the moor in atrocious weather the weekend that Charlotte died.

Detectives who carried out an investigation into her death ruled out criminal behaviour or negligence.

However, legal representatives for Charlotte's mother, Jennifer Shaw, the Ministry of Defence, the Health and Safety Executive, Edgehill College, and two Edgehill College teachers are attending the inquest which is expected to last up to two weeks.



Print Sponsor


SEE ALSO
No negligence in moor girl death
21 Mar 07 |  Devon
Tributes paid to river death girl
09 Mar 07 |  Devon
River death girl saw team cross
07 Mar 07 |  Devon
Moor trek stays after girl dies
05 Mar 07 |  Devon
Babbling brook can become killer
05 Mar 07 |  Devon
Tradition of the tors challenge
05 Mar 07 |  Devon

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

FROM OTHER NEWS SITES
Plymouth Evening Herald Ten Tors drowning girl 'begged to stop' - 38 mins ago
Times Online Pupils 'begged for trek on which Charlotte Shaw drowned to be abandoned' - 45 mins ago
Derbyshire Times Drowned girl's team pleaded to abandon hiking trip - 3 hrs ago
Mail Online UK Schoolgirl, 14, who drowned in swollen river 'begged teachers to call off trip' - 4 hrs ago
The Independent Ten Tors death: teacher 'ignored pleas' - 13 hrs ago



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

BBC navigation

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific