Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Sport: Football: FA Carling Premiership
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Sport 
Motorsport 
Football 
Rugby League 
Rugby Union 
Cricket 
Tennis 
Golf 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 


The BBC's Mike Sewell
Ashton wants a public meeting
 real 28k

Joe Ashton
"I know that club backwards and I'm going to fight to keep it in the Premiership"
 real 28k

The BBC's Nick Garnett with fans in Sheffield
Fans in the city are divided
 real 28k

Wednesday, 19 January, 2000, 18:07 GMT
Ashton dismisses talks offer

The row overshadows Tuesday's cup win over Wolves


Labour MP Joe Ashton has dismissed Sheffield Wednesday chairman Dave Richards' offer of a private meeting to clear the air over an increasingly bitter row.

Earlier on Wednesday in an open letter to Richards the politician accused the Owls' board of wanting the debt-ridden club relegated, since it would then be easier to sell.

The club dismissed this as "total nonsense" and offered Ashton a meeting behind closed doors.

The Owls' former vice-president says their response is "a disgrace and a joke".



If Sheffield Wednesday were to be downsized from a business with a £23m turnover with £18m debts in the Premier League, to a First Division club of £9m with no debts, it would be much easier to sell
Joe Ashton
Richards responded by inviting Ashton and three other local Labour MPs to a meeting at the club where he would "answer all of their questions".

But Ashton said Richards' response was unacceptable.

"He hasn't answered any of my questions, with the exception of whether they are looking to be relegated," he complained.

"I've asked at least 10 questions in my letter and he's only responded to one. It's a disgrace and a joke.

"I'm certainly not going to meet him in private because he will simply fudge and deny everything we are asking of him. I think it shows they've something to hide."



We want to stop media speculation once and for all. It is unsettling the players and upsetting the fans
Director Howard Culley
Richards is unwilling to become involved in a public slanging match, and will almost certainly reject Ashton's terms for a face to face meeting.

"The only way I will sit down and talk to him is if it is in front of the media, with TV cameras and radio microphones and the written press, and they can ask him the questions," said the MP.

"It's about time he had a press conference because all he is doing is hiding behind public relations statements."

Before Ashton's latest complaints Wednesday director Howard Culley had responded to the letter with a short statement.

"It beggars belief that anyone could even suggest we would be happy to be relegated. Staying in the Premiership is our priority," he insisted.


Ashton is determined to meet with Richards in public
"The chairman Mr Richards has always said there is an open door at this club and that door is wide open for them."

Ashton's letter catalogues a series of "heated exchanges" he says took place between himself and Richards.

The first supposedly took place in May last year when the MP warned Richards against becoming chairman of the Premier League and deputy chairman of the FA.

Ashton says this triple role is detrimental to Wednesday.

Another matter for any potential debate is the size of Wednesday's debt, with Ashton claiming it is up to £18m.


Ashton's key points
How did debts occur?
Richards cannot chair Wednesday and the Premier League
Suspects relegation would make club easier to sell
The MP says Richards told him it was only £6.5m before the four MPs met last week with the merchant bank Charterhouse, who own a 36% stake in the club.

The letter-writing MP says the bank gave the impression that "it now anticipates relegation" and wants to protects its assets.

Ashton also questioned how a business which has turned over in excess of £50m in the past three years could be in such trouble.


Manager Danny Wilson has already rejected the MPs' calls for his resignation
Shareholders have already given Richards an ultimatum - to come up with an action plan by 21 February or face a vote of no confidence.

The club says they have nothing to hide, and that the affair is damaging the club's battle to avoid relegation.

"We want to stop media speculation once and for all. It is unsettling the players and upsetting the fans at such a crucial period," said Culley.

"This is a public company with published accounts and there is nothing here that is not within the public knowledge.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
BBC RADIO NEWS
BBC ONE TV NEWS
WORLD NEWS SUMMARY
PROGRAMMES GUIDE

See also:
19 Jan 00 |  Football
Ashton's letter in full
18 Jan 00 |  FA Carling Premiership
Owls scrape into last 16
18 Jan 00 |  FA Cup
MP promises Owls 'truth'
14 Jan 00 |  FA Carling Premiership
MPs demand Wilson sacking
17 Jan 00 |  FA Carling Premiership
Unions rally around Wilson
15 Jan 00 |  FA Carling Premiership
Wilson's answer to political football
Links to other FA Carling Premiership stories are at the foot of the page.