Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Business
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Market Data 
Economy 
Companies 
E-Commerce 
Your Money 
Business Basics 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Sport 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 
Friday, 14 January, 2000, 14:40 GMT
Mannesmann faces culture shock

Mannesmann workers protest against Vodaphone takeover Mannesmann workers protest against Vodafone takeover


By Patrick Bartlett in Frankfurt

The biggest hostile take-over battle in history enters its final stage.

Mobile merger battle
In Dusseldorf, the German telecommunications and engineering group, Mannesmann,has formally presented its defence against the 135bn euro (£85bn) bid from the British mobile phone company Vodafone Airtouch.

It argues that Vodafone's bid grossly undervalues Mannesmann.

It has told its shareholders to "throw the Vodafone offer in the bin" and plans to float its internet arm to fend off the world's biggest hostile takeover bid.

Culture clash

Behind the detailed arguments, is a battle which strikes at the heart of Germany's consensual business model.


Chris Gent: Vodaphone's flamboyant boss Chris Gent: Vodafone's flamboyant boss
The German Chancellor, Gerhard Schroeder, has said hostile takeovers damage corporate culture.

Chris Gent, the flamboyant, cricket-loving Vodafone boss is seen by many in Germany as a corporate raider.

With his hostile take-over bid for Mannesmann, Mr Gent is attempting what no outsider has yet managed here.

Workers demonstrated against the takeover bid outside Mannesmann's Dusseldorf headquarters.

To them, Vodafone represents an aggressive Anglo-American business culture.


Unions: fears Vodaphone will destroy Mannesmann business culture Unions: Fears Vodafone will destroy Mannesmann business culture
They fear that they will lose their jobs and their influence, if Vodafone wins.

The unions, who in Germany must be consulted about all major company decisions, have the most to lose.

Claus Eilrich, spokesman of the engineering and electrical union, IG Metall, says that Vodafone threatens the consensual business culture which has been the key to Mannesmann's success.

"In principle, we've nothing against foreign companies taking stakes in German firms," he pointed out.

"What we don't like, and what we fear from Vodafone's actions, is that the business culture which has been developed over years at Mannesmann - which takes account of the interests of workers as well as shareholders - will be destroyed by a Vodafone take-over."

German in name only


Mannesmann: Biggest mobile company in Germany Mannesmann: Biggest mobile company in Germany
Mannesmann is the biggest mobile phone company in Germany, and one of the country's most successful businesses.

Although German in name, 60% of Mannesmann's shares are held by overseas investors.

In the global economy, such go-ahead, high-growth companies are an attractive target for foreign predators.

Professor Klandt of the European Business School in Mainz says most of Germany's business community still see hostile take-overs as socially unacceptable.

" We potentially will have a problem in this area. Many German managers will not be very happy. I think it's part of the game and it's not possible to avoid this kind of behaviour," he says.

Increasingly, the new generation of business leaders are questioning the old way of doing business.

Germany's consensual industrial model has brought job security and stability.



I think what they are missing is the gut feeling its worth taking a risk in order to do a good deal
Hugh Herring, Business Analyst
Critics say it discourages the risk-taking needed for successful entrepreneurship.

Hugh Herring is a business analyst for the British Chamber of Commerce in Germany.

"Its more bureaucratic. Decisions are taken by many people as opposed to a few people. They are looking for consensus - whether or not to do something. I think what they are missing is the gut feeling its worth taking a risk in order to do a good dea," he says.

The pressure of change is mounting. Gerhard Schroeder, despite his protestations against hostile take-overs, appears to be encouraging change.

The German government, for instance, has proposed a tax reform which would allow banks and other investors to sell their stakes in companies tax free.

The change slipped through almost unnoticed among a raft of tax measures.

Analysts say that this reform could trigger the biggest shake-up in corporate ownership for decades, bringing with it a flood of foreign investment.

Public battle


Mannesmann and Vodaphone slug it out in public Mannesmann and Vodafone slug it out in public
In newspaper adverts, and in investor briefings around the world, Vodafone and Mannesmann have been publicly slugging it out, in their battle to win over shareholders.

Such high-profile take-over campaigns are a novelty in Germany.

Mannesmann has shown that, when their interests are threatened, Germany's business leaders are increasingly willing to adopt Anglo-American business values.

Klaus Esser, Mannesmann's chairman acknowledges this way of thinking.

" I do not see a difference between a British or a European or German or Italian approach. I think that we may have had in earlier times, national differences in doing business, " he says.


Klaus Esser:Mannesmann's chairman is under pressure Klaus Esser: Mannesmann's chairman is under pressure
"We are doing business these days for the benefit of shareholders."

The Anglo-American way is still seen by most here as too aggressive.

But German businesses cannot survive in isolation.

In the long-term, accepting hostile take-overs may be the price Germany has to pay to stay competitive in the global economy.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
BBC RADIO NEWS
BBC ONE TV NEWS
WORLD NEWS SUMMARY
PROGRAMMES GUIDE

See also:
10 Jan 00 |  Business
Mannesmann claims "mislead" shareholders
28 Nov 99 |  Business
Mannesmann rejects Vodafone offer
24 Nov 99 |  Business
Europe's level playing field?
19 Nov 99 |  The Company File
The rapid rise of Vodafone
21 Dec 99 |  Business
Vodafone's Christmas Eve bid
19 Nov 99 |  The Company File
Vodafone's £79bn merger bid

Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
Links to other Business stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Business stories