Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point
On Air
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Thursday, January 7, 1999 Published at 09:38 GMT


Atchoo! But is it a cold or the flu?

The flu virus shown here is markedly different from a cold virus

It's that time of year again and you're feeling lousy.

The symptoms? A blocked nose, sore throat, constant coughing and the shivers. Surely it can mean only one thing - you've got the flu.

Not necessarily, say the doctors. In fact the chances are you've come down with something far less menacing - a common cold.

All too often the two very similar, yet very separate, illnesses are confused as the same. Specifically, cold victims tend to overstate their ailment by claiming they've been struck down by the flu.

To an extent, they can be forgiven, says Professor Ron Eccles of Cardiff's Common Cold Centre.


[ image: The elderly are most at risk from flu]
The elderly are most at risk from flu
"I'm not surprised people tend to get them mixed up. It's impossible for the average person to separate a severe cold from a mild flu," he says. "They are both generally referred to as 'flu-like illnesses'."

But he agrees victims often plump for the more drastic option because it "tends to sound more serious" and generate "more sympathy".

"Undoubtedly people tend to tell the boss they've got flu when they only have a cold. It sounds better if they want time off work.

"But not everything that causes red spots on the skin is chicken pox."

Key symptoms

Both are caused by viruses, says Prof Eccles, but these are as "different as a cat from a dog".

Common cold symptoms are:

  • A scratchy, sore throat
  • A blocked or runny nose
  • A cough

Whereas common flu symptoms include:

  • Spells of high fever (hovering above 101°F) and chilliness
  • Severe muscle aches and pains
  • Followed later by the traditional cold symptoms
    (Flu also tends to have a more sudden on-set)

Both tend to last for about five or six days in a normally healthy person, and are transmitted in similar ways - cough, sneezing and fingers made dirty from being poked in the nose and eyes.

Killer virus

The effects of flu can also be far more serious. It can cause pneumonia and kill its victims.

"Historically, influenza has killed far more people than any other viral disease, including the likes of the black death," said Prof Eccles.

And it's not just the elderly and young babies who are at risk, he says, pointing out that many of the 20 million killed in the 1919 flu epidemic were young men and women.

Vaccine available

More severe it may be but the flu does have one advantage. There is a vaccine against flu but not for the common cold.

Colds are caused by the huge family of viruses called rhinoviruses. With more than 80 different constantly mutating rhinoviruses, vaccination is impossible.

And while we do tend to build up our own immunities, it's impossible to develop the same level of immunity against a cold as flu, says Prof Eccles. That's what makes it so common.



Advanced options | Search tips




Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©


Internet Links


The Common Cold Centre, Univeristy of Wales, Cardiff


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.




In this section

Europe's new power struggle

Cronyism: The new sleaze

Sledging: The classic summer sport

Stylites: Climb a tree and stay there for 36 years

A history lesson for Hague?

Six hats: Edward de Bono's strange lesson

Refugee: today's playground insult?

The Gabba: Great Aussie Batting & Bowling Again?

Chucking: Why the fuss?