![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Tuesday, December 8, 1998 Published at 02:54 GMT UK Politics Gummer - why I called beef safe ![]() John Gummer with his daughter Cordelia in 1990 Former Tory minister John Gummer will tell the BSE inquiry he described British beef as "perfectly safe" because he was happy for his children to eat it. As Conservative agriculture minister, Mr Gummer achieved notoriety in 1990 by feeding a hamburger to his six-year-old daughter Cordelia.
"In matters as important as these it is essential to have a personal benchmark to be applied to decisions wherever appropriate. "In such circumstances I applied the test, 'Would I be entirely happy for my children to eat this?' "That seemed to me to be the proper question for a non-expert to ask when assessing the views of experts."
Like Stephen Dorrell and William Waldegrave last week, Mr Gummer said he acted in line with best scientific advice available at the time. But he admits to having to scale back plans for work on BSE in 1989 in the face of Treasury pressure. He says: "The chief secretary [to the Treasury] questioned the realism of the bids on BSE and salmonella, suggesting that they assumed a higher incidence of reported cases than experience suggested. "I replied that there were real fears of risks to public safety on these issues. "Recent laboratory work had indicated that BSE might be transmitted from one animal to another which had raised public concern in spite of the fact that there was no evidence that BSE could be transmitted to humans. "MAFF did agree to reduce the bid for salmonella and BSE related funding. If I had thought that these concessions would have adversely affected MAFF's ability to deal with BSE, I would not have made them. "While I was always conscious of the public health position, I also considered it essential to keep a tight hold on rationality." Mr Gummer insisted that throughout his time at the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, he put people before other considerations. "My first principle as minister at MAFF was that the customer and the consumer came first. "I re-organised ministerial responsibilities so that I made a clear division between consumer interests and the food, farming and fishery industries. "This was not in relation to BSE alone - this was in relation to food safety in general. With regards to BSE the government had three objectives - to protect the public from any possible risks; to identify the nature and cause of the disease and to establish the scope of its transmissibility; to aim to eradicate the disease and to prevent its recurrence." |
UK Politics Contents
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||