Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point
On Air
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Thursday, December 3, 1998 Published at 15:01 GMT


Swiss schools move to performance-related pay

Swiss teachers earn twice an English teacher's income

As the government announces details of its plans to reform teachers' pay and conditions, BBC Education Correspondent Mike Baker visits Zurich to compare the experiences of teachers in Switzerland with those in England.

While teachers in England prepare for the introduction of performance-related pay, teachers in Switzerland are facing a similar linking of pay to results.


[ image: Mike Baker visits Zurich and finds teachers facing performance-related pay]
Mike Baker visits Zurich and finds teachers facing performance-related pay
But the starting points for the two teaching professions are very different - in terms of pay, status and the numbers of young people wanting to enter teaching.

Teachers in Switzerland with 10 years experience can expect to earn around £46,000 a year, double the amount their counterparts in England will be paid.

The social status of teachers is also considered to be high and, without a national curriculum or headteachers, Swiss teachers exercise considerable independence in the classroom.


[ image: Zurich's education minister wants to sack bad teachers]
Zurich's education minister wants to sack bad teachers
However there are plans to link teachers' pay with performance, with regular inspections in classrooms to assess how teachers are providing lessons.

The education minister in the canton of Zurich, Ernt Buschor, says that good teachers should be rewarded and bad teachers should be given training or removed from teaching altogether.

But the promise to reward all successful teachers has been queried by union leaders, who ask whether there is a budget available to provide extra money for all teachers. Instead they anticipate that overall spending on teaching will be driven down by linking pay to performance.

While the threat of union action against performance-related pay in England comes against a background of a shortage of recruits into teaching, education authorities in Switzerland will be able to push ahead with reforms in the knowledge that there is no lack of applications from young people wanting to enter teacher training.



Advanced options | Search tips




Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©



Relevant Stories

24 Nov 98 | Queen Speech
'Far-reaching reform' for teachers

16 Jun 98 | Features
Pity the poor teachers?





Internet Links


Department for Education and Employment


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.




In this section

Teachers to refuse 10% rise

Merit pay for best teachers

Mixed response to pay proposals

How performance would be assessed

Performance pay: Head to head

Peace breaks out in performance pay dispute

Warning over teachers' performance pay

Performance pay moves a step nearer

How teachers can earn £35,000+

Heads snub Blair over merit pay

Teachers vote to strike if pay talks fail

Pay promise for deputy heads

Teachers vote on industrial action

Union backs dialogue over teachers' pay

Concession on pay reforms

Pay: What the fuss is about

Teachers reject £1bn pay package

Government on collision course with teachers

Teachers back industrial action

Pay plan 'will not be imposed'

Warning over teachers' pay

Performance pay 'unmanageable'

Performance pay 'will not mean red tape'

Heads say performance pay is unrealistic

Ballot demanded for teachers' performance pay

Teachers 'reject payment by results'

Performance pay 'doomed to fail'

Teachers 'on the way to higher pay'

Teachers threaten appraisal boycott