Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point
On Air
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help
Wednesday, November 25, 1998 Published at 15:29 GMT


Talking Point


Should Pinochet now be extradited?

After weeks of speculation the UK's highest court the House of Lords has decided General Pinochet does not hold diplomatic immunity and can face extradition proceedings to Spain.

Three out of five Law Lords overturned a ruling by the High Court that the former Chilean dictator is immune from prosecution for crimes against humanity allegedly committed when he was head of state.

The general must now appear before Bow Street Magistrates' Court in London next week, when Home Secretary Jack Straw will decide whether extradition proceedings can go ahead.

If Mr Straw gets the extradition wheels turning, the process is expected to be long and tortuous.

Do you agree that Pinochet should be extradited?

Pinochet supporters are stunned by the decision. Former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher said that the "old, frail and sick" General Pinochet should be released and allowed to return to Chile.

His son, Sede Fundacion Pinochet said it was a political and facist judgement.

However the ruling was greeted by cheers of celebration from protestors who had been keeping a vigil outside the Grovelands Priory Hospital in north London, where General Pinochet is under arrest while recuperating from a back operation.

Carlos Slepoy, a prominent human rights lawyer said, "it is an irreversible step towards the prosecution of crimes against humanity".

What do you think?

Should Pinochet now be extradited?


Your reaction in full





Advanced options | Search tips




Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©



  Your reaction in full







Live Talking Points

Should antibiotics be banned in animal feed?

Are ramblers 'scum of the earth'?

Has the UN Declaration of Human Rights been a success?

Is cricket corrupt?

Does the European Union work?

Should scientists clone body parts?

Will the Lockerbie suspects get a fair deal from Western justice?





Previous Talking Points

Is Carol Vorderman worth £5m?

Do you want your taxes set in Europe?

Can we trust weather forecasters?

Are you sick of Christmas already?

Are beauty contests outdated?

Is the British press xenophobic?

Should Pinochet now be extradited?

Pinochet's extradition - the case in favour