Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point
On Air
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Friday, November 6, 1998 Published at 02:30 GMT


NHS 'should provide patches and gum'

Smoking kills one-fifth of all Britons, the doctors say

Nicotine replacement therapy should be provided on the NHS, leading doctors have claimed.

They say that although the treatment appears expensive in the short term, nicotine replacement therapy is a useful aid to giving up smoking.

It proves cost-effective because it is not a life-long treatment and can lead to a longer life, they said.

The therapy consists of administering nicotine in a variety of ways, including patches, chewing gum and sprays.

Most people who use it give up after about a month if it works for them.

'Quitting a priority'

Professor Godfrey Fowler, Emeritus Professor of General Practice at Oxford University and Dr Liam Smeeth, a GP at the department of primary care at London's Royal Free Hospital, made the claims in the British Medical Journal.

Professor Fowler is an ex-smoker who has advised the Department of Health's scientific committee on smoking policy.

He said he was interested in the issue because, although it was a long time ago, he remembered well the difficulty of giving up.

The doctors said the government's public health goals made reducing the number of smokers a priority.

"The World Health Organisation has identified smoking as the single most important preventable cause of death in Europe," they write.

They add, however, that "stopping smoking is difficult" and it is usually insufficient to simply advise someone to stop.

Limited power

Professor Fowler said: "A GP is denied something which he can offer people to help them, he is denied prescribing that for them on the health service.

"He isn't denied the right to give people tablets to help them sleep, tablets to deal with pain, even tablets to help them lose weight.

"But he isn't allowed the right to prescribe something to help them stop smoking."


[ image: Quitting can be hell]
Quitting can be hell
The doctors conducted a review of 47 trials of nicotine replacement therapy, involving 23,000 patients.

They found that the products doubled the success rate for those trying to give up smoking.

Professor Fowler said given the evidence, the therapy should be available on the NHS, because at the moment cost was a deterrent.

"I know people say, 'well, if you can afford to smoke you can afford to buy patches'," he said.

"But we don't apply that in other areas of health care - people who can afford to drink and run into alcohol problems get their care on the health service.

"If people over-eat they can get treatment, and now they're even thinking of giving people Viagra on the health service.

"Smoking kills one in five people in this country. It seems extraordinary that something that helps with that is not available on the NHS."

'Kick-start'

Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) campaigns to make quitting smoking easier.

A spokeswoman said the group was generally supportive of the proposals, adding that the therapy is most effective when combined with GP support.

"Nicotine replacement therapy should be more widely available so people can get access to it if they want it," she said.

But ASH would not want to see the therapy provided on the NHS for too long.

She suggested that patients should get the first couple of weeks' treatment free and after that "kick-start" they could pay for their own treatment.

The government is due to publish a White Paper on smoking by Christmas, and the Department of Health declined to comment until then.





Advanced options | Search tips




Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©



Relevant Stories

06 Oct 98 | Health
Beating the smoking blues

29 Sep 98 | Health
Giving up smoking helps at any age

27 Jul 98 | Health
Penis shock tactics 'could cut smoking'

31 May 98 | Latest News
Parents urged to quit smoking





Internet Links


ASH - Action on Smoking and Health

British Medical Journal

Department of Health


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.




In this section

Smoker drops discrimination claim

Young smokers risk greater genetic damage

Anti-depressants beat the craving

£10m lung cancer blitz

Tobacco firms 'hid safer cigarettes'

Cancer sufferers abandon tobacco case

Cigarettes: a complex cocktail of chemicals

High Court rules against tobacco claimants

Alert over herbal cigarettes

Smokers advised to combine therapies

Health coalition begins anti-smoking crusade

From Sci/Tech
Smoking cities

Dobson launches tobacco crusade

Mixed reaction to tobacco White Paper

Public say passive smoking is dangerous

Higher death risk for women smokers

Government targets young smokers

Controversy on passive smoking measures

Nicotine patches to be free on the NHS

From UK Politics
Controversial ban among tobacco controls

Tobacco tax hike prompts smuggling warning

'Stop tobacco firms targeting children'