Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point
On Air
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Monday, October 26, 1998 Published at 16:23 GMT


CJD families condemn health service

Stephen Churchill: Family "kept in the dark"

Relatives of some of those who died from the human form of "mad cow" disease are calling for better care for victims.


The BBC's Margaret Gilmore reports on one of the families affected by the human form of BSE
Members of 11 families have been telling the BSE inquiry how their relatives died and why they felt let down by a health service that knew little about the disease.

Speaking at a news conference, Dorothy Churchill, the mother of a CJD victim said she thought the standard of health care seemed "very patchy".


Stephen's mother, Dorothy, tells Radio 5 Live about her son's treatment
"I would say the vast amount [of families] have found shortcomings in the care and understanding and that's what we have to get right out for the future. There's going to more victims ... but so far the system isn't working."

She added: "It depends on your postcode whether you get good care for human BSE."

Support group

Mrs Churchill and her husband David set up the Human BSE Support Group to offer advice and information to other victims' families after the death of their 19-year-old son Stephen.

Mr Churchill said the family was kept in the dark about Stephen's condition.

"The only clue that we received was when we saw our son's brain biopsy operating notes and it had in the top right-hand corner 'reason for operation' and it had 'CJD?'" he said.


Victim's father David Churchill describes the moment he discovered his son's diagnosis
He said there was little information available at the time and they relied on the media for details.

It emerged that several relatives had carried out their own research in the quest for information.

Stephen's sister, Dr Helen Churchill, who was a dental student when her brother fell ill, told the inquiry she had spent many evenings in her college medical library researching neurological disorders.

And Gerard Callaghan, whose brother Maurice died from nvCJD, said that his family read up on neurological illnesses to find out what was causing Maurice's rapid deterioration.

But at a news conference later he said he was satisfied with the care his brother received.

"Maybe we were lucky but it shouldn't be a question of luck," he said.

Reliving the tragedy

Frances Hall, from Durham, was one of several distraught relatives giving evidence.

She talked about her son, Peter, who died on 8 February 1996, just before his 21st birthday.


BBC Environment Correspondent Richard Wilson discusses the families' anger and disappointment
Peter, who had been a vegetarian since the age of 15, fell ill shortly after he began a university degree. Mrs Hall said: "He just appeared apathetic, he lost interest in his appearance, before that he had been a bundle of energy."

At first, Peter's doctor diagnosed depression but his condition continued to deteriorate and he was eventually taken into hospital.

"It was obvious this was a serious condition, and that's when I first asked about CJD," she said.

Mrs Hall added that she had stopped buying beef five years before Peter's illness, when BSE in cattle first hit the headlines.

The inquiry resumes on Tuesday. It will publish its final report next June.



Advanced options | Search tips




Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©



Relevant Stories

26 Oct 98 | BSE
CJD families call for better care





Internet Links


The BSE Inquiry

Witness statements to the inquiry

Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.




In this section

Beef on bone 'still a risk'

'Bring back the beef'

Health expert reassures over CJD spread

Minister ignored officials

Beef on bone risk 'diminished'

Clarke hits back at BSE claims

Medical officer tells of BSE secrecy

Former medical boss was 'kept in the dark'

Consumer groups attack 'BSE secrecy'

CJD families' plea on care

Ministry 'unscientific' over BSE

Former chief vet holds back BSE tape

BSE: the cattle killer

Public 'misled over BSE'