BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh
BBCi CATEGORIES   TV   RADIO   COMMUNICATE   WHERE I LIVE   INDEX    SEARCH 

BBC NEWS
 You are in:  UK Politics
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Interviews 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 


Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

SERVICES 
Friday, 10 May, 2002, 11:17 GMT 12:17 UK
'Byers is no liar' - Cook
Transport Secretary Stephen Byers surveys Newcastle during a visit to regeneration projects on Tyneside
Mr Byers said he did not mislead Parliament
Commons leader Robin Cook has mounted a staunch defence of beleaguered Transport Secretary Stephen Byers, insisting: "He is not a liar".

Mr Cook said there was "no sleaze" attached to Mr Byers, stressing that his colleague had been "completely open" and "truthful" about the Martin Sixsmith affair.


There has not been the slightest suggestion of any sleaze whatsoever attached to Stephen Byers - he is not lying

Robin Cook

The Commons leader waded in to defend the transport secretary as the Conservative Party continued its call for an urgent debate about his future.

Tory leader Iain Duncan Smith has written to Prime Minister Tony Blair urging him to give the Opposition space next Tuesday to debate a "motion of censure" - effectively a vote of no confidence - against Mr Byers.

Demands for a debate were heightened by Mr Byers' denial on Thursday that he had misled Parliament over the resignation of transport communications' director Martin Sixsmith.

Byers is 'believed'

If Mr Duncan Smith's appeal is rejected, the motion is likely to be discussed in nine days' time when the Tories have Commons time for an Opposition-initiated debate.

But the Liberal Democrats have indicated that the spotlight might fall again on Mr Byers even sooner, if they decide to make him the subject of a debate in their time next Wednesday.

Mr Cook told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "There is no suggestion here, whatsoever, that Stephen Byers either misled the House or knowingly misled the House and indeed, why should he?"

Commons leader Robin Cook
Mr Cook dismissed the row as 'Westminster gossip'

He continued: "I was with many people yesterday who believe entirely that Stephen Byers has been completely open and has been truthful.

"The reception that he got on our benches within the House of Commons demonstrates that complete faith in him.

"There is absolutely no dissent over this, partly because we know Stephen Byers's is doing a very good job and he is trying to clear up the enormous mess he inherited from the botched privatisation of the rail industry and that is what really matters to the constituents."

'Say sorry'

Mr Cook added: "There has not been the slightest suggestion of any sleaze whatsoever attached to Stephen Byers - he is not lying."


I don't think we have had a principled resignation since Lord Carrington in 1982

Martin Bell
But former Northern Ireland Secretary Mo Mowlam was reported to have added her voice to calls for Mr Byers' resignation.

At an event to promote her memoirs, she is reported by The Times to have said there had been "too many cock-ups" in the transport department and Mr Byers "ought to do the right thing".

Martin Bell, the Independent former MP who swept to office on an anti-sleaze ticket, said the government would benefit from saying sorry once in a while.

"I don't think we have had a principled resignation since Lord Carrington in 1982," he told Today.

The transport secretary has been accused of misleading MPs by saying Mr Sixsmith had resigned when this was not the case.

'Go now'

During stormy Commons scenes on Thursday, Mr Byers said: "I have not misled the House as some have alleged - all of my statements to the House have been based on the information available to me.

Martin Sixsmith
Martin Sixsmith has been given a £200,000 pay off
"That is precisely why the agreed statement with Mr Sixsmith explicitly says that any misunderstanding over his resignation was in good faith."

On Friday, Mr Byers remained defiant about his position, insisting during a visit to regeneration projects on Tyneside that he had nothing further to add.

Shadow transport secretary Theresa May told MPs that if Mr Byers had "a shred of decency left he would go and go now".

Meanwhile the Liberal Democrat's Don Foster insisted that Mr Byers "did mislead Parliament".

The row stems initially from an e-mail sent by the then transport spin doctor Jo Moore suggesting bad news could be "buried" after the 11 September attacks.

Row

It then escalated after reports that Mr Sixsmith had e-mailed Ms Moore to warn her not to announce bad news on the day of Princess Margaret's funeral.

It was later announced that both Ms Moore and Mr Sixsmith had resigned.

The transport secretary announced both resignations on 15 February and made a Commons statement on the issue 11 days later.

But Mr Sixsmith insisted he had not resigned.

The row was sparked again on Tuesday when the transport department acknowledged Mr Sixsmith had been telling the truth.

 WATCH/LISTEN
 ON THIS STORY
Robin Cook, Commons leader
"I'm totally in favour of honest politics, any minister who knowingly misleads parliament would have to go"
The BBC's Robert Orchard
"Yet again the Transport Secretary was forced to fight for his political survival"
Transport Secretary Stephen Byers
"I have not misled the House"
Shadow Transport Secretary Theresa May
"We have heard no remorse, no regret and no glimmer of an apology"
 VOTE RESULTS
Should Stephen Byers resign?

Yes
 88.51% 

No
 11.49% 

11166 Votes Cast

Results are indicative and may not reflect public opinion


BBC News Online political correspondent Nick Assinder watches as Stephen Byers faces yet more calls for his resignation.
Can Byers cling on?


Key stories

Background

Main players

TALKING POINT
See also:

10 May 02 | UK Politics
Sixsmith: Byers 'tore up' agreement
09 May 02 | UK Politics
The things Byers said
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK Politics stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK Politics stories